News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Eyeo wins German copyright decision, sets legal precedent... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:20PM (#29983372)
> As for selling a modified version, if it isn't modified enough than you still infringe copyright of the original author. With "enough" being something that needs to be defended in court if challenged.

Hang on. Does "modified version" mean the same physical copy I bought and then modified, or a copy I made myself and then modified?

The way you worded that sounds like you're talking about both, but the former makes no sense. Why would it be a copyright violation to buy a book, white-out one sentence, and resell it? And elsjaako was definitely talking about the former.

Re:Eyeo wins German copyright decision, sets legal precedent... by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:46PM (#29984671)
> Why would it be a copyright violation to buy a book, white-out one sentence, and resell it? //

Because of exhaustion of rights working on first sale of right to _make_ derivative copyright works not being exhausted on sale.

In USA under Fair Use you have pretty liberal rights compared to most other copyright regimes AFAICT. In the UK we don't have rights, not even under Fair Dealing, to modify works, never mind sell modified works (without permission of the copyright holder); they made an exception to allow caching to make web browsing lawful!

I can't buy your book, edit out part I don't like and resell it as your book, and I can't sell it as my book without your permission. Not even one copy. That's reasonable to me (unless there was a [implied] license for modifications to be made, say). I should of course be allowed to modify the physical copy I purchased as that's ordinary use and copyright shouldn't interfere with that.

Re:Eyeo wins German copyright decision, sets legal precedent... by elsjaako on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:51PM (#29983887)
Exactly, I meant modifying a physical copy (like a physical book from a shelf in a store), never actually copying anything in there.

I would be very interested to learn I was wrong about that.

Re:Eyeo wins German copyright decision, sets legal precedent... by withinboredom on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:56PM (#29984811)
You must be wrong, or literally every used textbook with notes in the margins is infringing on copyright. Although you could be correct, it’s just literally unenforceable.