Re:IRS Will Soon Require Selfies for Online Access
by gumby on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @01:12PM
(#29997583)
The case that a universal identifier, or even some authoritative list of people, has a benefit that exceeds its cost, has never been made. It’s simply “one of those things”
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:IRS Will Soon Require Selfies for Online Access
by Lammy on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @01:31PM
(#29997886)
"The invention of permanent, inherited patronyms was, after the administrative simplification of nature (for example, the forest) and space (for example, land tenure), the last step in establishing the necessary preconditions of modern statecraft. In almost every case it was a state project, designed to allow officials to identity, unambiguously, the majority of its citizens. When successful, it went far to create a legible people. Tax and tithe rolls, property rolls, conscription lists, censuses, and property deeds recognized in law were inconceivable without some means of fixing an individual's identity and linking him or her to a kingroup. Campaigns to assign permanent patronyms have typically taken place, as one might expect, in the context of a state's exertions to put its fiscal system on a sounder and more lucrative footing. Fearing, with good reason, that an effort to enumerate and register them could be a prelude to some new tax burden or conscription, local officials and the population at large often resisted such campaigns."
— James C Scott, Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed
(Thanks shoo — https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29885742)
Re:IRS Will Soon Require Selfies for Online Access
by jdmichal on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @01:28PM
(#29997844)
The problem with SSNs is that places treat it like a secret, when it's an identifier. They were not designed to be a secret, and obviously are a pretty terrible secret at this point in time. What with the fact that probably every person older than 18 has had theirs leaked at some point in time.]
If places would just stop treating them as a secret, it wouldn't even matter.