News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to avoid layout shifts caused by web fonts by chrismorgan on Sunday January 30, 2022 @07:46AM (#30136691)
-apple-system and BlinkMacSystemFont are now both obsolete and covered by system-ui. Almost all of the named fonts in common font stacks are either now superfluous or not a good idea any more, causing more harm than they solve.

For sans-serif, I recommend at most three items: a web font, system-ui, and sans-serif. No more. I would note that system-ui is not necessarily sans-serif, but in practice it almost always is, and ui-sans-serif (along with ui-serif, ui-monospace and ui-rounded) is only implemented by Safari yet.

For serif, I recommend at most three items, possibly including one named font: a web font, Georgia, and serif. See, serif is probably a narrower serif (something like Times New Roman), but Georgia a wider one—they’re fairly different in character, so that it can be worth including if you’re doing so deliberately.

For monospace, I recommend at most four: a web font, ui-monospace (I wouldn’t, but some macOS people prefer it), Consolas, and monospace. I think Consolas is worth keeping in until Firefox updates its Windows default (https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=713680), because Courier New is that bad.

Most font stacks now are just cargo culting, and are mostly mildly harmful.

Re:How to avoid layout shifts caused by web fonts by thrdbndndn on Sunday January 30, 2022 @09:33AM (#30137505)
> I would note that system-ui is not necessarily sans-serif

And that's exactly where it causes problem [1].

https://infinnie.github.io/blog/2017/systemui.html

Re:How to avoid layout shifts caused by web fonts by chrismorgan on Sunday January 30, 2022 @06:54PM (#30142616)
Interesting, I hadn’t come across that particular issue, though it seems obvious now (I know about those ugly old fullwidth fonts). And I’m guessing that quite incidentally -apple-system and BlinkMacSystemFont are unlikely to be affected. I’ll need to reconsider my recommendation—though I will note that I’ve not generally used system-ui anyway, just considered it acceptable. I wonder if it’s time to lobby browsers to update their default sans-serif fonts, as they have updated their monospaces over the last few years (except for Firefox on Windows). The whole ui-sans-serif/ui-serif/ui-monospace thing is a bit of a crock. (And I wonder if I stand any chance of getting the 13px monospace default size killed. That thing is such an utterly obsolete nuisance—though of course removing it from monospace doesn’t remove the concept, which is used in fonts of various languages.)
Re:How to avoid layout shifts caused by web fonts by lelandfe on Sunday January 30, 2022 @09:53AM (#30137687)
I would never in a million years think of this. Thanks for the link.
Re:How to avoid layout shifts caused by web fonts by TacticalCoder on Sunday January 30, 2022 @08:16AM (#30136913)
> Almost all of the named fonts in common font stacks are either now superfluous or not a good idea any more

It's all fallback, how can they be "not a good idea"? That's the beauty of these CSS font stacks: you can always put first the latest best practices.

> Most font stacks now are just cargo culting, and are mostly mildly harmful.

I disagree and if anything they're not complete enough (I'll write another comment).

Re:How to avoid layout shifts caused by web fonts by chrismorgan on Sunday January 30, 2022 @07:05PM (#30142708)
It’s not all fallback: it’s getting in the way of the actual fallback monospace/sans-serif/serif. The cargo-culting nature of this means that there tend to be one or two bad fonts in there, and sometimes some systems will have bad fonts aliased to otherwise good names (e.g. that’s why I say “don’t write Courier”, because although it’s fine on macOS and probably aliased to something reasonable on Linux platforms, Windows aliases Courier to Courier New, which is a terrible font).

I don’t want your idea of a suitable font, in general, because the default defaults (that is, the browser’s default value for sans-serif) are thoroughly good enough, and I changed my defaults, and by writing the likes of `…, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif`, you didn’t change anything for most people, but prevented me from getting my chosen default sans-serif.

Long font stacks are fighting a fundamentally unwinnable battle with small potential benefits, high uncertainty, and definite costs (normally mild) to people that actually expressed preferences to their user agent.

Re:How to avoid layout shifts caused by web fonts by michaelcampbell on Sunday January 30, 2022 @08:06AM (#30136843)
> superfluous or not a good idea any more, causing more harm than they solve.

Can you expand on why?

Re:How to avoid layout shifts caused by web fonts by pville on Sunday January 30, 2022 @08:53AM (#30137196)
Firefox has left me scratching my head a few times, I think they limit the amount of fallback fonts to resist fingerprinting. Long lists like these will get cut short. Text you intended to be monospace might not be rendered as such as the "monospace" at the very end was never reached.
Re:How to avoid layout shifts caused by web fonts by chrismorgan on Sunday January 30, 2022 @07:08PM (#30142732)
I haven’t ever encountered that, and would expect the limit to be rather long (certainly no less than 32 elements, probably far longer) if there is such a limit. What there is is whitelisting, only exposing certain fonts in order to reduce font list fingerprinting: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1121643.
Re:How to avoid layout shifts caused by web fonts by michaelcampbell on Sunday January 30, 2022 @09:21AM (#30137416)
Huh, ok, never experienced that but that is probably just due to you and I going to different sites. I do use FF as my daily non-work driver though.
Re:How to avoid layout shifts caused by web fonts by OJFord on Sunday January 30, 2022 @01:32PM (#30139718)
What's the benefit of putting `system-ui` in front of `sans-serif` that outweighs the down-side that it might not be sans serif?

Also, even with `ui-sans-serif` (i.e. if it's guaranteed that it is/someone's doing something deliberate if it isn't) why's that what you want for the sans serif text on your web page, that isn't 'system UI'?