News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by jackfoxy on Sunday September 18, 2011 @01:02PM (#3010649)
What should I read to learn more about history?

I used to consider my knowledge of history better than at least 95% of the population, but while reading The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire I realized how sketchy my view of history really was. So at the ripe old age of 35 I set off on a course of study centered on two series of books, The Story of Civilization, by Will and Ariel Durant, and Timeframe, a Time-Life series focusing on a timeframe in human history and what was going on in all parts of the world inhabited by man: lots of pictures and of course superficial, but it painted in a lot of gaps I othewise would have never covered. The Timeframe series starts much earlier than the Durant's, but once both series were in sync I would read the books in both series for an epoch, as well as at least two other books, either written in the era or about the era, drawing mostly from science, culture, and biography. For instance I read all the books of Euclid, Newton's Optiks and Principia (I slogged through the Motte transaltion before the first modern English translation became available), The Wealth of Nations, Shelby Foote's 3-volume history of the Civil War, and The Origen of Species. (It's real easy for me to spot folks who spoot-off about Wealth or Origen who have not actually read the books.) My program culminated with Tragedy and Hope, which being such an inflammatory work, I did not trust to read without the full background of history. The process was like watching Western Civilization unfolding.

Now for the unintended consequences: I became a bore at cocktail parties. I wanted to talk about the ideas in the fascinating book I was reading. I used to love arguing politics. Even with my prior knowledge it was hard enough finding opponents who would engage in rational discourse, now it is impossible. It's been so long my debating skills have totally gone down the tubes. The sad thing is I believe my problem is really society's. Political correctness (among other problems) in academia, has produced a generation of intellectually crippled intellectuals; and the entertainment industry, including the 24-hour news cycle as entertainment, has just stupefied people. I fear for democracy and republican government.

Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by zedshaw on Sunday September 18, 2011 @03:33PM (#3011053)
The force is strong with this one.

I'd love to debate random topics with you. Assuming you've actually read everything you claim, I think you'd be a refreshing change from the vast majority of people who simply regurgitate whatever their heroes say.

If you're interested, email me sometime: zedshaw at zedshaw.com.

Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by marcamillion on Sunday September 18, 2011 @04:00PM (#3011102)
Hrmm...while I haven't read all of those books - granted I am still relatively young (sub 30) - I too feel like I have no outlet to really debate various topics that I would love to.

People really aren't interested.

If there was some forum where people of like minds could get together and talk (verbally, not typing on a keyboard) say a Google Hangout or something, I think that would be awesome and definitely something I would be interested in.

Provided it can be moderated and organized and not be chaos (and focused on content, learning, expanding knowledge, etc.).

Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by jackfoxy on Sunday September 18, 2011 @04:46PM (#3011216)
Zed, You are one of the interesting people I would like to meet someday. I will eventually get in touch. My job (among other distractons) is sapping me right now, but I hope to get back to real life by mid-November. Likewise I can be reached jacfoxy at gmail dot com.
Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by wyclif on Sunday September 18, 2011 @06:06PM (#3011404)
I would add Jacob Burckhardt's The Civilization of the Renaissance in Italy to the book list. It appears to be a glaring omission.
Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by brndnhy on Monday September 19, 2011 @06:29AM (#3013010)
This was one of my favorite college texts. I'm really disappointed that I'd forgotten about it until your comment. Thanks.
Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by wyclif on Monday September 19, 2011 @06:51PM (#3015532)
Thanks. BTW, Caesar's _The Gallic Wars_ is available online from MIT: http://classics.mit.edu/Caesar/gallic.html
Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by mdiep on Sunday September 18, 2011 @05:47PM (#3011357)
I'd love to see a full list of all the books you read and the order in which you read them. I recently started reading The Story of Civilization and augmenting it with other works seems like a wonderful idea.
Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by jackfoxy on Sunday September 18, 2011 @08:15PM (#3011684)
I've meant to compile this list, so you just inspired me. I wish the Durants had had the stamina for one more volume. I don't know much about the European revolutions of 1848 and would have like to read about that time from them. I already had read a lot of ancient Greek literature in translation as well as The Pentateuch, all the historical books of the Old Testament and the Gospels. Western Civilization springs from intellectual roots in Athens and Jerusalem, so any survey has to include that heritage. My degree is in Comparative Literature, so I put a lot of stock in origninal source material. The only languages I read are English and German, so everything is in English or translation except Faust, which IMO would be a waste in translation. The books I read for my survey (this was my survey to fill in my personal Bildungslöcke) are not all classics, and not even all to be recommended. It may appear surprisingly heavy on 20th century, but a lot of intellectual threads I thought I should understand better got kicked off in that century. In more or less chronological order by authorship or content (and I've probably forgotten a few):

Euclid The Elements

Arrian The Campaigns of Alexander

Garmonsway (trans.) The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle

Komroff (ed.) The Travels of Marco Polo

Haydn The Counter-Renaissance

Braudel The Mediterranean and the Mediterranean World in the Age of Phillip II, Vol I&II

Pascal The Thoughts

Spinoza The Ethics

Christianson In the Presence of the Creator: Isaac Newton & his Times

Newton Opticks

Newton Principia (get the modern English translation by U.C. Press)

Hampson The Enlightenment

Voltaire Candide

Rousseau The Social Contract

Boswell Life of Johnson

Goethe Faust

Phillips The Cousins' Wars

Schom Napoleon Bonaparte

Heidler & Heidler Old Hickory's War

Babbage On the Economy of Machinery and Manufactures

de Toqueville Democracy in America

Darwin On the Origen of Species

Foote The Civil War: A Narrative

Maurois Disraeli

Twain Life on the Mississippi

Spector Admiral of the New Empire, The Life and Career of George Dewey

Cardwell The Norton History of Technology

Abbott Flatland, A Romance of Many Dimensions

Meyer & Brysac Tournament of Shaddows, The Great Game and the Race for Empire in Central Asia

Doughty Travels in Arabia Deserta

Lefevre The Golden Flood

Massie Dreadnought, Britain, Germany, and the Coming of the Great War

Lawrence Seven Pillars of Wisdom

Durant The Story of Philosophy

Cardozo The Nature of the Judicial Process

Schapiro The Communist Party of the Soviet Union

Popper The Logic of Scientific Discovery

Kershaw Hitler: 1889-1936 Hubris

Blemenson (ed.) The Patton Papers (1940-1945)

Hayek The Road to Serfdom

von Mises Human Action

Skinner Walden Two

Chambers Witness

Kuhn The Structure of Scientific Revolutions

Guevara Guerrilla Warfare

Cleaver Soul on Ice

Lacey The Kingdom, Arabia & the House of Saud

Durant The Lessons of History

Hackworth Lessons Learned, Vietnam Primer

Quigley Tragedy & Hope: A History of the World in Our Time

EDIT: Just remembered two more

Hobbes Leviathan

Locke Two Treatises of Government

Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by sb on Monday September 19, 2011 @01:23AM (#3012406)
If you don't mind reading German then you might be interested in the the four volume series "Deutsche Gesellschaftsgeschichte" by Hans-Ulrich Wehler. Friends from Germany keep telling me that this is the reference about Germany's society. Parts II and III should cover 1848 and I figure there are similar texts for other European countries.

(Since you've read Faust and the intial post mentions Gibbon's Rise and Fall, you might be interested in Theodor Mommsen's "History of Rome" as well.)

Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by mhartl on Monday September 19, 2011 @04:12AM (#3012742)
Quick question: Is Origen really the name of Darwin's book, or is it just misspelled? You (mis?)spelled "Origin" the same way everywhere, which makes me wonder...

P.S. I'm heartened to see Mises and Hayek on your list. I recommend adding Burke and (especially) Carlyle. If you can fully digest Carlyle, your fear for democracy and republican government will turn to panic, and your journey to the Dark Side will be complete.

Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by hegemonicon on Monday September 19, 2011 @10:29AM (#3013661)
According to google image search, it's Origin: http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=On+the+Origin+of+Sp...
Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by jackfoxy on Monday September 19, 2011 @11:26AM (#3013889)
Misspelled. Caught me.
Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by AmericanOP on Monday September 19, 2011 @02:23AM (#3012556)
You may have seen Ideas: A History of Thought and Invention by Watson. Could be a good umbrella book to tie it all together.
Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by jackfoxy on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @11:17AM (#3043591)
I remembered another book from my survey of western civ:

Tuchman A Distant Mirror

Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by derrida on Monday September 19, 2011 @06:02AM (#3012963)
Did you enjoy Spinoza's Ethics?
Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by jackfoxy on Monday September 19, 2011 @11:34AM (#3013916)
At the time I found it somewhat interesting, but it's one of the books that really didn't stick with me. as I progressed reading through the centuries it was more interesting within the developments of its time and immediately succeeding era. Reading the philosophers I have read, it always struck me they encapsulated a certain essence of the era that followed their time. Probably post hoc selection has a lot to do with why they are still remembered. I think PG is right about most philosophy. I haven't read any at all in over a decade.
Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by Willwhatley on Monday September 19, 2011 @12:01AM (#3012178)
I've wondered about variants on democracy. The parliamentary and constitutional forms seem to me to incentivize (for those who want power) going along to get along. Sophists, flatterers, demagogues; there is no good incentive to vote, only the strong disincentive of some other party's bums overseeing you rather than ones you know.

There's a Twain short story about folks who get more than the initial vote, in proportion to their accomplishments. So a propertied or moneyed man is so much more enfranchised, a doctor of philosophy has a couple more votes, and so forth. The incentive there for demagogues would seem to weight one even more firmly than presently in favor of the rich and the academic guild. I don't support any scheme that brings us closer to a plutocracy than we already are--merely mention this as a starting point.

And then there is government by lot; the next dogcatcher, etc. to be selected in some randomized fashion, perhaps confine the pool to certified catchers of dogs, treason for tampering, and so forth. The incentive becomes enormous to raise the general quality of the citizens in proportion to how broad the pool of candidates is; and, of course, to monkey with the criteria for candidates to benefit oneself and disadvantage one's adversaries.

Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by Volpe on Monday September 19, 2011 @01:26AM (#3012410)
There are democratic countries where it is compulsory to vote .

This of course brings it's own set of problems...

Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by ra on Monday September 19, 2011 @06:54AM (#3013049)
In Australia it is compulsory to vote. Having lived here through four general elections, I actually believe it has a negative effect on democracy.

That is to say, compulsory voting forces the most disinterested and politically ignorant members of society into the polling booths. It usually favors the most conservative party. In Australia that translates to maintaining "old-fashioned" views on, most notably, processing of refugees.

Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by Volpe on Monday September 19, 2011 @07:36AM (#3013121)
Is that problem really caused by compulsory voting, or more Australian society in general?

Australia was sporting the White Australia policy up until about 30 years ago, and still requires citizen applicants to pass an 'English' test. It's rather primitive and discriminative processing of refugees (arriving by boat only!?) seems to fall in line with that as well.

Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by derrida on Monday September 19, 2011 @07:38AM (#3013129)
"It's real easy for me to spot folks who spoot-off about Wealth or Origen who have not actually read the books." What is sad is that I recall realizing at University that certain graduate students had not read some of the books they were teaching! I think the humanities are vitally important, but the academic humanities, unfortunately, sometimes breed a certain kind of person who wants to get a job in academia for impure reasons.
Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by anatoly on Sunday September 18, 2011 @04:12PM (#3011131)
This is a good program. It reminds me of the curriculum of St. John's College: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St._John%27s_College_(United_St...

Perhaps I'm overly optimistic, but it seems plausible to me that there's a subreddit out there for people just like you.

Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by jackfoxy on Sunday September 18, 2011 @08:32PM (#3011721)
I was contacted by St.John's as a high school senior, and thought their program looked really interesting, but my folks couldn't afford a private college for me. In those days a California resident could go to U.C. and it just cost living expenses and books.
Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by eavc on Sunday September 18, 2011 @06:03PM (#3011398)
Either DepthHub or TheAgora, maybe.
Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by Alex3917 on Monday September 19, 2011 @12:14PM (#3014099)
Do you find that at some point reading more history has diminishing returns in terms of your ability to understand current politics?

It seems like having good political sense requires two things: having a solid understanding of the current state of people and assets, and having a good understanding of the impacts of policy. (As well as having some understanding of the whole human experience thing.)

While history is obviously important for understanding this stuff, it seems like after a certain point one would get more insight from other places. I don't doubt that most people don't know enough of history to understand politics, but at the same time most people don't know enough of anything else to understand politics either.

Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by jackfoxy on Monday September 19, 2011 @11:02PM (#3016088)
Don't confuse knowledge with understanding. Almost all good things exhibit diminishing returns. One lesson of history is to gain deeper understanding of human nature. That is a big key to understanding politics in any age. Plenty of people become adept at politics knowing nothing of history. Another lesson of history is to understand the balance between conservatism and progressivism. Birds need left wings and right wings to fly. Healthy societies need conservatives and progressives, but the so-called left/right dynamic is only the most apparent dynamic in politics, the one with the most entertainment value; and so the entertainment industry exploits it and ends up devolving political discourse. Think of the carnival side-show 3 shell game. The shells moving around and the banter between the con-man and the shills distracts everyone and provides entertainment. Where the ball ends up is the libertarian/authoritarian dynamic of politics. Most people don't have a clue, but if you have gained understanding from history (which requires studying a balance of sources) you see it. History is only one course of study to gain understanding of human nature and balance.
Re:PG's Rarely Asked Questions by maw on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @10:20AM (#3017638)
Now for the unintended consequences: I became a bore at cocktail parties.

I dunno, I think it'd be more interesting to talk with you than to talk with people about what they drank at the last party they went to--especially since "what" usually just means "how much".