News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by paulpauper on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:41PM (#30108023)
He was a demonstrating adult level math ability even at the age of 5. Also, he was genius level at other subjects too. How would it not be genetic. Think of how hard parents push their kids in today's super-competitive economy and high-stakes higher ed system, how many turn out even close to as talented as him?
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by lordnacho on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:01PM (#30108276)
Not sure why you think the split is so tilted towards genetics. If TT had been born in some 3rd world country with poor nutrition and crappy education system, how would he be exposed to all the higher level math topics? It's clear you need that exposure, you aren't just going to know things about what mathematicians have thought about and consider important without coming into contact with some.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by paulpauper on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:07PM (#30108339)
We have a sample size of 600 + million ppl between the US and Western Europe with full access to food, electricity, and other modern necessities, not third world countries. How many are as smart as him.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by klyrs on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:35PM (#30108625)
> How many are as smart as him.

I'll accept that nobody is, but his mom was a math teacher. Few of us get that kind of leg up, certainly not 600m+. When I was 5, "don't get shot" was already getting a significant share of my brain's power, and I had it better than most. Sure, he's got a brain like gasoline, but don't discount the spark and oxygen that allowed the genius to deflagrate. And don't just throw numbers around like that if you don't have proof. If you respect the mathematics, act like it.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by lordnacho on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:11PM (#30108387)
And how many of them were able to dust up a person who could explain to them not only how algebra works, but why one should study it? At the age where they can actually do it and not get bored?

Math education comes up here regularly, and we have lots of smart math people here, but the story is often that some commentator was simply never shown anything interesting in their whole schooling. I'd never have given it much thought were it not for one particular math teacher who put a lot of effort into me and a few other interested kids. I still keep in touch with him.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by contravariant on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:51PM (#30108767)
Markedly fewer than people with similar genes I imagine.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by j7ake on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:08PM (#30108932)
If you’re asking about math talent as in child prodigies, then one can browse previous winners of the math Olympiad.

But I have a feeling his success as a professional mathematician involves the interaction of such math talent with hard work and good mathematical taste.

One can read his PhD qualifying exams to observe he was actually not an outlier amongst his peers in his early career.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by BeetleB on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:57PM (#30109393)
So in other words, the answer to your parent's question is "No, you don't have any evidence."

You are providing questions as a substitute for actual evidence. Your questions are worthy of being asked, but they are still questions.

Basically a variant of "I cannot explain ... therefore it must be Y! How could it not be Y?"

Just because people don't have adequate explanations for nurture doesn't make it an automatic "genetics". All it means is that they don't have adequate explanations. This does not make your stance any stronger or more likely to be correct.

(Disclaimer: I can easily believe genetics is the answer. I won't, however, be sure of it).

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by geodel on Thursday January 27, 2022 @08:36PM (#30109681)
Really? Do you have proof of this is result of extraordinary nurture. Because nurture would be far more easy to see/document and match against against other examples.
Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by BeetleB on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:03PM (#30109860)
> Really? Do you have proof of this is result of extraordinary nurture.

> Just because people don't have adequate explanations for nurture doesn't make it an automatic "genetics". All it means is that they don't have adequate explanations.

Your question is the equivalent of "Since you cannot provide evidence, I must be right." This is a fallacy. The other party's lack of evidence does not strengthen your position.

Re:Masterclass on mathematical thinking by wolverine876 on Friday January 28, 2022 @12:56AM (#30111111)
> Think of how hard parents push their kids in today's super-competitive economy and high-stakes higher ed system, how many turn out even close to as talented as him?

Maybe they don't know how to do it. Maybe TT got lucky.