But this doesn't justify removing every codegen feature. Namespaces and enums won't make your code less reasonable, and moreover they're just syntax sugar, they don't change actual JS semantics.
Besides, there is an straightforward way to remove enums from a program just like removing type annotations: Inline them as static fields of an object.
There is a simple syntactic transformation.
e.g. change 'enum' to 'const', add a '=' before the '{'
and use ':' instead of '='
const HttpMethod = {
Get: 'GET',
Post: 'POST'
};
// now this no longer breaks
const method = HttpMethod.Post;
Namespaces can be translated in almost the exactly same way. const HttpMethod = {
Get: 'GET',
Post: 'POST',
} as const;
type HttpMethod = (typeof HttpMethod)[keyof typeof HttpMethod];
Maybe wrap the `{…} as const` in Object.freeze(…) for good measure.It’d be really nice if they’d improve the ergonomics on this in some way (`type Values<T> = T[keyof T]` would reduce it to `type HttpMethod = Values<typeof HttpMethod>`, which is a start but not enough), to make it a genuine and suitable alternative to enum (minus the other frippery that’s generated) and const enum (because it’s pure JavaScript, not an extension).
About the only positive that is qualitatively different is the simplicity of comparing the output to the input. But for someone building a large typescript codebase, and who uses sourcemaps, it's not really a big issue. There are many many languages that compile-to-JS, and I feel that insisting on 'purity' for purity's sake isn't really a good justification. That, TS as a super-set of JS instead of as a isomorphic mapping between constructs is a perfectly viable way to innovate in the language space.