News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Socrates on the blessing of being refuted by dfxm12 on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:42PM (#30152163)
I think the article is operating under the false assumption that most political discourse is meant to be a Socratic conversation. It's really not. Look at a political debate, or a talking heads show on cable news. There is no truth that is sought out, no hypotheses to accept, no exploration of if a conclusion follows the premises logically. All there is, is persuasive sound bytes, with no deference paid to the truth and no refraining from the "false opinion concerning the subjects of the present conversation".

The media drives a lot of this with the format of their shows/political debates. I'm sure these sound bytes are better for ratings, but they are poor for getting to the bottom of a political platform and how that's really best for the general population.

Re:Socrates on the blessing of being refuted by marginalia_nu on Monday January 31, 2022 @06:35PM (#30156419)
This is not all that different from the Athens Socrates operated in. A significant portion of Plato's work portrays Socrates interrogating various forms of sophists, politicians, generals; the "talking heads" of his time.

Socrates was a notorious weirdo, a bit like the Richard Stallman of Athens.

Re:Socrates on the blessing of being refuted by more_corn on Monday January 31, 2022 @07:22PM (#30156914)
It is still possible to seek truth even if those arguing against you are seeking only political power. Some of my most satisfying conversations have been with Machiavellian powermongers. They have compelling arguments and finely honed tactics of persuasion. Our arguments come away in pieces and new ideas are constructed out of the wreckage. It is by disagreeing with someone that we get to explore the ideas we would never consider on our own. Some of my most novel ideas have come about by being refuted by others.
Re:Socrates on the blessing of being refuted by jhoechtl on Monday January 31, 2022 @04:00PM (#30154267)
> The media drives a lot of this with the format of their shows/political debates. I'm sure these sound bytes are better for ratings, but they are poor for getting to the bottom of a political platform and how that's really best for the general population.

I only developed a more informed sense to follow the political sphere like five years ago or so. This is so true, the media and their need for quotes makes so many debates into a farce. Politicians seem like being in front of a judge instead of a truth-seeking interviewer. Not that politicians are overly known for truth-seeking but there is a certain line between for a reporter being investigative and sensational.

Re:Socrates on the blessing of being refuted by beebmam on Monday January 31, 2022 @02:42PM (#30153177)
Public debate is performance for the audiences. Private debate can absolutely be like Socratic dialogue
Re:Socrates on the blessing of being refuted by pasabagi on Monday January 31, 2022 @03:43PM (#30154012)
I don't know what Socratic dialogues you've been reading, but if somebody started speaking like they were out of one near me, I'd probably report them for being a replicant.