News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What is FORGE? by ZeroGravitas on Sunday January 30, 2022 @10:20AM (#30137899)
Fracking for geothermal basically.

Probably better than fracking for fossil fuels, for multiple reasons, but still a mildly ironic repurposing of the tech.

Re:What is FORGE? by fghorow on Sunday January 30, 2022 @10:37AM (#30138031)
Regarding "repurposing". You have it backwards. Hydraulic fracturing for geothermal -- then known as Hot Dry Rock, but now called EGS -- has been around in practice since (at least) the 1970s [1]. It's basically the creation of permeable pathways for water to flow through in order to mine the heat.

"Fracking" for natural gas took off in 2000's. The essence of the process is the same -- creation of permeable pathways. But many of the more controversial practices (high volume flow, slickwater, heavy use of biocides) are avoided by EGS projects specifically for environmental reasons.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hot_dry_rock_geothermal_energy

Re:What is FORGE? by beerandt on Sunday January 30, 2022 @06:49PM (#30142572)
No- fracking became a known cause du jour in the 2000s, and it benefited from higher oil prices plus multiple advances in the various technologies and geology/ geophysical mapping.

But the technology goes back before the 1950s.

ETA: Wikipedia says 1947.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydraulic_fracturing

Re:What is FORGE? by conradev on Sunday January 30, 2022 @11:15AM (#30138415)
Mildly ironic and also a clever way to repurpose existing infrastructure and training
Re:What is FORGE? by Dangeranger on Sunday January 30, 2022 @11:38AM (#30138601)
EGS precedes fracking technology by decades.
Re:What is FORGE? by cgriswald on Sunday January 30, 2022 @02:34PM (#30140311)
The important point is that a lot of current infrastructure and expertise is in fracking, which can be repurposed for EGS, irrespective of which technology was technically first.
Re:What is FORGE? by ZeroGravitas on Sunday January 30, 2022 @12:18PM (#30138960)
Are you sure?

You mention the first test well in 1977 which is decades after it was originally used to extract gas.

Re:What is FORGE? by fghorow on Sunday January 30, 2022 @02:39PM (#30140360)
True.

But, until the practice became the mainstay of new shale gas production hydraulic fracturing was about as uncontroversial as drilling itself. (Yes, there are deliberate ironies in that statement.)

Geologically speaking (roughly), a gas or oil "play" involves source rocks (which are the locations where the hydrocarbons were deposited and matured) and traps (which are locations where the oil and gas migrated to in economically recoverable quantities). Oil and gas, being less dense than water, migrate upwards as buoyant fluids in the overlying rocks until they are trapped by impermeable layers. There are other styles of trap, but that gives you the gist of it.

Old style oil and gas plays exploited the traps. Fracking plays now exploit the (mostly shale) source rocks.

In my opinion, what caused the recent controversies are the sheer numbers of wells being drilled for fracking. In addition to the new locations where development takes place -- at least in recent memory in places like Pennsylvania -- there were also a larger number of accidents per unit time. Perhaps there was an element of less-experienced operators drilling and fracking wells that also increased the rate of accidents.

EGS geothermal plays fracture rocks, yes. (Heck, so do quarries for things like road metal.) But the resource value proposition is so weak compared to hydrocarbons that geothermal people realize they MUST do things right or they will be shut down. Hence, better casing designs -- leading to far fewer leaks -- and a reluctance to use nasty chemicals.

Everything is a tradeoff. Geothermal is not a fossil fuel. But it is not a panacea either.