News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by karaterobot on Friday January 21, 2022 @07:49PM (#30031920)
I would have thought it was unlikely that an apparatus as large as the Soviet Union would never have drawn up plans for a contingency in which politics forced them to consider an invasion of their rival superpower.

Not that they would intend to use them, but to have gone to the trouble of mapping the military targets at such a scale, then never spending time to have someone think about how they'd occupy those sites if they had to, seems so foreign to how I expect military brains to work, that I have trouble believing it's true.

A brief Google search doesn't show any (credible) plans, so maybe you're right: but, absence of evidence, especially in a secretive bureaucracy that actively expunged so much of its archives, is not necessarily evidence of absence!

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by p_l on Friday January 21, 2022 @08:41PM (#30032295)
Reality is probably more unrealistic than people think, and funnier to boot.

People who were at least slightly aware of military planning in Poland but not necessarily with the "why" of the plan (this included pretty big portion of citizenry, due to conscription) tend to think Warsaw Pact's claims about defensive warfare were just lies.

Meanwhile the defensive warfare concept was to counterattack once the "inevitable NATO strike against communism" happens, to as quickly as possible take logistic routes that America could use to wage war in Europe. Atlantic is pretty big issue for any invasion not just towards America, after all.

Then you hit the next layer of hilarious misunderstandings (YMMV) which is western planners somehow not getting the memo that Soviet decision makers in Moscow actually believed in NATO first strike (honestly, I don't blame them) and in turn often wargaming first strike from warsaw pact side.

Supposedly at one point, early in 1990s, some high rank officers from both sides got to meet and look at unredacted data about capacity of both sides in Europe, with NATO representative going "oh god, with those numbers you could steamroll us, why you didn't?" and Soviet one being "ugh we could have done with much less forces, we didn't actually want to start a war"

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by wolverine876 on Friday January 21, 2022 @08:50PM (#30032354)
The Soviet Union invaded and took control of many of their neighbors, including most of Eastern and Central Europe, Central Asia (including invading Afghanistan in 1979), as well as creating and supporting regimes elsewhere (Cuba, etc.). When the people of some countries (e.g., Hungary, Czechoslovakia) tried to form democracies, the Soviets sent in tanks. They tried to sieze Berlin early on. It's not at all far-fetched that they would try to expand further into Europe.

Do you have good sources for the claims above? It looks pretty revisionist, and matches Soviet propaganda, to suggest the Soviets weren't aggressive and expansionist.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by wolf550e on Friday January 21, 2022 @09:01PM (#30032433)
Both things are true. The Soviets were very afraid of NATO because NATO was always richer and had more population and industry. So the Soviets wanted a lot of buffer. To have the front far away from Russia, and be able to fall back a long way before being forced to fight on Russian land. That is what the conquest of Eastern Europe was for.

The propping up of communist states worldwide was an attempt to not get surrounded by American client states / satellites / allies.

Look at China propping up North Korea. Why? Because they see South Korea as an American client state and they do not want to have a border with it.

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curtis_LeMay#Strategic_Air_Com... for what made Soviets think maybe NATO is serious about first strike.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by wolverine876 on Friday January 21, 2022 @10:55PM (#30033319)
Yes, the poor victim Soviets. Not expansionist at all. You can make up whatever rationalizations you want, but they did conquer other countries on a scale rarely seen in history. The rest, your claims about their motivations and poor victimhood, are baseless.
Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by the_af on Friday January 21, 2022 @11:06PM (#30033407)
> You can make up whatever rationalizations

The parent post is not "making up" rationalizations nor do I see an attempt to justify Soviet repression.

The Soviets were victims... earlier, during World War II, when their territory was razed to the ground and their people targeted for total racial extermination, and also faced the brunt of that war -- the most destructive war ever -- and did most of the blood shedding. That has to leave a permanent mark in the national psyche. A lot of what they did afterwards was making sure nobody and no country was ever in the position to do that to them, again. They definitely were creating buffer zones to protect their homeland, and I believe most modern analyses agree on this.

This doesn't make them saints. Yes, they were repressive and brutal to satellites they believed felt out of line. But it's not "making up rationalizations", it's what actually happened, and it does explain things.

Also,

> Not expansionist at all

Most powers were expansionist in some way or the other during World War II and its immediate aftermath.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by vba616 on Saturday January 22, 2022 @02:33AM (#30034537)
>The Soviets were victims... earlier, during World War II, when their territory was razed to the ground and their people targeted for total racial extermination

World War II didn't start with the invasion of the Soviet Union, it started with Germany and the Soviet Union agreeing to dismember Poland, IIRC.

And then somehow or other there was a bit of unpleasantness with Finland, wasn't there?

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by roenxi on Saturday January 22, 2022 @04:34AM (#30035150)
Eh, that isn't so extreme. The most unusual there is that this plan to partition a country didn't have a British or French representative at the negotiating table.

The Soviet Union was a disaster, and certainly the they did a lot of things to other countries that they shouldn't have. But they were a clear victim in WWII; the amount of blood they shed was absolutely unreal.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by Shared404 on Saturday January 22, 2022 @08:31AM (#30036430)
I apologize in advance, I'm about to be somewhat pedantic.

>But they were a clear victim in WWII; the amount of blood they shed was absolutely unreal.

If I've understood your intent correctly, you probably want "...the amount of their blood that was shed...". My understanding of "blood they shed was absolutely unreal" would be that they were killing others in massive amounts.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by vba616 on Saturday January 22, 2022 @04:43AM (#30035195)
Is it false to say that Germany only was able to invade because of their ability to import Soviet resources due to the pact?
Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by the_af on Saturday January 22, 2022 @07:43AM (#30036184)
Yes, I would say it's false.

It also misrepresents the nature of the relationship between the two powers. Germany was gearing for war against the Soviet Union, it was the sine qua non of Hitler's plan, which he even detailed in writing years before.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by vba616 on Saturday January 22, 2022 @11:02PM (#30043526)
>Yes, I would say it's false.

Have you any comments to make about these:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German%E2%80%93Soviet_Credit_A...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German%E2%80%93Soviet_Commerci...

"there is one common element in the ideology of Germany, Italy and the Soviet Union: opposition to the capitalist democracies"

>It also misrepresents the nature of the relationship between the two powers.

How? As you say, Germany was gearing for war, how does that contradict the Soviet Union supplying them with the means?

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by the_af on Sunday January 23, 2022 @08:08AM (#30045879)
Let's step back a bit. What are you trying to say? That because the Soviet Union traded raw materials in exchange for knowledge and tech, then they weren't victims even though 20 million of their people were killed in WW2 after the Nazis invaded?

Because that's the subthread you're replying to.

The USSR was traumatized by war with Nazi Germany and it definitely informed their following geopolitical decisions, so that their territory would never be invaded again.

It seems you're trying to contest this with some weird tangent.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by vba616 on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:05AM (#30059349)
>That because the Soviet Union traded raw materials in exchange for knowledge and tech, then they weren't victims even though 20 million of their people were killed in WW2 after the Nazis invaded?

No, I don't endorse that statement.

The leaders of the USSR, like Stalin, enabled the Nazis to invade and kill millions of people (perhaps millions of non-Russians too) by sending them raw materials prior to the attack. That's not a claim about intent, or victimhood or a personified USSR.

If that is/had been identified as the mistake, it wouldn't seem so logical to build an empire for protection. That's why this is not a tangent.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by the_af on Monday January 24, 2022 @12:07PM (#30060506)
> No, I don't endorse that statement.

Good to know!

> The leaders of the USSR, like Stalin, enabled the Nazis to invade and kill millions of people (perhaps millions of non-Russians too) by sending them raw materials prior to the attack.

Agreed. However, context matters: the trade immediately helped Nazi Germany's war effort, which in turn allowed them to execute operation Barbarossa. At the same time, the Soviet Union was desperately in need of modernizing their army and they didn't have many allies in a situation to assist them; out of this collaboration with Nazi Germany came the advanced tank designs they later used to beat the Germans. Still, not losing millions of people to the war would have been better.

The Soviets knew they were playing with fire. Hitler never hid his plans for the Soviet Union; it was the sine qua non of Nazi Germany, where most of its "lebensraum" would be acquired. But what else could they do? We are playing armchair diplomats/generals here. Remember the world was wildly different back then; empires still existed and Churchill still wanted a British Empire. Alliances that make no sense now might have made more sense then.

> If that is/had been identified as the mistake, it wouldn't seem so logical to build an empire for protection.

I disagree. The Soviet Union had more enemies, of which Nazi Germany turned out to be the most immediate one. Let's remember the West initially considered letting Germany and the Soviet Union damage each other, and saw Germany as a valuable assert against communism. They even toyed briefly with allying with the remnants of the Wehrmacht to defeat the Soviet Union after WWII! That this was even considered, albeit briefly and by few people, shows the Soviet Union was at least partly right to be paranoid.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by aix1 on Saturday January 22, 2022 @03:53AM (#30034935)
For those unfamiliar with the Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molotov%E2%80%93Ribbentrop_Pac... (esp. the Secret Protocol and the subsequent invasion of Poland).
Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by vba616 on Saturday January 22, 2022 @04:03AM (#30034989)
Something I ran across while browsing related pages that I hadn't thought about, is the assertion that Germany got a huge amount of imported resources from the Soviets before they invaded that enabled them to engage in the devastating invasion, as well as carrying on the war with others.
Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by the_af on Saturday January 22, 2022 @07:48AM (#30036210)
The assertion is dubious. I mean, yes, Germany imported resources from the Soviet Union. No surprise there.

Later, they also massively used Soviet slaves in order to fuel their war machine and factories. Without them, it would have been harder or impossible for Nazi Germany to continue the war. This is partly why they switched from "kill all Soviets on sight" to "extermination through labor".

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by vba616 on Saturday January 22, 2022 @11:06PM (#30043542)
Which is why the peaceful trading before the invasion miiiiiight have been a miscalculation by Stalin that led to millions of deaths.

Germany invaded because they needed resources that they couldn't get elsewhere. Letting them bootstrap that into the invasion, among all of the mistakes that were made in WWII, seems like it might have been one of the top ones.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by the_af on Sunday January 23, 2022 @08:14AM (#30045912)
Everyone made mistakes immediately before WW2. Some in the West even liked Hitler. Stalin sought support from the West and was denied; partially the reason for the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact. The British also made mistakes, and let's not forget the French.

None of this detracts from the fact the Soviet Union was ome of the biggest victims in WW2 and that they were traumatized by this.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by justsomehnguy on Saturday January 22, 2022 @06:31AM (#30035794)
> started with Germany and the Soviet Union agreeing to dismember Poland, IIRC.

If 'IIRC' then you should at least check Wikipedia on events what preceded Molotov-Ribbentrop. It surely wasn't a a great sunny day when Molotov called Ribbentrop and said "Hey, Josha! I have a great idea this morning! Let's split Poland!"

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by sozforex on Saturday January 22, 2022 @07:27AM (#30036091)
Well, if examined history starts in 1939, then agreement looks really bad.

If you extend the starting date to maybe autumn 1918 (Polish–Soviet War, Poland's invasion while Russia is in the state of civil war), then it can be considered as less bad, with some justifications that are not out of the historical norm.

Though that Polish invasion from 1918 can be considered as preemptive (defence from evil bolsheviks, trying to recover pre-1772 borders).

Though that Soviet invasion from 1939 can be considered as preemptive (defence from evil capitalists and fascists, trying to restore pre-1921 borders).

Though it is hard to do similar mental gymnastics with relation to invasion of Finland.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by the_af on Saturday January 22, 2022 @09:05AM (#30036696)
> Though it is hard to do similar mental gymnastics with relation to invasion of Finland.

Well, again context helps (like you showed in the other parts of your comment). Note my comment does not imply the Soviet Union was right in waging war against Finland:

From Wikipedia's article on the Winter War:

> "Joseph Stalin regarded it a disappointment that the Soviet Union could not halt the Finnish revolution. He thought that the pro-Finland movement in Karelia posed a direct threat to Leningrad and that the area and defences of Finland could be used to invade the Soviet Union or restrict fleet movements. During Stalin's rule, Soviet propaganda painted Finland's leadership as a "vicious and reactionary fascist clique"

Again, Stalin's fear and paranoia about other powers invading its territory, which in turn mandated creating buffer or safe zones around the Soviet Union. It's not outlandish, given the USSR's many actual enemies and their history of interference within Russian.

His fears partially proved true (with some degree of self-fulfilling prophecy) when Finland played a (limited) role in assisting the Germans with Barbarossa and the Siege of Leningrad.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by sozforex on Saturday January 22, 2022 @10:50AM (#30037663)
Oh, I've replied to a reply to your message. I think what you've wrote is closer to my own perception than the reply to your message that I have replied to.

Context - yes, it helps. Though it is hard (impossible?) to construct an encompassing enough context for complex historical events. And it is sometimes too easy to use partial contexts to to help people to perceive events in the right way.

I did not read your comment as telling that invasion of Finland was right. I do consider fear and paranoia existing at that time about external powers as justified.

On "Appeasement" wikipedia page you can read about perception that "fascism was a useful form of anti-communism" held by many.

And as far as I know, Soviet Union was preparing to wage a large war in Europe (just not in 1941).

Part about mental gymnastics - well, that was about what I wrote about justifications. I do not consider it right to justify invasions. Especially when I'm talking about justifications used by a country I was born in / lived almost all my life. But I felt a need to say something in defence of an opinion containing more nuance (yours).

I consider as bad a lot of things that were happening at that time (at any time in history?).

Now that I looking at the chain of the messages - it looks like I've tried to defend (in my own strange way) a comment that was trying to defend another comment =)

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by lr1970 on Saturday January 22, 2022 @09:32AM (#30036922)
> World War II didn't start with the invasion of the Soviet Union, it started with Germany and the Soviet Union agreeing to dismember Poland, IIRC.

Why not start counting WWII from the Munich Agreement [0] of September 1938 when Britain and France gave Hitler a go ahead to occupy Czechoslovakia? This capitulation by Western powers greatly expanded hitler's appetite craving for more.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Munich_Agreement

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by konart on Saturday January 22, 2022 @01:34AM (#30034276)
>Most powers were expansionist in some way or the other during World War II and its immediate aftermath.

Most powers are expansionists in some way at any point of time in history. I think a quote from "Seventeen Moments of Spring" is quite appropriate here.

(the dialog is between a soviet spy and a german general while they are on a train. The war is almost over at this point):

General: States are like people. Static makes them sick. Borders suffocate them. They need movement, this is an axiom. Movement is war.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4T2s7WM4Uqk (no english subs)

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by p_l on Friday January 21, 2022 @09:15PM (#30032547)
I'm not saying they didn't take control, I'm saying that the reasons for those actions might differ from the obvious take - they were fond of buffer zones, for example (resulting in Finland being "left free" due to neutrality, though they pushed them to arm up - to prevent NATO access - or lose that neutrality). Controlled neighbours were just as good if not better as third world (aka neutral) countries in that respect. N.B. part of the conflict between Trotsky and Stalin was that Trotsky did want to expand the revolution with military force, whereas Stalin proposed "socialism in one country".

The belief about "western capitalism first strike" was one of the major fuels for the paranoia spiral involved in soviet foreign affairs, combined with experiences starting from western support of "Whites" during revolution, through the rather belligerent actions (especially from USA) once Truman was POTUS (and well, all of Truman doctrine and its long-term effects). A non-trivial issue that shows up from reading as stuff becomes declassified is how both sides constantly misunderstood each other, leading to (in hindsight idiotic) situation where initial ideas about disarmament on Soviet side turn into Berlin airlift. Meanwhile Austrian politicians figure out how to get everyone to leave by making the country neutral. It also didn't help that in Poland we probably didn't finish burying our dead in Warsaw when USA drawn up plans to nuke it as part of nuclear first strike on USSR, plans that I have little doubt were heard in Moscow, further fueling the spiral of cold war.

So the end result is a paranoid regime (and from paranoid to controlling there isn't even a step, it's a blink) that, even when some forces try to reduce said paranoia, they stumble upon evidence that it's warranted, resulting in nobody willing to back off (on USA side, you can probably shift some proportions and replace paranoiacs with "communism must die!" die hard ideologists). In the end it's not even one side playing checkers while the other plays chess - it's two sides playing long-distance play-by-mail chess where they delegate their moves to be done by a pigeon[1].

As for propaganda - consider that both sides, to a certain extent, bought into their own propaganda, sometimes even those that should know that a specific aspect of it was false (like JFK strong arming USSR to take missiles out of Cuba, instead of admitting that the missiles were taken away in exchange for removal of the reason they were placed there - which was USA placing missiles in Turkey).

As much as the books are fiction, John Le Carre summarised it pretty well in The Secret Pilgrim although from the western PoV (but similar take could be probably pretty much taken about soviets on the average):

Smiley muses that the most vulgar thing about the Cold War was that the Western societies learned to "gobble up [their] own propaganda." The West became so convinced of the righteousness of its own cause, and the evil of the Soviets', that it never stopped to examine the ethics of its actions. In the name of expediency, the Circus opened its arms – and its purse – to every petty thug and two-bit con man who called himself an anti-Communist.

[1] Referencing a polish idiom about playing chess with pigeon - not only does it not know how to play, it will push the pieces away and shit on the board.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by cycomanic on Saturday January 22, 2022 @02:49AM (#30034624)
Thank you very much for these insightful comments! I think it's extremely important to learn from these mistakes from the past. However I see so many believe in the good vs. evil narrative of the cold war. The real world is often much more complex.
Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by wolverine876 on Friday January 21, 2022 @10:57PM (#30033333)
What you are saying has no basis in fact (and then you bring in actual fiction!). How about some significant evidence? There is plenty of the Soviets conquering and taking away the freedom of dozens of countries.
Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by the_af on Friday January 21, 2022 @11:14PM (#30033463)
> What you are saying has no basis in fact

Which parts? That the Soviets feared a NATO first strike, or at least deemed it a real enough possibility to prepare for it, is true (see: "Seven Days to the River Rhine"). That they Cuban missile crisis was a consequence of the US placing missiles in Turkey is fact. That the Soviets were fearful of the West and paranoid about signs of their interference is fact. That Finland was left alone because of its neutrality is fact. And the list goes on.

PS: Le Carré wrote fiction but also had real insight into the intelligence world, having worked in it. And what his fiction states is absolutely true: the West, in its eagerness to combat communism, supported, aided and propped up all sorts of ruthless murderers and dictators as long as they declared themselves anticommunists.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by Xylakant on Saturday January 22, 2022 @07:48AM (#30036215)
> And what his fiction states is absolutely true: the West, in its eagerness to combat communism, supported, aided and propped up all sorts of ruthless murderers and dictators as long as they declared themselves anticommunists.

For example, western germany happily supported the RENAMO in the Mozambican Civil War - and the US at least contemplated support until the sheer scale of atrocities committed was too big to ignore. One million people died in this conflict. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozambican_Civil_War

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by cycomanic on Saturday January 22, 2022 @02:55AM (#30034650)
I'm not sure what you are trying to argue. The OP is giving some pretty good overview of the motivations of the USSR for how they acted. They never argued that they never invaded other countries. Why do you think they did what they did? Just to be evil? So what about the enty of democratic governments that were overthrown by the US and their allies (and that includes most western European countries) and the totalitarian regimes they supported. Was that also just to be evil?

I guess we are left with two superpowers doing evil just to be evil.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by p_l on Friday January 21, 2022 @11:22PM (#30033512)
And at no point I said they didn't do any conquering and taking freedoms, just like other superpowers that got high on "great game". The paranoia that led to things such as nearly starting preemptive strike in response to Able Archer 83 is well documented though. Great powers don't go for conquering for fun (usually...). They wage wars and atrocities to fulfill the goals as they see them, whether it's ensuring creation of border zones by conquest or making vassals out of border countries, or ensuring they get cheap fruit or ensuring another country doesn't better on literacy tests - none of that excuses the atrocities done.

However understanding the reasoning can help figure out why, what, and how things happened, and it's useful for actually stopping to believe in propaganda and, most importantly, keep seeing the other side as people - even if horrible people (then you might figure out the levers to pull).

As for Carre - I picked it out, because he wrote it better (on basis of his own professional experience, even) than I had the idea for, about believing one's own propaganda.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by dodobirdlord on Friday January 21, 2022 @09:24PM (#30032610)
> Supposedly at one point, early in 1990s, some high rank officers from both sides got to meet and look at unredacted data about capacity of both sides in Europe, with NATO representative going "oh god, with those numbers you could steamroll us, why you didn't?"

This makes for a good story but seems pretty unlikely. Recognizing the disparity in army sizes available for rapid deployment in Central Europe, the NATO doctrine through the Cold War was to stop any invasion attempt somewhere in Germany with large-scale use of tactical nuclear weapons. There were enough NATO forces in the area that invading Soviet forces would have to be concentrated enough to be vulnerable to theatre deployment of nuclear weapons.

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by p_l on Friday January 21, 2022 @09:41PM (#30032751)
The steamroll, of course, assumed that NATO didn't nuke Western Germany out of existence. And while Warsaw Pact returned to idea of Close-in Air Support later on, the idea of making holes in NATO front by dropping a nuke then blitzing through still hot ground held at least to 1989 in limited fashion.

But yes, there's a reason why I put "supposedly". It's a nice story and there might be a kernel of truth to it, but the details probably were different.

That said, a lot of the front line units (especially american) in western germany were there to make nice coffins to mobilize public into support for war in europe (and at least some soldiers definitely were aware of the concept).

Re:Soviet Military Maps of North America and UK by the_af on Friday January 21, 2022 @10:54PM (#30033303)
Yes, Warsaw Pact military policy, planning and wargaming was defensive in nature against a presupposed NATO aggression. The Warsaw Pact itself was formed as a reaction against NATO, which was formed first.

The famous "Seven Days to the River Rhine" [1], a Soviet designed 7-day scenario of limited nuclear war between the Warsaw Pact and NATO presupposed a NATO nuclear first-strike.

It goes against Cold War era propaganda and of course Hollywood paranoid fiction like Red Dawn, but the Warsaw Pact -- as far as NATO was concerned -- was preparing for a defensive war against the West.

Satellite countries and "failing" communist allies are a different matter, and of course the Soviets steamrolled them when they thought it was needed.

----

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seven_Days_to_the_River_Rhine