News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Free mail service for custom domains - G Suite al... by andreinwald on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:10AM (#30006956)
Old emails will be saved. But without attachments.

Is it okay for you?

Re:Ask HN: Free mail service for custom domains - G Suite al... by em-bee on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:35AM (#30007116)
any system that deletes stuff automatically without oversight is dangerous and can lead to critical loss of data.

the only time it is ok is when it is backups that are superseded by new backups, or a trash storage where i put things manually, and even there i prefer to empty the trash manually too.

but this is just how i am used to working. i realize that i accept messages in irc disappearing if i don't log them too (but then i set up logs for quite a number of channels that matter to me), and i could accept this service for certain use cases like for mailing lists which are usually archived elsewhere anyways.

but i could not use it for emails from family, friends or customers who might send me things that i want to keep.

furthermore, if you consider encrypted email you can't even tell what is an attachment and what is the body. removing the attachment would also affect unencrypted, but signed emails.

Re:Ask HN: Free mail service for custom domains - G Suite al... by andreinwald on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:53AM (#30007263)
Thank you for your detailed opinion!

I understand the importance of attachments. But it's the only way to make email hosting cheap or free, bc attachments occupy 99,9% of disk space.

Re:Ask HN: Free mail service for custom domains - G Suite al... by marcos100 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:43AM (#30007179)
No, a lot of times, the attachment is more important than the text of the e-mail.
Re:Ask HN: Free mail service for custom domains - G Suite al... by andreinwald on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:52AM (#30007256)
I understand the importance of attachments. But it's the only way to make email hosting cheap or free, bc attachments occupy 99,9% of disk space.
Re:Ask HN: Free mail service for custom domains - G Suite al... by thunderrabbit on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:00AM (#30007307)
Yes, email attachments take up a lot of space.

But anyone who tries to auto-delete my attachments will never get my patronage.

Why do you want to cripple email to create a free service? This seems like a race to the bottom, with very little upside for you.

Re:Ask HN: Free mail service for custom domains - G Suite al... by andreinwald on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:10AM (#30007389)
Not everyone is willing to pay for mail service for custom domains. Paid email services already costs near or below disc storage prise.

Limiting attachments - the only possible way for free ADs-based alternative.

Re:Ask HN: Free mail service for custom domains - G Suite al... by rosndo on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:08AM (#30007371)
Since when is disk space the bottleneck for email hosting? Do you not intend to offer features like search?
Re:Ask HN: Free mail service for custom domains - G Suite al... by andreinwald on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:23AM (#30007505)
Disk space - is most popular limitation on email hosting plans now. Gmail 15 GB + ADs model, Zoho: 5 GB.

Mail search - will be offered. But old emails w/o attachments.

Re:Ask HN: Free mail service for custom domains - G Suite al... by rosndo on Thursday January 20, 2022 @07:05AM (#30007837)
Disk space being the most popular limitation does not imply that it is a real bottleneck.