News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by Gigachad on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:57PM (#29959954)
What is the solution here? Do trains need armed security when passing through unsafe regions?
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by dls2016 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:10PM (#29960098)
> But Union Pacific is partly to blame for not deploying more security, said Los Angeles Police Capt. German Hurtado, who works in the Hollenbeck Division.

Half-way through the article we get the point. This is just another example of how our retail supply lines are optimized at every turn to shovel maximum crap through the pipe... be it minimally-staffed stores or unsecured trains. It's all about cash flow, baby!

Let the market fix the problem.

Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by flyinglizard on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:14PM (#29960801)
Optimization is good. It means everything is efficient, cheaper, more abundant and new things can be built on top of old things. It's a wonderful quality.

Now, in which first world country do freight train need guards across their route? And it's not like the train is being hit in the middle of the desert, Breaking Bad style. There are few spots where this happened.

It seems to me like police across the US are either scared of doing their job or simply don't care, together with a public which has been desensitized to crime.

Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by Syonyk on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:56PM (#29961259)
> efficient

"Efficient" in terms of what outputs, relative to what inputs?

Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by flyinglizard on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:13PM (#29961412)
Efficient in respect to the meaning imparted by the comment I responded to, of course.
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by ALittleLight on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:39PM (#29960405)
How can the market fix the problem? Some people aren't abiding by the market so how could the market constrain them? It's like advising a chess player to just play better when his opponent is snatching his pieces off the board - that might not work.

If the market reacts by making it harder to steal, then presumably this will increase the cost of goods which will, presumably, increase the value of stealing them. The market doesn't have a lot of options that I can see.

Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by walkhour on Monday January 17, 2022 @04:03AM (#29964698)
> If the market reacts by making it harder to steal, then presumably this will increase the cost of goods which will, presumably, increase the value of stealing them. The market doesn't have a lot of options that I can see.

These increases needn't be the same. It could be that by increasing the security budget 10%, theft decreased by 90%, and prize increased by 1%, which wouldn't be high enough to create a "theft demand". It could also be that the same security budget increase did nothing on the theft rate. My point is this is not necessarily how the market works.

This is similar to the argument that taxes increase the cost of products, which increases the cost of running the government (since the government consumes free market products), which will require more taxes. This needn't be the case.

In any case, there are and have been societies with more inequality and poverty than USA where there was less crime. Obviously nobody wants those solutions in USA but the market would find its was absent regulation in this case.

Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by dls2016 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:48PM (#29960506)
Retail and supply chain theft will always be a cat and mouse game.

This is not an issue for which society/government should pay the cost to fix it (which you seem to imply by saying the markets have no options).

Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by solveit on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:32PM (#29960994)
Enforcement of property rights is basically the textbook example of a government function. Or do you want logistics companies to hire private armies?
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by dls2016 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:39PM (#29961099)
Railroads already have police, armored cars are allowed armed guards (as do other high-value shipments, I'm sure), retail stores have security (however neutered they may be).

I don't see why shoplifters are thrown in jail and wage thieves are not. Why do cops gun down shoplifters but won't lift a finger for wage thieves? Why don't cops bust down the doors of polluters? It's the selective enforcement of property rights I have a problem with. The enforcers already side with capital 9 times out of 10.

Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by solveit on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:37PM (#29961602)
I understand that you have justified complaints, but saying stupid things (government should not go after retail and supply chain theft) in order to take potshots against "capital" does not make a good conversation and I would rather see less of it on HN. Obviously you want shoplifters to be prosecuted as well as wage thieves and polluters.
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by dls2016 on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @09:13PM (#30003501)
The original articles on this are already very sympathetic to capital, and so that’s the direction of my criticism. The story suggests we should feel bad for the railroad companies without any investigating whether the company itself could share some of the blame. Today there’s a story about how UP cut many of their security employees.

The original articles and discussion here on HN is surprisingly one-sided.

Obviously I don’t like railroad theft but let’s not send in the army to protect a supply chain which has perhaps been made too efficient.

Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by ajsnigrutin on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:45PM (#29961170)
The government has a legal monopoly on many things, including putting people behind bars. If you pay taxes, you'd expect them to "do something", because if they don't, where's the point in paying those taxes?
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by ultrarunner on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:59PM (#29961295)
The point for those paying, or those collecting?
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by ALittleLight on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:30PM (#29960975)
The idea that government shouldn't be the party to address crime seems very foreign and wrong to me. We shouldn't want private companies handling crime and punishment. That is a role for government.
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by dls2016 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:42PM (#29961134)
Government or police? Government enforces pollution laws and will step in over wage theft. But you can't call 911 and say "my boss stole from my paycheck!" whereas that happens all the time with shoplifting.

Why must the government step in when these skeleton-crewed retail stores and supply chains have inevitable, predictable loss issues? The article itself makes this point.

Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by CameronNemo on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:16PM (#29960164)
The trains already have their own police force from what I read in the tweets from a couple days ago.
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by ALittleLight on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:39PM (#29960412)
Their police force seems really bad.
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by selimthegrim on Sunday January 16, 2022 @06:02PM (#29961323)
For $20/hour do _you_ want to be on the news for having shot someone over toilet paper?
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by newsclues on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:15PM (#29960146)
Restore law and order to society.
[dead]
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by goldenchrome on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:20PM (#29960207)
It appears that you're shielding criminals behind mental illness, and making light of the plight of the victims by suggesting that they're wealthy elite. Most of the packages stolen off the trains belong to regular folks.
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by Hokusai on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:26PM (#29960269)
Seems that you don't care for poor people as far as your stuff is safe, and that violence is your solution to complex problems.
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by goldenchrome on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:34PM (#29960347)
Not all poor people are thieves. I didn't suggest that violence was the solution.
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by Gigachad on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:55PM (#29960609)
It's pretty offensive to categorize poor people as thieves. There are plenty of poor people with ethics and integrity.
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by dallashoxton on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:02PM (#29960676)
Violence indeed would solve the problem of rail theft though. Don't want to get shot? Don't try to steal from a train.
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by kfarr on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:09PM (#29960086)
Agreed. The solution is building more housing and expanding UBI, not guns.
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by kfarr on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:29PM (#29960299)
Curious why people are downvoting this. Do you really think the people stealing these goods prefer to be doing this compared to other options available to you and me?
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by john_moscow on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:17PM (#29960837)
People resort to stealing when they have unsatisfied ambition. When they want more than they have, and don't see a legal way to get it. If every job available to you is minimum wage where you don't make any noticeable difference, you resort to making that difference elsewhere.

UBI won't solve this problem. It will skyrocket the rent/food prices due to supply/demand mechanics and further entrench stockholders/real estate owners vs. the salary/rent class. And even if you somehow solve that (somehow get free food/housing for everyone), you will still end up with plenty of depressed people with plenty of free time and a strong belief that someone else is hiding a patch of greener grass under their carpet.

On the other hand, if you modify the tax rules to make corporations and large chains less viable than small businesses (i.e. forcing most of the population to work for themselves and trade with their peers, rather than following the corporate manual), people will suddenly start respecting each other more and will pressure the victim mentality folks to sober up and join the ranks.

But that's not going to happen, because all 3 branches of power + the media are controlled by the shareholder class, that will swiftly redirect any dangerous leanings to the direction bringing them further profit (remember how BLM conveniently diverted the "protestor type" from Occupy Wall Street?). So don't be surprised if having a mailing address will soon count as a privilege and your workplace will offer mandatory trainings asking you to denounce it in the name of all good against all evil.

Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by Hokusai on Monday January 17, 2022 @12:16AM (#29963553)
> The sad part of this situation is the initial people that broke into the containers on the trains are long gone with their loot, now the marginalized people are getting caught digging through the discarded items that were not valuable enough for ones that broke in and most likely they will be the ones prosecuted for political gains even if they get out on no cash bail.

I did not realize that. It makes it even more of a sad situation.

Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by josephcsible on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:22PM (#29960892)
> If every job available to you is minimum wage

Which isn't the case for anyone in this labor shortage. There's plenty of employers willing to pay more than double that who still can't find unskilled workers.

Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by john_moscow on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:31PM (#29960983)
It's trickier then just the paycheck. People have an inherent need of seeing their actions slowly making a progress to some global goal. Saving for retirement could be one. Paying off your mortgage, or growing your business, or raising your kids, or even having a meaningful career (that gives you more control over the company's decisions) could be another one.

If everyone is replaceable and the salary only covers recurring expenses, people go nuts and start looking elsewhere. A lot of the visible homeless lifestyle is a (petty) power to inconvenience others. A lot of the theft is about the power over someone else to get what was intended for them.

Opening your own bakery and turning people into recurring customers through clever recipes scratches the same itch, but makes the society a much more pleasant place to live. Except, given the interest rates, centralized suppliers and property prices, good fucking luck with that.

Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by moralestapia on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:33PM (#29961010)
Oh, really? I know plenty of people with amazing credentials who are being let go like nothing. That's empirical and n=1, but that's what I see from where I'm at.
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by josephcsible on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:34PM (#29961024)
I believe that you know people who are being let go. I don't believe that those people can't find any new jobs that pay more than minimum wage.
Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by dallashoxton on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:08PM (#29960737)
Because the idea that property laws shouldn't be enforced and that the response to property crime is to give the thieves more stuff (housing and UBI) is a perverse incentive and a recipe for a lawless society where criminality is rewarded.

This isn't an argument against UBI or expanding housing per se, it's an argument against the people saying property laws should not be enforced because the criminals are poor.

Re:Rail Theft Soars in California by ryan93 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:53PM (#29960580)
Yes based on the wildly different behavior between them and the average programmer. Why would you expect them to have the same preferences and inclinations in life?