News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube ranks “wholesome and funny” comments higher? by paulpauper on Monday January 31, 2022 @02:44PM (#30153209)
youtube comments are so heavily censored it's crazy. Tons of ghosting going on.
Re:YouTube ranks “wholesome and funny” comments higher? by thirteenfingers on Monday January 31, 2022 @03:04PM (#30153486)
Indeed. Just last week there was a whole thread here on HN about the problems with toxicity detectors: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30066720 I'm not sure if this is the system youtube is using, but it would certainly align with my experience where people have left innocuous comments on my videos that disappear a couple hours later - comments such as "this music is beautiful, damn" where the only thing I can think of, short of that user's entire account getting deactivated, is that the word "damn" tripped some sort of toxicity flag.

I hate bullies as much as the next person on HN, but I'm deeply unsettled by youtube's recent efforts in the direction of manufacturing consent.

Re:YouTube ranks “wholesome and funny” comments higher? by seattle_spring on Monday January 31, 2022 @03:14PM (#30153618)
What types of comments are being censored? A lot of people claim HN is heavily censored, but when you turn on "showdead" it reveals mostly truly vile and awful comments are the ones hidden.
Re:YouTube ranks “wholesome and funny” comments higher? by climb_stealth on Monday January 31, 2022 @04:12PM (#30154429)
Profanity seems to do it. Even in a positive context. I have had it happen recently where I added a comment but it never made it into the comments. There was no error.

There may have been the word shit in my comment. But it was polite and constructive. Meh. Makes me not want to bother and I don't.

Re:YouTube ranks “wholesome and funny” comments higher? by bliteben on Monday January 31, 2022 @03:13PM (#30153606)
I don't understand how they don't expect a first amendment case against them, they likely are discriminating against certain ethnicities, races, or localities in using algorithms to block / sort comments. It seems like at some point all automated moderation like this will have to be reviewable.

On the other hand it is nice that their comment section isn't as toxic as it once was.

Re:YouTube ranks “wholesome and funny” comments higher? by kube-system on Monday January 31, 2022 @04:08PM (#30154376)
Because the Constitution and the Bill of Rights are a governmental founding document and only apply to the government. Alphabet is not part of the government, and therefore, it does not apply.

Discrimination by companies toward the public is covered mainly by Civil Rights Act (or the Americans with Disabilities Act in the case of discrimination based on disability).

Re:YouTube ranks “wholesome and funny” comments higher? by bliteben on Monday January 31, 2022 @05:06PM (#30155262)
yeah yeah separate but equal
Re:YouTube ranks “wholesome and funny” comments higher? by TulliusCicero on Monday January 31, 2022 @04:12PM (#30154437)
A first amendment case based on what? They're not the government.
Re:YouTube ranks “wholesome and funny” comments higher? by bliteben on Monday January 31, 2022 @05:11PM (#30155347)
Employers can't discriminate based on any of these things and there is no right to be employed. This will keep coming up as the percent of speech that happens on monopolized platforms continues to increase.
Re:YouTube ranks “wholesome and funny” comments higher? by TulliusCicero on Monday January 31, 2022 @06:38PM (#30156448)
> Employers can't discriminate based on any of these things and there is no right to be employed.

Okay, but that's not the first amendment. That's the Civil Rights Act, IIRC. And I think it'd be difficult to prove discrimination in this case.

Re:YouTube ranks “wholesome and funny” comments higher? by fallingknife on Monday January 31, 2022 @03:45PM (#30154049)
There is no first amendment right to have your comment visible on Youtube. In fact, Youtube has the first amendment right to show whatever comments they want. They could even have fake accounts that post positive comments and upvotes, and charge users money for artificial engagement. Google executives could decide that they wanted to support literal Nazis, and promote their videos, add fake likes and engagements, and do the opposite to any opposing political views. This would all be perfectly legal.

We have restricted the constitutional rights of corporations in other cases e.g. utilities, though. And we can do it again.