Re:Obama Signs Patent ‘Reform’ Bill
by chc on Sunday September 18, 2011 @10:31PM
(#3011984)
I don't think that's quite right. As I understand the law (and IANAL), you could still get their patent invalidated for lack of novelty — you just couldn't claim the patent yourself in that case.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
This Act changes the U.S. from a First to Invent system to a First to File.
Prior art still invalidates patents in first-to-file systems.
First to file only means that, if you filed for a patent on some thing after someone else who also filed to patent it, you definitely don't get the patent (in a first-to-invent system, whichever of you can show the oldest documentation of invention gets the patent).
Re:Obama Signs Patent ‘Reform’ Bill
by monochromatic on Monday September 19, 2011 @12:05AM
(#3012190)
Under a first to file system, you still have to be an inventor. If you're trying to patent something that you copied from someone else, you're not an inventor.
And even if you didn't derive your work from theirs, you still have a problem with prior art.
First to file doesn't mean anything if there's prior art.
Prior art has very little to do with denying patents in the U.S.
Unfortunately true, but it does make it really hard to sue you.