News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Future of E-Bikes by cianmm on Sunday January 23, 2022 @04:31AM (#30044847)
I’m a total convert to ebikes and use a VanMoof (mentioned in this article as an example of vertical integration - its a great bike when it works, but it has a high failure rate. My parents use more traditional brands with a much lower failure rate but about twice the price) to move around my fairly bike unfriendly city. This article gets a lot of points right, but a few important ones wrong.

Firstly, I find it pretty surprising that the author would want to remove the drivetrain. I frequently do 75km (47 miles) in a weekend on a single charge on my bike, and I imagine that a lot of that range is due to the power that I’m providing to the bike rather than relying entirely on the inbuilt motor. The ability to go far is central to the goal of replacing as many car journeys as possible with sustainable transport such as bikes. In addition, bikes provide decent exercise with relatively little effort, built into day to day. Cycling makes us healthier. Also, if you run out of battery then you’ll just have to push the bike, rather than cycle a bike roughly the weight of a city-share bike back home, which isn’t a particularly difficult task for most. I do however see the benefit of this type of bike for some who use bikes as an accessibility tool, although maybe in those cases a scooter with a seat would be more convenient since it’s smaller.

The second idea in the article which made me double-take is the idea of removing direct mechanical brakes from the bike. As somebody who commutes around a busy city on a daily basis, this had me wondering if the writer actually cycles in a city or not. As a bike commuter I need to deal with drivers who want to kill me, pedestrians who jump out from behind obstructions with no warning, and other cyclists are too indifferent to their surroundings that they’re likely to injure the both of us. I need to fully trust that when I squeeze that brake lever that my bike will come to a stop in the exact way that I intend. Including if the electricals fail for some reason.

Finally, not bike related, the writer demonises the idea of making specific streets bike and pedestrian only, banning cars, and even seems to dislike the idea of the 15 minute city, where you aren’t required to leave your local neighbourhood on a day to day basis. This might be coming from the perspective of living in American city where the car is king, but it seems incomprehensible to me that somebody wouldn’t want to have all of their daily necessities easily accessible by foot, and be able to bike, or scoot, or take public transport to pretty much anything else they could need within a 15 minute window. There are both social and economic benefits to this, as it increases neighbourliness as people get to know each other, and also moves away from a small number of big box shops to a much greater number of local green grocers, butchers, book shops, and so on. Reduction of emissions is another huge benefit of course.

Overall I agree with the article directionally but think it gets a few pretty important things wrong.

Re:The Future of E-Bikes by danhor on Sunday January 23, 2022 @08:22AM (#30045944)
> Firstly, I find it pretty surprising that the author would want to remove the drivetrain.

The Author is arguing for replacing the chain with power wires, by generating power from pedaling and feeding it into the motor (with efficiency losses of 5%). So the power split from "human" power vs. battery power will barely change, with the benefit of less mechanical parts. It would thus also work just like a conventional E-Bike when the battery is empty (with 5% less efficiency).

> The second idea in the article which made me double-take is the idea of removing direct mechanical brakes from the bike

Many E-Scooters already use an electrical break (in addition to a mechanical one on the rear wheel), like the Ninebot E22. In my experience, I had less issues with using the front motor to break than many mechanical breaks on my previous bikes even though the communication seems kinda iffy (a bidirectional UART).

I wouldn't want to remove all mechanical breaks, but replacing the one on the rear wheel with an electric, primary one seems like a good idea.

Re:The Future of E-Bikes by pahool on Sunday January 23, 2022 @04:46PM (#30050789)
> The Author is arguing for replacing the chain with power wires, by generating power from pedaling and feeding it into the motor (with efficiency losses of 5%)

My understanding is that the efficiency loss is strictly limited to delivering electrical power back to mechanical power via motor instead of via the chain drive. The problem with this design is that it completely eliminates the ability to deliver mechanical energy directly. The rider pedaling charges the battery which then powers the motor. Going from mechanical energy to stored electrical energy is going to introduce a much greater loss in efficiency than a mere 5%. In a more standard e-bike model, when the rider pedals, my understanding is that they are delivering mechanical energy directly, bypassing the conversion to electrical energy. I may be wrong as I am not very familiar with e-bikes, but, if this is the case, the 5% figure seems highly misleading.

Re:The Future of E-Bikes by danhor on Monday January 24, 2022 @04:37PM (#30064397)
There's no need to go via the battery. The electrical energy from the generator is directly used by the motor, only the excess energy (if there is any) gets stored in the battery. Both generators and motors can be very efficient (and of course the conventional chain also has some losses).

See https://electrek.co/2021/08/31/radical-new-electric-bike-dri...

Real, especially cost reduced, systems could be a lot worse thougn.

Re:The Future of E-Bikes by bambax on Sunday January 23, 2022 @07:28AM (#30045660)
> this had me wondering if the writer actually cycles in a city or not

Yeah, the whole business of dispensing with brakes is absurd. For one, the engine (usually) only powers the rear wheel; if you use only engine braking that means you don't have a brake on the front wheel, which is the one that does most of the job! And two, sometimes you need to brake super fast and I doubt any engine can react or go into reverse fast enough for that.

Re:The Future of E-Bikes by somerandomqaguy on Sunday January 23, 2022 @03:39PM (#30050210)
It's more then that. At least for motorcycles, and depending on the geometry of the bike, your front represents 70% of your total braking capability on a heavy cruiser vs 90% of your total braking capability on a sports bike.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jDGvzy038Eo&t=59s <-- demonstrates it rather clearly. From 80kph, braking distances are:

Rear brake only: 40m (131 ft)

Front brake only: 17m ( 55 ft)

Combined: 13m ( 42 ft)

The issue that braking capability is a function of friction of the tires against the road surface, which is in turn a function of force pushing the tire into the ground. When you begin to decelerate there's a weight transfer to the front tires, increasing the weight on the front and decreasing the weight on the rear. In other words, increasing the effectiveness of the brakes in the front and decreasing the effectiveness of the brakes in the rear.

In the extremes with (im)proper body position, you can lift the rear tire clear off the ground: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2BqCJgTpEf0

So someone suggesting that you remove your most powerful brakes seems... odd?

Re:The Future of E-Bikes by chrismorgan on Sunday January 23, 2022 @04:48AM (#30044926)
> I need to fully trust that when I squeeze that brake lever that my bike will come to a stop in the exact way that I intend. Including if the electricals fail for some reason.

I take it you’ve never experienced mechanical brake failure. It can happen, and is probably more likely to happen than an electrical brake, because of the greater forces applied on the flimsier brake cable.

One of my sisters once was riding her bicycle to school, which had only one operable brake at the time—the other was ineffective for some reason and she hadn’t mentioned this to us, so it didn’t get fixed. Well, going down the final hill, the brake cable snapped; and when she reached the bottom of the hill where you turn onto the campus, she panicked and turned despite her speed, and so tumbled over a low brick wall at the gate and broke an arm, rather than just going up the other side of the hill until she stopped.

Re:The Future of E-Bikes by jacquesm on Sunday January 23, 2022 @05:47AM (#30045207)
Brake cables need periodical exchanging. Many people don't do this for some reason. A well maintained brake cable will support your whole weight, one that is ignored for a decade or so will snap when you need it most.

There is no periodical roadworthyness review for bicylces, if I look at the things people sometimes cycle on I shudder. Broken / not properly tensioned spokes, cracked rims, missing brake pads, brakes not working at all, fixies, broken ball bearings, skipping chains etc. Bikes need maintenance, like every other vehicle.

Re:The Future of E-Bikes by chrismorgan on Sunday January 23, 2022 @06:36AM (#30045439)
> for some reason

(a) it takes effort; (b) it’s working, right? so why would I spend $6 + my own labour, or probably $50 for someone else to do it, on a new cable?

You are quite right that bicycles need maintenance, but they work well enough for many people with limited to no maintenance, so that even when they experience what their bike is like when maintained, they often still won’t find it worth the bother. (I would be inclined to be like that if only using the bike for fairly short trips; as it stands, my standard trip is 40km each way, so such losses would become too galling.)

This preference not to maintain incidentally points to a way in which I think electric drive-trains have real potential: they should require much less maintenance, and generally retain higher efficiency. “5% less efficient than a chain”, perhaps, but that’s a maintained chain. Minimally-maintained chain drivetrains will probably have lost that 5%, and unmaintained ones can easily lose 20%.

Re:The Future of E-Bikes by jacquesm on Sunday January 23, 2022 @01:09PM (#30048574)
An unmaintained chain can break, and that can cost you a few thousand in dental work or your life if you are extremely unlucky. Better keep it lubed and make sure the sprockets aren't worn too far (especially important on derailleur bikes).
Re:The Future of E-Bikes by cianmm on Sunday January 23, 2022 @07:45AM (#30045756)
I have experienced brake failure, maybe twice in the more than a decade I’ve been commuting. Pretty scary stuff when it happens, I feel for her.

I’ve always gotten that broken brake repaired within 48 hours (I live in somewhere that is pretty close to a 15 minute village, and it includes a bike shop, and there’s a bike shop a similar distance from my office), and not cycled in the meantime.

I’d find spontaneous electrical failure a much more likely occurrence than spontaneous failure of both independent brakes.