Re:Former nuclear leaders: Say ‘no’ to new reactors
by wbl on Saturday January 29, 2022 @04:00PM
(#30130380)
It's costly because the author made it excessively costly in his previous job.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Former nuclear leaders: Say ‘no’ to new reactors
by number6 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @04:10PM
(#30130496)
And if a reactor blows up (happens roughly ever 35 years) there are huge additional costs. Last time we were extremely lucky that we hadn't to evaluate Tokiyo.
If something like this would happen in Central Europe it would be extremely costly for the whole world.
But something like this could happen trice right?!
Re:Former nuclear leaders: Say ‘no’ to new reactors
by ch4s3 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:33PM
(#30132793)
Chernobyl was the only one of those that blew up and it was based an idiotic graphite pile design abandoned everywhere outside of the USSR in the 50s. Fukushima Daiichi experienced 3 small hydrogen explosions that were fully contained by the reactor building, and wouldn't have happened if they hadn't built their backup power for that reactor underground. According to a linear no-threshold model, the accident would most likely cause at most 130 cancer deaths in total assuming everyone in the zone of highest exposure received the maximum possible exposure, which they did not.
Three Mile Island didn't kill anyone and no one was exposed to enough radiation to increase their risk of cancer. The accident happened because someone trained on submarine reactors misapplied that training and turned off the cooling system. No operating reactor allows an operator to do that anymore. The reactor did not blow up.
Only one civilian nuclear power reactor has ever "blown up", Tokyo was never in danger, no one died because of Three Mile Island, and even around Chernobyl the predicted incidence of cancer is failing to materialize.
Re:Former nuclear leaders: Say ‘no’ to new reactors
by number6 on Sunday January 30, 2022 @05:08AM
(#30135533)
Ok let's change the perspective from cost in human lives to cost in money as the parent comment statet: is nuclear power still cheap if we count these disasters?
Re:Former nuclear leaders: Say ‘no’ to new reactors
by wbl on Saturday January 29, 2022 @04:47PM
(#30130879)
People live happily in Denver Colorado or New Jersey. Nobody ever says we should evacuate them. But they get an extra dose of radiation from living there, which reactors don't get. It's about costs and benefits.
Central Europe also doesn't have tsunamis.
Re:Former nuclear leaders: Say ‘no’ to new reactors
by coldtea on Saturday January 29, 2022 @05:41PM
(#30131319)
Yes, if they could only throw caution to the wind, give it to the lowest bidder, and relax quality and safety standards!
Re:Former nuclear leaders: Say ‘no’ to new reactors
by pseudalopex on Saturday January 29, 2022 @06:23PM
(#30131674)
Straw man.