Re:Ask HN: Why is spam email still a thing?
by michaelmrose on Monday January 17, 2022 @03:11PM
(#29971183)
> GMail in particular is known to be aggressively negative towards email originating from anywhere other than another GMail account.
This just isn't correct. Gmail does indeed have a HUGE market share at around 20-30% depending on source but with every business using mail for notification and business communication you will note that an even smaller minority of mail comes from other gmail accounts. If Gmail actually worked like that it would have ceased to work entirely and lost most of its users. If I understand correctly the actual issue is all the major players vs very small players like people running their own server.
In that scenario the users whether it be on yahoo, google, msn what have you get 99.999% of their intended email while the person running their own email server will have a much larger miss rate a bigger problem and one that can't be solved on the client side at all.
From the perspective of the end user who is neither aware nor concerned about small servers issues server side filtering works very well. Looking at my spam folder it seems to be filled not with nigerian scams which don't even make it to my spam folder but with emails from people who have send me emails which have some degree of legitimacy but which I have repeatedly deleted unread like political emails requesting contributions. From my perspective it works great.
This just isn't correct. Gmail does indeed have a HUGE market share at around 20-30% depending on source but with every business using mail for notification and business communication you will note that an even smaller minority of mail comes from other gmail accounts. If Gmail actually worked like that it would have ceased to work entirely and lost most of its users. If I understand correctly the actual issue is all the major players vs very small players like people running their own server.
In that scenario the users whether it be on yahoo, google, msn what have you get 99.999% of their intended email while the person running their own email server will have a much larger miss rate a bigger problem and one that can't be solved on the client side at all.
From the perspective of the end user who is neither aware nor concerned about small servers issues server side filtering works very well. Looking at my spam folder it seems to be filled not with nigerian scams which don't even make it to my spam folder but with emails from people who have send me emails which have some degree of legitimacy but which I have repeatedly deleted unread like political emails requesting contributions. From my perspective it works great.