News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by steveklabnik on Friday January 28, 2022 @11:30AM (#30116832)
Oh yeah, just knocking down 150 bridges is a very easy decision that's going to go over extremely well with the local population, certainly not political suicide as well as a massive, expensive project in its own right. It's not like all those bridges existed for good reason, and just getting rid of them wouldn't have massive impact on an extremely large number of things about the city.

They absolutely need better maintenance. It's been a safety hazard for most of my life. But the solutions are not easy.

Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by donkeyd on Friday January 28, 2022 @12:56PM (#30118083)
> Oh yeah, just knocking down 150 bridges is a very easy decision that's going to go over extremely well with the local population, certainly not political suicide as well as a massive, expensive project in its own right.

I knew this response was coming. However, doing nothing isn’t an option. I also never said it’d be easy. If you can’t afford 450 bridges, you need less bridges or more money. You can’t just ignore the problem.

Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by ada1981 on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:29PM (#30118499)
It turns out not only is not doing anything an option, it’s the option that has been selected.
Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by ravitation on Friday January 28, 2022 @03:44PM (#30120113)
I'm amused that people are willing to contextualize this bridge failure within what is essentially the entire 20th century economic history of Pittsburgh; and then act like that history somehow excuses the complete failure of local governments over that same time period to either repair or eliminate unsafe infrastructure. It's honestly nothing short of absurd.

No one is honestly expecting the local governments throughout the Pittsburgh metropolitan area to eliminate 150 bridges (or some other arbitrarily large number) by 2023... They expected the local governments (and the state and federal governments) to behave competently and never let it get to this point. The decline of Pittsburgh as an industrial hub started over half a century ago... They've had plenty of time to address things like this in that context.

The fact that keeping infrastructure safe is "political suicide" or "costs too much money" is essentially the entire problem - and it's a problem that is not at all unique to Pittsburgh.

Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by steveklabnik on Friday January 28, 2022 @03:53PM (#30120216)
One can wish that the city spent less time and money building new sports stadiums, spent more time and money investing in infrastructure, yet still acknowledge that the political reality on the ground makes doing so hard to near-impossible.
Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by ravitation on Friday January 28, 2022 @04:40PM (#30120734)
I guess for me, the fact that the political reality makes infrastructure "hard" is profoundly obvious... And, while the specific details may change with the city, that reality is quite common throughout the US (even the relatively specific economic conditions discussed earlier in the context of Pittsburgh are not really that unique)...

Pretending like this type of infrastructure decline is somehow unique to Pittsburgh, which, at least implicitly, the top level comment does, does a great disservice to actually finding solutions to the problems with that "political reality on the ground" - and not just in Pittsburgh.

Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by steveklabnik on Friday January 28, 2022 @04:50PM (#30120841)
That's fair. I do also agree that it seems obvious, but given the number of the people in this thread and elsewhere suggesting that fixing it would just simply be so easy, it doesn't seem like that's the case for many others.

I didn't read the OP as saying "nowhere else has infrastructure problems" but "bridges are a particularly acute problem in Pittsburgh for these reasons." I would certainly agree that suggesting this kind of issue is unique to Pittsburgh would be misguided.

Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by ravitation on Friday January 28, 2022 @05:26PM (#30121309)
That's also fair. I think my initial reading of the top comment, and some of the replies, was overly assumptive; and my take on the nature of the cause was a direct result of my already pessimistic view of contemporary American political structures.
Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by HollywoodZero on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:54PM (#30128547)
> The fact that keeping infrastructure safe is "political suicide"

Is this a good reason why politics should always include term limits? It would prevent anyone from NOT doing something that is in the good for the constituents, but is seen as "political suicide". Since no one can be in politics long term, you might as well make the tough decisions.

Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by BitwiseFool on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:18PM (#30118381)
>"However, doing nothing isn’t an option."

Cynically, it actually is for a cash strapped municipality. If they lack the money for proper maintenance - but can afford the bare minimum amount of caretaking - they certainly cannot afford the cost to dismantle the bridge. They will go with bandaid solutions virtually every single time.

Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by sofixa on Friday January 28, 2022 @11:09PM (#30123699)
There's no need to dismantle, it can just be closed if it's deemed unsafe.
Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by Mountain_Skies on Saturday January 29, 2022 @02:24AM (#30124504)
This particular bridge's condition was rated as poor but not unsafe.
Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by FireBeyond on Friday January 28, 2022 @03:25PM (#30119862)
And then get screwed with lawsuit costs and payouts. But that's a can they can kick down the road.
Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by steveklabnik on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:06PM (#30118231)
Yes, it is something that should be done, and yes, it won't be easy. Your comment reflected absolutely none of that, and even was arguing against me saying that it would be extremely difficult, so it did in fact seem like you were saying that this is a simple fix. Heck, you didn't even say "figure out how many bridges you can afford," but simply "remove 150 of them."
Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by duck on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:49PM (#30119462)
I think the other option is to just restrict the weight limit on these and change bus routes.
Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by TheCondor on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:31PM (#30118529)
There is a lot to be learned from this. It’s contemporary to talk about the boom/bust cycles of fracking towns out west. Building a bridge or a nuclear power station is a much bigger commitment than simply building the structure and getting it operational. It outlasts political memory.

I lived in Pittsburgh and remember one way bridges (like a fast path for morning rush hour, but screw getting home) and lots of sort of ad hoc things. They never had a fire wipe the place out and allow for some replanning or long term planning. Worse, if you were to try to knock some things down, there is a huge emotional reaction to it (the out field walls to Forbes field are still there, two stadiums later) I remember the city tax being fairly high as well, in many places I think increased mass transit (usually costs taxes) plus some tolls or something to discourage use on some bridges (read: another tax to use the bridge you were taxed to build) would make sense. Probably a federal bail out or mass closing of bridges are the only options. You are right, it’s not easy.

Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by hardolaf on Friday January 28, 2022 @12:19PM (#30117563)
Pittsburgh itself has actually knocked down quite a few bridges over the last 30 years. The suburbs have not as they just run out of money.
Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by steveklabnik on Friday January 28, 2022 @12:23PM (#30117618)
I'm from up route 28 before I moved into the city, PennDOT certainly is always doing quite a bit of work. 100% agree that there's been changes to bridges over the years. But nothing on the scale of "knock down a third of the bridges with no replacement."
Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by trashface on Friday January 28, 2022 @05:07PM (#30121082)
I agree, I haven't lived in the 'Burgh for a long time, but its geography is basically, lots of little hills and a few big ones. Everywhere you look, you are staring at a hill. And you are on a hill. Plus rivers. A lot of bridges (and tunnels) are needed out there for basic navigation.
Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by recursive on Friday January 28, 2022 @12:16PM (#30117518)
It could well be better to knock some down in an organized way. If the alternative is to have committees and referendums and posturing until nature decides which ones to take.
Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by steveklabnik on Friday January 28, 2022 @12:34PM (#30117769)
The devil is in the details. What's "an organized way" if not "committees and referendums"? Even just the traffic impact studies alone to figure out what would happen when taking out each bridge, let alone that very often they'd impact each other and so you'd also need to figure out what happens with traffic for combinations of bridges, seems like a daunting and expensive task to me.
Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by FireBeyond on Friday January 28, 2022 @03:26PM (#30119877)
Phase it. You don't have to nominate every bridge and start simultaneously. Like you say. Choose a few, remove those, then re-evaluate what traffic looks like now.
Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park by steveklabnik on Friday January 28, 2022 @03:36PM (#30120005)
I wouldn't expect anyone, even the OP, to suggest undertaking 150 demolitions simultaneously.

That still doesn't help you decide which bridges.