The Most Patriotic Thing You Can Do

Re:The Most Patriotic Thing You Can Do by rgarcia on Monday September 19, 2011 @05:49PM (#3015348)

I think there's an argument to be made that even the industries you mention improve the lives of people in society. Assuming (1) all gambling/cigarette/fast food transactions are voluntary on both sides, and (2) people act rationally, then any money that you spend is done because you perceive the good you receive to be worth more than the money you spend on it.

One counterargument in the case of addictive drugs or "vices" is that transactions aren't completely voluntary, since you are acting under the influence. In gambling you might also not act rationally. Nevertheless these are still a subset of all transactions, and taking your argument to the extreme of outlawing these industries would prevent a decent number of society-bettering transactions from taking place.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:The Most Patriotic Thing You Can Do by Hisoka on Monday September 19, 2011 @06:23PM (#3015462)

I never suggested outlawing any industries. Just pointing out the flaws in his post.

Our modern society is set up so that it takes our primal urges to the extreme, making it BAD for the individual, but probably good for the overall economy. Our choices are hardly rational because we don't understand how our genes and primal urges work subconsciously. That's why men cheat, do drugs, and self sabotage ourselves.

[ Parent | on HN ]