News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by paulpauper on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:33PM (#30107905)
probably helps also to have a 1 in 100 million IQ too, but sounds like fun anyway. I am not sure how some of thee masterclasses are useful. Like the one by the astronaut . I don't plan on going into space anytime soon. Maybe Elon Musk would enjoy that one. No amount of videos will make even a typical PhD in math even as close to as good as him. It's 90% genes , 10% other factors.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by uoaei on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:38PM (#30107981)
Is it really common opinion that TT is smart because of his genes? I would think having a helpful and engaged math-fluent father and lots of encouragement from an early age has way more to do with it. You can't seriously believe that an introduction into mathematical thinking from an early age and close advision from math-fluent parents is only 10% of the reason that TT is where he is today.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by umvi on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:43PM (#30108047)
From the wiki:

> Tao exhibited extraordinary mathematical abilities from an early age, attending university-level mathematics courses at the age of 9. He is one of only two children in the history of the Johns Hopkins' Study of Exceptional Talent program to have achieved a score of 700 or greater on the SAT math section while just eight years old; Tao scored a 760

I think genetics have more to do with this level of achievement than encouragement from an engaged father. Tao has 2 brothers - why aren't they mathematical supergeniuses too? Either he was born with a brain that has extraordinary analytical ability, or he was born with an insane work ethic not commonly associated with young kids. But even then, are there reports of him having to work super hard to understand things? If you can do advanced algebra at age 5, I'd say your brain is something extraordinary. Whether the underlying reason for that extraordinary brain is due to genes or some other trigger, it likely was not mainly due to an "encouraging father", IMO.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by paulpauper on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:53PM (#30108183)
Regarding his brothers, imagine if IQ is like a bunch of switches. TT was born with all his switches flipped 'on' out of some maximum. His brothers were born with most of them flipped on, as were his parents. Having high IQ parents increases the odds of more switches being flipped on, but having all of them flipped is still innate.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by nefitty on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:28PM (#30109103)
I've struggled to visually conceptualize this sort of occurrence. This helps a lot. Thank you!

Now, to torture the metaphor, how do I flip on the rest of my switches...

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by sooheon on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:23PM (#30110386)
You can't (your germ line mutations are fixed, and even if you could change your genes in place your brain has already developed according to the previous genetic code and environment). You can only choose where to direct the output of your already flipped switches.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by whatshisface on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:24AM (#30111304)
People on Reddit are taking pills to try and do that. Sometimes you hear about them getting aggressive cancers. Other times you hear about them semi-successfully treating damage they did to their brains with past drug use. Randomized controlled trials never show anything, but if you're being held back from being a genius by one protein that you got a bad gene for, you'd be one of the positive testimonials without showing up above the noise in a trial. Who knows.

Ask again in 2122.

In the meantime, I guess, we all need to learn that our worth as a person is determined by who we are, not what we are.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by drexlspivey on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:52PM (#30108175)
> Tao has 2 brothers - why aren't they mathematical supergeniuses too?

The previous sentence from the one you quoted states that

“Tao also has two brothers, who are living in Australia. Both formerly represented the country at the International Mathematical Olympiad”

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by pedrosorio on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:49PM (#30108748)
Very impressive no doubt, and again, they are brothers, so genetics plays a part. But their achievements aren't even close.

His (younger) brother, Nigel achieved two bronze medals (placing 132nd and 114th overall) at the age of 15 and 16 [0]. Quite good, specially at a younger age than most participants.

Terence [1] got a gold medal (13th place) right before completing 13 years of age. He achieved a similar feat (28th place) around his 12th birthday and a more humble performance (87th place, but still better than his brother's best) around his 11th birthday. At 11, better than 58% of his competition, some of the best 17 and 18 year olds at competitive math in the world.

He is cited as "the youngest bronze, silver, and gold medalist, respectively, in IMO history." [2]

These are entirely different levels.

[0] https://www.imo-official.org/participant_r.aspx?id=783

[1] https://www.imo-official.org/participant_r.aspx?id=1581

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_International_Mathemat...

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by somerando7 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @08:06PM (#30109457)
If I were to guess, his brothers and parents pushed him, and had more experience with teaching compared to their older son. They got him interested, and he went from there.

He was probably lucky to be the younger brother growing up.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by pedrosorio on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:00PM (#30110241)
Terence Tao is the oldest brother.

But of course that doesn’t matter. One could equally hypothesize being the oldest allows for most attention from the parents, etc.

But then again, Judit Polgar, by far the strongest chess player among the famous 3 Polgar sisters, was the youngest…

In my opinion, this sort of “human peak” genius performance requires more than small differences in upbringing.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by somerando7 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:24PM (#30110394)
Oh, then I was completely wrong :D I would think the youngest kids are generally the more academically advanced. (But this is coming from someone who has 0 kids :D)
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by nabla9 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:07PM (#30108925)
He has two brothers, Trevor and Nigel. Both have represented Australia in the International Mathematical Olympiad.

Trevor Tao is autistic savant with a double degree in maths and music. He is FIDE International Master in Chess.

Nigel Tao has IQ 180. I think he works with Go language development.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by agumonkey on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:17PM (#30108448)
There's a video of his childhood submissions (~10yo) and it didn't feel he was an alien. Now maybe his real strength showed up later in life.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by paulpauper on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:45PM (#30108087)
I don't think you understand the difference between being good at math and being at his level. Good parents can make the difference between being good at math or mediocre at math, but not knowing higher level concepts at the age of 15 or so . Or PhD at 22 or something. There are thousands of professors in the US even in math, how many produce super genius math kids with similar ability? Two 120-IQ parents a more more likely to produce a 110 IQ kids than someone with a 170+ IQ like TT; that is something else.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by raphlinus on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:48PM (#30108737)
Unusually, we have pretty good documentation about Prof Tao's background, childhood, and mathematical education. I found this a good read.

http://math.fau.edu/yiu/Oldwebsites/MPS2010/TerenceTao1984.p...

My favorite part is when he was asked, at age 8 minus epsilon, whether addition distributes over multiplication (after having established that multiplication distributing over addition is an example of a distributive law), and he said, "only for Boolean algebras."

(Disclosure: I was also a child prodigy, so much of this story resonated with me. I'm now a research software engineer at Google, working on lots of mathematically intensive topics in 2D graphics, but obviously nowhere nearly as accomplished as Prof Tao)

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by krackers on Thursday January 27, 2022 @08:07PM (#30109463)
The entire Q&A is great. My favorite part is the snippet of his basic program for fibonacci computation.

   300 print "mr. fibonacci is leaving now,"
   310 print "and wishes to see you again sometime in the future"
   312 print
   313 print
   315 print "here goes his car!!!!!!!!"
   320 print "(brmmmm-brmmmm-putt-putt-vraow-chatter-chatter bye mr. fibonacci!)"
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by nefitty on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:34PM (#30109164)
If I asked the people close to you what you do/think differently than others, what would they say?
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by raphlinus on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:58PM (#30109401)
I don't think I come across as an alien. For example, I'm very deeply involved in my local Quaker meeting, and I don't think any of that is particularly different than others. That said, I can nerd out extremely deeply into a problem, to a point where I've noticed other people's eyes glaze over. Case in point, I've become interested in memory models for GPUs, and while most people in the field would be content to leave it there, I've actually dug into the Alloy code for the formalization of the Vulkan memory model (and found some issues along the way). I'd estimate there are probably less than two dozen other people in the world who have dug that deep, and, thinking about it now, I can see a pretty direct line to what child-prodigy-me would do in a similar situation.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by dr_kiszonka on Friday January 28, 2022 @12:38PM (#30117834)
1) When talking to others, do you feel that you need slow down a lot and simplify to give them a chance to keep up with you?

2) Is learning any topic easier for you than for an average person or are you so talented in just a few areas?

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by nefitty on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:07PM (#30110284)
Very cool. Thanks for the response. I may be reaching but maybe genius is a combination of curiosity, processing speed, mental RAM and focus. Maybe each of those can be improved in regular people...
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by IggleSniggle on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:43AM (#30111404)
As a human high in curiosity and processing speed but low in RAM and focus, my personal experience is that diet+prescription drugs can unlock the rest.

At least for me, this also comes with costs. Some of these costs are immediately observable to me (much lower levels of broad-insight / Gordian-Knot-slicing, and I am less patient with others). Other costs are only presumed…I have guesses about associated long-term health risks both direct and indirect.

Anyway, all this to say, I think it can be done artificially. Since these things take time to play out towards mastery, you better hope you can get it right. Just like in software, some things can be a Pareto improvement, but some things can be prematurely optimized, and some things really never needed to be built in the first place.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by nefitty on Friday January 28, 2022 @07:05PM (#30122266)
I hadn't thought of it but I see that I'm high RAM, high curiosity. Haha we should make a Meyers-Brigg for this.

I agree about inputs. I have a list project I'm working on called "This I Believe". I'm trying to decode my deeply held beliefs so that I understand mself and can change those beliefs. The very first thing I put on it was "Better living through chemistry."

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by sooheon on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:26PM (#30110408)
> You can't seriously believe that an introduction into mathematical thinking from an early age and close advision from math-fluent parents is only 10% of the reason

I can't seriously believe the alternative.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by pdog on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:39PM (#30110475)
His dad is a doctor and his mom is an astrophysicist and mathematician. Do you think that is a coincidence?
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by lukas099 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @11:01PM (#30110567)
Are you implying that if there isn't a mostly-genetic basis for his intelligence, the career success of his family members must be a complete coincidence?
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by wolverine876 on Friday January 28, 2022 @12:55AM (#30111103)
But how do they pass on their skills, through years of daily interaction, or via genetics?
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by klyrs on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:36PM (#30107943)
> It's 90% genes , 10% other factors.

Do you have evidence to support these numbers, or the more general claim of genetic supremacy?

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by paulpauper on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:41PM (#30108023)
He was a demonstrating adult level math ability even at the age of 5. Also, he was genius level at other subjects too. How would it not be genetic. Think of how hard parents push their kids in today's super-competitive economy and high-stakes higher ed system, how many turn out even close to as talented as him?
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by lordnacho on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:01PM (#30108276)
Not sure why you think the split is so tilted towards genetics. If TT had been born in some 3rd world country with poor nutrition and crappy education system, how would he be exposed to all the higher level math topics? It's clear you need that exposure, you aren't just going to know things about what mathematicians have thought about and consider important without coming into contact with some.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by paulpauper on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:07PM (#30108339)
We have a sample size of 600 + million ppl between the US and Western Europe with full access to food, electricity, and other modern necessities, not third world countries. How many are as smart as him.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by klyrs on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:35PM (#30108625)
> How many are as smart as him.

I'll accept that nobody is, but his mom was a math teacher. Few of us get that kind of leg up, certainly not 600m+. When I was 5, "don't get shot" was already getting a significant share of my brain's power, and I had it better than most. Sure, he's got a brain like gasoline, but don't discount the spark and oxygen that allowed the genius to deflagrate. And don't just throw numbers around like that if you don't have proof. If you respect the mathematics, act like it.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by lordnacho on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:11PM (#30108387)
And how many of them were able to dust up a person who could explain to them not only how algebra works, but why one should study it? At the age where they can actually do it and not get bored?

Math education comes up here regularly, and we have lots of smart math people here, but the story is often that some commentator was simply never shown anything interesting in their whole schooling. I'd never have given it much thought were it not for one particular math teacher who put a lot of effort into me and a few other interested kids. I still keep in touch with him.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by contravariant on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:51PM (#30108767)
Markedly fewer than people with similar genes I imagine.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by j7ake on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:08PM (#30108932)
If you’re asking about math talent as in child prodigies, then one can browse previous winners of the math Olympiad.

But I have a feeling his success as a professional mathematician involves the interaction of such math talent with hard work and good mathematical taste.

One can read his PhD qualifying exams to observe he was actually not an outlier amongst his peers in his early career.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by BeetleB on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:57PM (#30109393)
So in other words, the answer to your parent's question is "No, you don't have any evidence."

You are providing questions as a substitute for actual evidence. Your questions are worthy of being asked, but they are still questions.

Basically a variant of "I cannot explain ... therefore it must be Y! How could it not be Y?"

Just because people don't have adequate explanations for nurture doesn't make it an automatic "genetics". All it means is that they don't have adequate explanations. This does not make your stance any stronger or more likely to be correct.

(Disclaimer: I can easily believe genetics is the answer. I won't, however, be sure of it).

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by geodel on Thursday January 27, 2022 @08:36PM (#30109681)
Really? Do you have proof of this is result of extraordinary nurture. Because nurture would be far more easy to see/document and match against against other examples.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by BeetleB on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:03PM (#30109860)
> Really? Do you have proof of this is result of extraordinary nurture.

> Just because people don't have adequate explanations for nurture doesn't make it an automatic "genetics". All it means is that they don't have adequate explanations.

Your question is the equivalent of "Since you cannot provide evidence, I must be right." This is a fallacy. The other party's lack of evidence does not strengthen your position.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by wolverine876 on Friday January 28, 2022 @12:56AM (#30111111)
> Think of how hard parents push their kids in today's super-competitive economy and high-stakes higher ed system, how many turn out even close to as talented as him?

Maybe they don't know how to do it. Maybe TT got lucky.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by hackinthebochs on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:23PM (#30110390)
The genetic model for the occurrence of supreme levels of ability more accurately matches reality than an environmental model. We know that polygentic traits in a population follow a normal distribution[1], which entails a regression to the mean for traits in offspring[2]. This means the occurrence of extreme ability is a function of the ability of the parents. While being rare, it becomes more likely if the parents themselves have some extreme traits.

This dynamic matches what we see in the case of Terrence Tao and his brothers, the Polgar sisters, and other cases of savants/virtuosos that come to mind. Usually one child has extraordinary ability while their siblings are much less remarkable. If the environmental model were accurate, we should see many cases where families produce more than one extreme talent of equal skill. But we don't see that in practice.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polygene#Trait_distribution

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regression_toward_the_mean#His...

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by NikolaeVarius on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:53PM (#30108191)
Genes must have something to do with it. Take the case of Srinivasa Ramanujan

No formal training in math. Made insane contributions to mathematics including solving "unsolvable" problems.

> A child prodigy by age 11, he had exhausted the mathematical knowledge of two college students who were lodgers at his home. He was later lent a book written by S. L. Loney on advanced trigonometry.[18][19] He mastered this by the age of 13 while discovering sophisticated theorems on his own. By 14, he received merit certificates and academic awards that continued throughout his school career, and he assisted the school in the logistics of assigning its 1,200 students (each with differing needs) to its approximately 35 teachers.[14]: 27 He completed mathematical exams in half the allotted time, and showed a familiarity with geometry and infinite series. Ramanujan was shown how to solve cubic equations in 1902; he developed his own method to solve the quartic. In the following year, he tried to solve the quintic, not knowing that it could not be solved by radicals.

If there was a method of raising kids like this "scientifically" , I bet a good portion of the worlds GDP would be put into this field of research

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by nefitty on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:52PM (#30109344)
I'm not sure why people feel so allergic to the idea of a genetic intelligence boost.

Our genes encode the layout of physical race tracks on which marbles of matter and information travel. Some people's bodies have a bunch of muscle tracks, so as they grow, their body benefits from the activity on those. They grow up to find it easier to gain muscle than other people.

For geniuses, I imagine that the brain is a perfectly laid out super highway. Any information that comes in gets to where it needs to go because there's signs and signals and traffic cops patrolling. If some piece of information can't find where to go, well, damned if we don't have a construction worker and a navigator jumping in the passenger seat with you to help out.

Ultimately, I think the brain is so plastic that each of us can one day decide to elect a new mayor to our body town. The new mayor can decide to tear up roads and fix potholes etc. Yeah, it would have been great if we had founded the town with a plan and hadn't had that college riot but here we are. Time to pave some roads.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by geodel on Thursday January 27, 2022 @08:51PM (#30109785)
> I'm not sure why people feel so allergic to the idea of a genetic intelligence boost.

Because it kinda puncture this feel good marketing bull that "you can be anything you want". It could also shut endless flowing money into extra-coaching classes outside normal schools which promise to "help child to reach their fullest potential".

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by nefitty on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:05PM (#30110269)
That does make sense. I think the reality is somewhere in the middle. I personally plan on hiring professional tutors for my children when I have them. Hopefully they're born with a lot of moldable clay, but either way, there are additional evidence-based education methods to utilize that promote mastery.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by whatshisface on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:44AM (#30111409)
But you can be anything you want, what's set by nature is how hard you have to work for each milestone of it.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by adgjlsfhk1 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @11:17PM (#30110666)
The big reason is because there have been a number of studies that show that the ability of genetics to explain IQ is not especially major.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by whatshisface on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:37AM (#30111374)
The studies trying to find the link between genetics and IQ are flawed in that they don't have a way to handle the interactions between genes. Instead they are based on correlations.

If you will be good at baseball if you have A and B, OK with neither, but terrible with only one, those genes will be identified in most studies as having nothing to do with baseball, maybe even identified as harmful.

I can offer a concrete example. Autism is more often found in high-IQ families, but itself is associated with decreased IQ. That suggests one case where either A and B alone are harmful, having neither makes you fine (and unlikely to bear children with A or B), and having both makes you smart.

I am not sure if we want people to figure out how to make connections involving specific genes, because a lot of us benefit from living in a world where we can game LeetCode by working longer and harder in a way that's unrelated to what Google is looking for.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by paulpauper on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:59PM (#30108249)
People will delay a dental procedure but they will not delay making their kids #1.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by barry-cotter on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:51PM (#30108763)
I wish I lived in a world where that was true.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by amznbyebyebye on Thursday January 27, 2022 @11:46PM (#30110779)
These are like world class atheletes, gifted and they put in the hard work to get to where they are today. That is what it takes to be one of these once in a decade type of mathematician.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by michaelhah on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:46PM (#30108096)
Probably getting to his level is highly genetically dependent but that’s not what watching a Masterclass vid is about. Probably really interesting but I would likely forget to cancel and i am planning on living forever so I’d end up paying an infinite amount of money for this.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by paulpauper on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:55PM (#30108211)
then what is it about then? listening to someone talk about their job? Can't you do that for free on YouTube?
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by travisjungroth on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:13PM (#30108975)
Sure, but not this class and maybe they enjoy this one more. People still pay for movies even if there are free movies.