News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't Be So F*cking Strategic by philwelch on Sunday September 18, 2011 @04:25PM (#3011166)
Don’t get me wrong. Good strategy combined with good execution is a joy to watch (case in point - Apple over the last decade). The last thing you would want is people off doing their own thing and being all ‘off-strategy’ and rebellious.

I think "strategic" is a little elaborate for Apple's actual plans since Jobs took over. Aside from the initial jump from computers to consumer electronics, the only actual strategic decisions Apple made were along the lines of "what products should we try to create?", "does this product still suck or should we release it soon?", and maybe the switch to Intel processors. They didn't fall into the trap of thinking about second-order shit like image or positioning or market or the economy, they just tried to figure out what would be a great product they could make, and what products and concepts were worth pursuing or not.

Re:Don't Be So F*cking Strategic by mechanical_fish on Monday September 19, 2011 @01:02AM (#3012348)
Are you forgetting about the decision to create Apple's entire retail division, i.e. the Apple Stores? An idea which people thought was ridiculous at the time?

Or the abandonment of support for clone hardware?

Or the decision to go into the media business by inventing the iTunes store -- but not to rely on media as the primary profit center, but rather as a way of driving sales of extremely profitable hardware?

Or the decision to base iOS on Mac OS X, but not to make them exactly the same thing, with the same apps running on both platforms?

Or the myriads of strategic decisions around the App Store, such as the strict review policy, or the pricing model?

Or even the decision to keep Flash off of iOS, at the possible cost of good relations with Adobe, a company that has traditionally been a bulwark of the Mac OS creative scene?

Or are you trying to deny that these are strategic decisions?

(Note that this is not meant to be an exhaustive list. For example, Tim Cook's list of strategic manufacturing decisions has got to be twice this size, but it's also composed of items that remain secret, or that I don't know about or understand. But why have companies been struggling for years now to match Apple's hardware prices? That's not a fortunate accident.)

Re:Don't Be So F*cking Strategic by philwelch on Monday September 19, 2011 @01:26PM (#3014382)
I would classify many of those as design decisions. Many of those seem like unavoidable were natural consequences of other decisions, but I agree the distinction isn't clean cut.

One of Tim Cook's strategic manufacturing decisions, as I recall, was to literally corner the market of NAND flash memory since the heyday of the iPod. Apple did and probably still does preorder a commanding proportion of the world's NAND flash production every year. Is that a strategic decision or just the natural consequence of consistently forecasting that you'll need that much NAND flash?

It sounds like I'm minimizing everything by deeming it "not strategic", but if you're going to characterizing the work Apple does, I don't think you'd be that far off characterizing it as intelligent people working out the natural consequences of a very small number of strategic decisions. If you're Apple, and you're going to make a touchscreen phone that doesn't suck, using Mac OS X technology, keeping Flash off, setting up the App Store the way it is are all consequences of that.

Re:Don't Be So F*cking Strategic by tptacek on Monday September 19, 2011 @11:01AM (#3013784)
In 1996, Apple sold the "Pippin" set-top game system, the Apple Network Server, not to be confused with the Apple Workgroup Server, at least 5 SKUs of Performa, 7 SKUs of Power Macintosh, the Quadra, the QuickTake digital camera, the eMate PDA, and the Color LaserWriter.

These products weren't discontinued because Apple was incapable of executing them. They were discontinued because the strategy of maintaining a one-stop-shop ecosystem, in which a niche of customers would buy not only their computer but also their printer and scanner from Apple, was rejected in favor of the strategy in which the mass market would buy single best-of-breed products from Apple.

Those aren't just two strategies; they're two diametrically opposing strategies.

Re:Don't Be So F*cking Strategic by philwelch on Monday September 19, 2011 @01:46PM (#3014471)
OK, when two of my favorite HN commentators disagree with something I said it's worth a second thought.

Yes, the strategic shift you point out was immense, but it was also a market shift in response to Apple's products. It wasn't until the iPod took off that Apple's position in the market changed any, they just went from selling 12 poorly differentiated lines of Macs to 4 or 5, but to the same niche. Apple can't strategically will themselves into a mass market, the most they can do is create products that might have a broader appeal than Macs do.

Re:Don't Be So F*cking Strategic by tptacek on Monday September 19, 2011 @02:10PM (#3014572)
The conventional wisdom seems to be that Jobs forced Apple to focus their product offerings down.

You seem to be saying, "Jobs' Apple didn't so much 'focus' as simply kill bad products".

I think the truth is somewhere in the middle; the strategic shift wasn't so much from complexity to simplicity as it was from niche to mass market. Some things were killed because they were crappy, others because they didn't have mass market appeal (for instance, custom-branded printers and digital cameras).

Apple seems to have been on a trend towards escalating revenue and improving margins long before the iPod was released; see for instance the historical 10Q's on "Wikivest" (whatever that is).

Re:Don't Be So F*cking Strategic by philwelch on Monday September 19, 2011 @04:39PM (#3015114)
High margins and a mass market strategy tend to be antithetical though.

I think by Apple's standards, anything that doesn't surpass the competition is a crappy product; at the very least it's not a product worth making. Apple had digital cameras and laser printers; what they didn't have was a way to do either product better than everyone else. Focus is certainly part of it, but Apple is less focused now than they were in 1999. Admittedly, compared to any other company, Apple still has extraordinary focus.

It's more my point that it's easy to imagine a world where a minority of Apple fanboys have all the Macs and iPhones and iPads, while Windows and Android rule the mass market. It's execution, not strategy--operational, marketing, retailing, and engineering execution--that makes the difference.

Re:Don't Be So F*cking Strategic by tptacek on Monday September 19, 2011 @04:44PM (#3015124)
Windows is a high-margin product.
Re:Don't Be So F*cking Strategic by ygtckr on Sunday September 18, 2011 @05:29PM (#3011312)
Which imho is a strategy.