Re:Are We Really Engineers? (2021)
by ameliaquining on Thursday January 20, 2022 @01:00AM
(#30005305)
Unless you're suggesting that the word "engineer" is entirely meaningless, this doesn't rebut the given objection to the proposed definition. If the word means anything at all, then the question has to be answered: Is the thing that it means that particular thing, or a different thing?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Literally all categories describing real-world phenomena are fuzzy at their extremes. Reality itself is fuzzy at extremes
Then what job isn't engineering?
By the definition given - "a process of optimization within a solution space bounded by constraints" - a taxi cab driver is certainly an engineer, with no fuzziness. Nor would it be an extreme case testing that fuzzy borders of that definition.
And that's why herval disagrees with that definition. As do I.
Definitions can also be overly broad, which is why we no longer use the term "star" to refer to planets, nor refer to the sun and moon as "planets". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Definition_of_planet .
While this is supposed to be an argumentum ad absurdum, it's quite great. Makes you consider that anything from dentistry to sanitation could really be thought of as similar to engineering and gives a nice healthy kick to the ego of an engineer.
You are right. The output they work towards is a longer lasting item (system).
In my region we always called softies lightweight engineers, although that term is proposed to be claimed by engineers in the field of energy and resources. I think it is still a good fit. Engineer is a very broad term, the knowledge of electrical and mechanical engineers overlap to some degree, but the focus is very distinct.
Otherwise engineer is just a title too, so I guess it is mostly meaningless?
Re:Are We Really Engineers? (2021)
by ameliaquining on Thursday January 20, 2022 @09:17AM
(#30009182)
What's the difference between a lightweight engineer and the other kind?
The engineering part is purely virtual for software developers I guess. While there is some basic physics in most curricula, most computer scientists are a bit "lightweight" on topics usually associated with engineering.
Re:Are We Really Engineers? (2021)
by ameliaquining on Thursday January 20, 2022 @12:23PM
(#30011801)
Which other fields of engineering are "lightweight"? Industrial? Chemical?
No, I guess it is only applied to computer science. Most people sort it more towards math than engineering.
Re:Are We Really Engineers? (2021)
by ameliaquining on Friday January 21, 2022 @09:30AM
(#30023934)
"Computer science" is sort of a different thing and not necessarily engineering, even though the typical software engineer's formal degree is in "computer science" (and also people don't use the terminology totally consistently). But as for software engineering, I think the article makes a really solid case that electrical, chemical, and industrial engineering don't have anything relevant in common that software engineering doesn't, so putting the latter in a separate "lightweight engineering" category just isn't right.