News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nova by Panic by Klonoar on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @03:45AM (#30069666)
You say these things as if they're non-obvious...

The fact of the matter is that VSCode's market share is massive, and expecting developers to port extensions solely because "it's a native macOS app" is not really a good pitch in 2020-2022. I would rather Panic suck it up and do the work to interop with the existing (massive) ecosystem so that those of us who like to run native apps can do so without it being a step down on just about anything else.

Something like this needs ecosystem buy in, and as far as I can tell right now, it doesn't have it. I wish it did.

Re:Nova by Panic by Skinney on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @07:59AM (#30071268)
I don't really see why Nova should attempt to be compatible with another editor just because they landed on JS as the integration language. It's doubtful that VS Code has the best API, and it's doubtful that VS Code's API is the best fit when the editor isn't primarily rendering HTML.

Because the editor works very differently, it's unlikely they'd ever manage to make the APIs completely compatible, and because of that it'd unlikely that you'd have much porting between the editors anyhow.

There are many editors out there with incompatible plugin APIs (sublime, vim, emacs, vs code, fleet etc.). There is room for Nova to do their own thing, and do their own thing better without catering to the crowd of another editor.

Re:Nova by Panic by Klonoar on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @05:23PM (#30078964)
>There are many editors out there with incompatible plugin APIs (sublime, vim, emacs, vs code, fleet etc.). There is room for Nova to do their own thing, and do their own thing better without catering to the crowd of another editor.

No, there's really not. The marketshare for a native-macOS editor is comparatively small, and they would be better served just making it work and interop well.

There is nothing special about their extensions API and there is no glory in re-forging this path.