News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by orangecat on Monday September 19, 2011 @11:15AM (#3013832)
Microsoft controlling what software you can run on Windows used to be the reductio ad absurdum I used to argue against the iOS model. Now Android is the only platform standing between us and a Right to Read world (http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html).
Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by megamark16 on Monday September 19, 2011 @11:39AM (#3013939)
Just until the day when it moves to the hardware level, where your hardware will refuse to run certain processes unless they are digitally signed. Good times.

See also "Intel Trusted Execution Technology": http://software.intel.com/en-us/articles/intel-trusted-execu...

Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by fhars on Monday September 19, 2011 @12:36PM (#3014199)
This is the one feature that Trusted Execution Technology (TXT) does not provide. We really wanted to have something like that for a security type appliance, but it is impossible. The only thing TXT provides is the ability to prove to a third party that you are running an unmodified version of the software endorsed by them, so they can avoid sending their valuable content to a device controlled by you. It doesn't help you to ensure that the device will only boot software endorsed by you (or anybody), only to prove what software is running to somebody else.

But one should probably be lucky that that functionality is missing...

Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by dexen on Monday September 19, 2011 @11:54AM (#3014002)
Things got quite close by now: mandatory driver signing in 64bit Windows Vista & 7. You need to select extra boot option to be able to load unsigned driver. Like the venerable ext2fsd: driver for ext2 & ext3 FS [1]. It won't work for Joe the Average User.

Terrorists win, game over.

[1] http://www.ext2fsd.com/

EDIT:

it's a clever move, limititing that requirement only to 64bit Windows. No need for one-time big switchover; the balance towards 64bit will shift gradually over time and before people raise enough opposition it may be too late for independet driver development.

We already know security based on centralized Certification Authorities did not work well for securing HTTPS.

Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by ReadEvalPost on Monday September 19, 2011 @01:08PM (#3014317)
Only allowing signed drivers to run in ring 0 by default makes a lot of sense though. The average user is way less likely to need ext2fsd and much more likely to install randommalwared.
Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by xpaulbettsx on Monday September 19, 2011 @04:57PM (#3015169)
For what it's worth, this wasn't to stop free software drivers, it was a stick to force IHVs to ship drivers that didn't suck, since they could no longer ship drivers that didn't pass WHQL testing.

The end result is a more stable system for consumers, but F/OSS got caught in the fallout.

If you as a F/OSS driver dev really want to avoid signatures, sign your driver using the test cert and run the following command in your installer:

    bcdedit -set testsigning on
Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by tomjen3 on Monday September 19, 2011 @11:21AM (#3013862)
Well, if you don't count Linux, the BSDs, webapps and even the venerable freedos (yes, somebody did clone DOS http://www.freedos.org/ and yes it runs the old DOS programs) I guess you are right.
Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by bergie on Monday September 19, 2011 @04:19PM (#3015056)
Linux will only help as long as there is hardware open enough that you can install it. With tablets and smartphones and their closed drivers this will be a disappearing opportunity in the Post-PC world.
Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by saturdaysaint on Monday September 19, 2011 @01:34PM (#3014412)
and OSX.
Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by notauser on Monday September 19, 2011 @02:24PM (#3014644)
OS X already has the app store, now it just needs the restrictive policy.

You might think it'll never come; well, people said the same things about Windows. In fact, they were far more outspokenly confident about Windows because Microsoft has historically been much less control-freakish than Apple.

Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by ebiester on Monday September 19, 2011 @11:20AM (#3013859)
If Microsoft were to shut down the other channels, that would be true. However, nothing stops you from making a traditional windows app. It just won't run with the Metro UI.
Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by tree_of_item on Monday September 19, 2011 @11:42AM (#3013951)
Which is barely a defense: Metro is the future of Windows applications and I doubt users will be very excited about their ability to install "traditional" apps.

I'm surprised that Microsoft beat Apple to locking down their desktop OS in the style of iOS, but in either case this is extremely disturbing.

Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by fpgeek on Monday September 19, 2011 @11:47AM (#3013979)
It's too early to call the desktop-lockdown race between Microsoft and Apple. Microsoft may be locking down a broader class of apps with their Metro restrictions, but Apple already has their locked-down desktop store up and running.
Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by r00fus on Monday September 19, 2011 @02:59PM (#3014804)
Perhaps, but Apple has no "Metro" lockdown - in fact the apps you sell on their storefront for the Mac are the same you can sell and market on your own (for now).

Software publishing freedom exists with equal footing to the locked-down storefront on the Mac.

This is not the case in Windows8. Microsoft will trumpet everything Metro-UI in their new release, and in order to play their game, you need to play their game.

Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by saturdaysaint on Monday September 19, 2011 @02:51PM (#3014770)
What would Apple's incentive be to do that? Both Apple and Microsoft have too much to lose if a big budget software maker (ie anyone selling stuff over $50) left their platform. Microsoft will never risk driving Electronic Arts into Google's arms, Apple will never risk sacrificing OSX's image as the "platform for creative people" (which would indeed happen if they lost Photoshop and ProTools). The %30 cut of app sales is a blip on both companies' balance sheets.
Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by kenjackson on Monday September 19, 2011 @11:50AM (#3013988)
I think its a positive development, across the board. The ability to better combat malware (no plugins is part of this too) will generally make these platforms safer.

If you really must distribute an app that needs to go outside of these walls non-metro apps are perfectly fine. You can accomplish a lot of what Metro apps can do today outside of Metro (at least from a look and feel perspective). And as Apple has noted, there is the web too.

I personally like the fact that you now have a CHOICE of where you get your apps. A curated app store, the old wild west of native apps, or the web. Choice is good.

Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by alex_c on Monday September 19, 2011 @12:04PM (#3014048)
How are you spinning this to be about choice? You're conflating the app type with the distribution channel.

I agree that curated native app stores are generally great. Users get higher quality apps with great discoverability, developers get a great distribution channel, and let's not forget, the platform owner gets 30%.

It's hard to argue that this is about choice of where you get your apps, though.

Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by slowpoke on Monday September 19, 2011 @05:27PM (#3015257)
If by "higher quality apps" you mean loads and loads of thinly disguised ad- and spyware, as well as generally useless crap, then yes, curated native app stores are "great".

I'd say the density of pure and utter crapware has never been higher than in the various app stores.

While a unified distribution method is generally a good idea for various reasons (see package managers), the whole app store concept runs completely contrary to those.

It's not about choice, it's about control.

It's not about security, it's about locking down the system.

It's not about convenience for the user, it's about completely undeserved profit for the platform owner.

It's not about helping the developers, it's about forcing them to play by someone else's (highly arbitrary) rules.

I'm frankly scared about this entire development. Call me paranoid all you want, but we're heading with full speed to some sort of digital 1984 if it goes on anything like this.

Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by alex_c on Monday September 19, 2011 @07:41PM (#3015653)
> If by "higher quality apps" you mean loads and loads of thinly disguised ad- and spyware, as well as generally useless crap, then yes, curated native app stores are "great". > I'd say the density of pure and utter crapware has never been higher than in the various app stores.

Compared to what? Download.com? Tucows? Every app put on the internet, ever? There are lots of useless and borderline malicious apps on the existing mobile app stores (and a handful of downright malicious apps), but I'm far from convinced that it's in any way worse than what we've had so far on the desktop. All the "browser toolbar" apps out there, by themselves, are enough to make app stores look good.

And having a unified place where you know you can get the official version of any app, along with any updates, and from where you can painlessly re-install all your apps when you get a new machine, cannot possibly be a bad thing.

What do developers get for that 30% cut? In Apple's case, they get access to a huge userbase who has already entered their credit card into the system and just need to press "buy"; they get access to payment processing, currency conversion, and storefront internationalization, close to world-wide, without lifting a finger. Is 30% "fair"? Probably not - it's probably a bit high for small developers, and larger developers may prefer to opt out and solve all those challenges for themselves, for much cheaper. (edit: for desktop Mac apps, they can. The fact that some developers choose to sell their Mac apps through the App Store suggests the 30% is worth it for those developers. It's important that those developers still have the choice to sell their desktop apps through other channels - so far, anyway).

Yes, it's ultimately about control, and about that 30% commission. I did say it's less choice, not more. But you can't say there are no benefits at all, to both users or developers.

Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by AndrewDucker on Monday September 19, 2011 @12:06PM (#3014059)
Except that the ARM tablets will only run Metro apps.

Which means that if you have one of them then you have no choice at all.

Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by crenshaw on Monday September 19, 2011 @12:19PM (#3014116)
Has that been stated or confirmed?
Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by isani on Monday September 19, 2011 @12:34PM (#3014191)
"All apps for ARM are going to come through the Store, which means they’re going to be Metro Apps."

– Windows president Steven Sinofsky http://www.pcpro.co.uk/blogs/2011/09/13/windows-8-on-arm/

Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by crenshaw on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @12:49AM (#3016333)
Mary Jo Foley just came out and said the exact opposite now:

http://www.zdnet.com/blog/microsoft/microsoft-desktop-apps-w...

Sinofsky is of course the person to listen to, but I'm concerned that wires aren't crossing correctly -- and I'm not sure from where.

Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by crenshaw on Monday September 19, 2011 @12:40PM (#3014215)
Thanks. That is definitive.
Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by AndrewDucker on Monday September 19, 2011 @12:23PM (#3014136)
They've said that x86 apps will not work on ARM:

http://www.crn.com/news/applications-os/231601663/microsoft-...

Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by crenshaw on Monday September 19, 2011 @12:24PM (#3014142)
OK. And Windows on ARM won't run Amiga apps either. You and I both know that's not really related to what the poster stated. The poster said that ARM will only run Metro apps. You can not run x86 apps and still run non-Metro apps. And you can run x86 apps, but not run non-Metro apps. It's a completely orthogonal statement.
Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by AndrewDucker on Monday September 19, 2011 @12:44PM (#3014227)
I took it as saying there were two types of apps - Win32 x86 apps and Metro apps, and that ARM would only run one of them.

If he'd said "ARM will not run x86 apps, so you'll need to recompile" then that would have been different, but without any kind of assurance there it sounded very much like they were ruling out running any existing apps on ARM tablets.

Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by tomjen3 on Monday September 19, 2011 @02:04PM (#3014547)
Actually there is no good reason Microsoft didn't write an X86 virtual machine so that their tablets could run the old programs.

The instructions set is obviously different, but Android does that with Java (on an ARM processor too) and Microsoft has enough smart people who could make sure that the performance would be great.

Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by rsynnott on Monday September 19, 2011 @04:22PM (#3015065)
> Actually there is no good reason Microsoft didn't write an X86 virtual machine so that their tablets could run the old programs.

There is. You'd be looking at something very much like Apple Rosetta. Now, the first Intel Macs were substantially faster than the PPC Macs that most people had at the time, but even then Rosetta felt painful. All current and near-future ARM chips will be slower than most current Intel chips; you'd expect it to be even more painful. Worse, for lightweight apps it would involve far more CPU usage, which would hurt battery life. People wouldn't _care_ that their Windows 8 tablet was getting two hours battery life while their friend's iPad was getting 10 because they were running a legacy app which was hogging the processor doing instruction translation; they'd just blame Microsoft.

The case of Java is a little different; both Dalvik and JVM are designed to be JIT compiled relatively efficiently to multiple common architectures. Architectures like x86 and PPC are generally _not_, and things like Rosetta suffer as a result.

Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by saturdaysaint on Monday September 19, 2011 @03:00PM (#3014808)
Confusion is bad. It's a shame that Windows' highest cachet titles (pro creative software, big budget games, etc.) won't be Metro.
Re:Only enterprise and developers can bypass Windows Store f... by ryannielsen on Monday September 19, 2011 @05:28PM (#3015261)
Why not? There's nothing that prohibits them from being Metro, right? If not, then why wouldn't developers of those apps eventually adopt Metro? If Metro provides the best customer experience and becomes associated with "high quality" apps, I bet they'll make the move to Metro.

(Note: I don't expect major vendors will adopt Metro the second Windows 8 ships, as they'll want to continue shipping titles with support for at least 7 for quite some time.)