In short, I wouldn't consider "your whiteboard code is missing a semicolon" to indicate a lack of productivity overall, only a lack of practice coding on a whiteboard. (It surprised me how much better my whiteboard code got over the course of a quarter of teaching.)
For more complicated tasks I guess you can say it's debatable when whiteboard is OK and when you should give the candidate access to a computer.
And that's under ideal conditions! Writing code on a whiteboard is so far from ideal for most people that keeping your variable names consistent is a challenge — balancing parentheses and brackets and keeping track of little dots is outright grueling, and doing all this during a job interview is enough to make even very competent programmers choke.
Give me a laptop with just a text editor and watch over my shoulder.
These sorts of tests are low pass filters, they're not designed to find good or great programmers, just confirm that the person can program at all (as we define it). Since most people who call themselves programmers really aren't, they're highly useful. Anyone who's looking for perfection of this nature in an interview and who fails a candidate for lacking that is doing the latter a favor by not hiring them.