Re:Naomi Wu video demonetized on YouTube
by kragen on Thursday January 27, 2022 @08:36AM
(#30100354)
Historically though she's done her builds herself, and she's been careful to call out the exceptions where a friend wrote some firmware for her or something. Not sure about video editing, I think she does that herself too. I don't think it's accurate to accuse her of "movie magic".
Re:Naomi Wu video demonetized on YouTube
by torginus on Thursday January 27, 2022 @08:45AM
(#30100461)
I have to admit I haven't checked out her recently, but I'm not accusing her of anything - I'm just saying that even if she delegates a part of her work (which is what all successful business people do) it is not a cause for condemnation.
Re:Naomi Wu video demonetized on YouTube
by kragen on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:44PM
(#30109266)
Aside from the wankers, people don't watch her videos because she's a "successful business person", but because she's a maker or because she's demonstrating the capabilities of newly available machinery. The Make Magazine guy's erroneous accusation was that she wasn't really a maker, just a successful business person. He was wrong about that. That's the context in which it would be reasonable to read your comment as an accusation, and, as far as I know, a false one.
Re:Naomi Wu video demonetized on YouTube
by torginus on Friday January 28, 2022 @09:47AM
(#30115225)
I have some general advice for you - please assume that people argue in good faith.
I didn't think you weren't arguing in good faith. I still don't think you weren't arguing in good faith. That's why I was explaining some important extra context to you that you seemed to be unaware of.
Despite a lot of popular youtubers giving off the vibe of being one-person shows, most employ production assistants and editors.
Besides, (old) Top Gear was one of the most beloved shows of all time, which constantly featured segments where the Clarkson-Hammond-May trio was implied to make various contraptions, which were clearly made by the production staff. Not once did I feel like that it detracted from the enjoyment.
So as long she puts out high quality content, no one should mind that what she does is 'movie magic' in part.