News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by BoiledCabbage on Saturday January 15, 2022 @02:32AM (#29944477)
I'm trying to understand.

You're saying that you wouldn't be able to perform online votes or surveys and remotely send money without a blockchain?

Could you expand more on what functionality that the blockchain provides that the other solutions in this space (online surveys and remotely send money) don't?

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by neiman on Saturday January 15, 2022 @02:52AM (#29944592)
Sure.

"Remotely send money" is a super hard thing to do. I literally just struggled for a month with a transfer that included 3 countries, none of them is English speaking. It required letters from banks, accountants, plenty of forms of different countries, translations, stuff which is lost in translation (the bank was unhappy with the word selection of a non-English speaker accountant, for example), different formats, different standards and navigating countless options and tricks in order to avoid ridiculous exchange and transfer fees.

This was for a "simple" action in the real world, involving me and a regular seller of something. Now take this and try to divide donations between 5 participants of your project, each from a different country and a different language. Good luck with that.

Hwoever, in my open source project we did the same thing in 20 seconds with crypto. Not because we avoid tax (we don't), but because the international mechanism is cumbersome and inaccessible if you're not an expert, and expensive probably even if you are.

We manage the donations/profits with votings, and are not familiar with a platform offering a safe way to do that in our settings.

Besides, my experience with platforms for open source projects (or in general) is bad. There is no one platform offering all the services we need, so we end up having dozens of accounts (which is actually a source of tension, because when you offer to use a new platform, an argument starts with those who "have enough accounts in their life"). Moreover, platforms eventually close, so you get stuck (migration is a hard thing to do).

Let me ask a question that maybe will look at it from a different angle. Which problems remotely sending money and online platforms solve that crypto has for managing votings and finance of an international online open source project? Seems to me it beings 100% extra problems and 0% solutions.

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by eterm on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:02AM (#29944652)
> "Remotely send money" is a super hard thing to do.

Technologically it is not.

Which is why anyone in the EU can instantly send money to anywhere else in the EU, for free, despite being a collection of 27 countries with dozens of different languages and legacy banking systems.

The hurdles are legal and regulatory, not technical.

Blockchain and new technology does not solve the underlying problem at all.

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by neiman on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:13AM (#29944723)
Part of the transaction I described (which was personal) involved a bank transfer between two EU states, and it's simply not true. It's not instantly, doesn't work 24/7 (a transaction made on Friday arrived on Tuesday), and you have to find plenty of tricks to avoid high fees and super bad exchange rates (EU has more than one currency, you know).
Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by Atropos on Saturday January 15, 2022 @07:45AM (#29945922)
You are correct, the technology for 24/7 SEPA instant transfers is there, but they are just ~ 10% of all SEPA transfers right now and - crucially - are not free yet: https://www.europeanpaymentscouncil.eu/what-we-do/sepa-insta...

Free instant transfers are the direction of travel, but in the EU, that is a question of regulation, not technology. Maybe in 2030 we will be there :)

But for many transactions, I see that instant would be nicer, but I don't see the crucial need. My employer pays all Eurozone salaries from a bank account in Luxembourg, I imagine it is just a script checking "Initiate transfers on 10 AM, 1 day before last working day of month". Being able to do "Initiate transfers on 23.59 PM of last working day of month" would be slightly nicer, but I don't think it really solves a huge pain point?

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by piva00 on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:26AM (#29944794)
Wise (former Transferwise) is pretty much instant in the EU, with very low fees.

Even then, transferring money with SEPA from my Swedish account to friends in Germany, Poland and the Netherlands is pretty much instant, I just don't like the exchange rate of my bank.

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by neiman on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:34AM (#29944832)
Wise (Germany->Poland) is the one who took me 4 days (Friday->Tuesday)...

I have no idea how you did an instant transfer from Sweden to Poland.

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by faeyanpiraat on Saturday January 15, 2022 @04:56AM (#29945203)
It might depend on the amount.

Wise might not had the liquidity in your currency pair, and you had to wait for a transaction to happen in the reverse direction.

(Just speculation)

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by EUFintecheer on Saturday January 15, 2022 @05:20AM (#29945281)
Uh, oh, will … no.

Its Not true in that Description, also dont forget: SEPA!=Euro!=EU!=EER

Source: Im running a bank. In the EU.

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by eterm on Saturday January 15, 2022 @07:35AM (#29945883)
Okay sure, but the point is that the solution is that is "Expand SEPA / faster payments system" not, "We need new technology".

It's a political problem not a technological one.

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by neiman on Saturday January 15, 2022 @10:49AM (#29947248)
It's a technological problem. The SEPA system relies on MANY providers giving a many services. Replaces it with a technology that doesn't rely on any providers but instead allowing direct transfer of money from one person to another, and by almost by definition it'll be faster.
Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by democracy on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:53AM (#29944931)
What's wrong with paypal?
Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by mateuszf on Saturday January 15, 2022 @07:11AM (#29945783)
You can find lot of stories of them blocking your account without explanation and taking the money.
Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by democracy on Saturday January 15, 2022 @08:09AM (#29946047)
Maybe for a reason, no?
Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by neiman on Saturday January 15, 2022 @10:50AM (#29947255)
I envy you for believing that big companies, like Paypal, always do things to small customers for a reason. Really.
Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by democracy on Saturday January 15, 2022 @08:15PM (#29952294)
It doesn't matter what I believe, it's what I experienced and observed. For example, I knew a couple who lost their money via fraudulent debit card transactions and bank did piss all to investigate - and I understand its hard and bank is not motivated much. By using a credit card for example fraudsters would've spent bank's money and my friends would not be responsible for such transactions. Now if they used crypto they would be in the same position and there wouldn't even be an authority to ask to investigate (how convenient). I am not saying that people are not getting ripped by corp - just by probability many people are. But I don't see "crypto" as the answer to the problems I know about. What specific problem crypto solves in payments?
Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by trenchgun on Saturday January 15, 2022 @04:17AM (#29945036)
That is not correct.

Source: recently received money sent by a friend from another EU country.

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by nathias on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:48AM (#29944903)
I'm from EU and this is a lie.
Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by ulfw on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:26AM (#29944795)
But none of that needs Blockchain as a technical solution.

E.g. my bank allows worldwide free SWIFT transfers in many many currencies. It's not hard to find out someone's name, bank account number and SWIFT code et voila... money sent. There's plenty of other solutions from Paypal to (Transfer)Wise etc.

Saying "it can be done in 20 seconds with crypto" is really only half the truth. At the end of the day we all need fiat money. So there's always a conversion step (if not two!) between fiat -> crypto -> fiat money. I can't pay my baker in Cardano nor my hair stylist in Fantom.

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by democracy on Saturday January 15, 2022 @08:11AM (#29946061)
I think the crypto shills for the "bank the unbanked" and "international money transfers" never really did any international money transfers
Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by RandomLensman on Saturday January 15, 2022 @04:41AM (#29945143)
Using some kind of crypto as a more internal transfer and accounting unit seems like a fair use case. And then on/off ramps to traditional when needed.

Could likely be done simpler, but then why not (there are payments solution providers that keep everything internal etc.).

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by neiman on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:49AM (#29944907)
> Saying "it can be done in 20 seconds with crypto" is really only half the truth. At the end of the day we all need fiat money.

Fair point.

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by CRConrad on Monday January 17, 2022 @06:56PM (#29973100)
> "Remotely send money" is a super hard thing to do. I literally just struggled for a month with a transfer that included 3 countries, none of them is English speaking. It required...

But this only shows that some (many?) places are woefully behind on online banking, not that blockchain is required. I can transfer money abroad from my bank account to, probably, yours (do you have an IBAN account number?) with just a few clicks more in my online bank than a domestic transfer. If the banks in your target countries caught up to that (not incredibly advanced) standard, you could have done that too. And I'm fairly sure neither my bank nor the ones of my recipients, nor the systems in between them, use any blockchain whatsoever for this.

So not a valid example that blockchain is actually needed.

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by lottin on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:51AM (#29944923)
Is this money transfer system compliant with current regulations? Because if it isn't, you're comparing apples with oranges.
Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by tintor on Saturday January 15, 2022 @02:37AM (#29944504)
They don't have to trust each other. ie. No need to have a dedicated treasurer.
Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by jhrmnn on Saturday January 15, 2022 @02:45AM (#29944558)
In the end, someone has power over the things in the real world, like releasing a version of the software or purchasing stuff. So everyone involved has to trust that someone at the least.
Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by Thorrez on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:15AM (#29944740)
If the developer introduces a major change, it'll fork the chain. Everyone on the old version of the software will see one chain, everyone on the new version will see the new chain. If not many people switch, the old chain will be the valuable one. So it's kind of a voting system where the community as a whole votes. If the vote isn't decisive, both chains have value.

As far as purchasing stuff, there's no central purchaser that I can think of.

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by CRConrad on Monday January 17, 2022 @07:04PM (#29973168)
> If the developer introduces a major change, it'll fork the chain. Everyone on the old version of the software will see one chain, everyone on the new version will see the new chain.

Why? Can't the system keep using the same chain, or is this just convention? If any software change required a fork, you couldn't do even the most trivial of bug fixes (say, fix a typo in the UI, or whatever). But I notice you said "major change"; so who decides what's "major" and what isn't? On which grounds?

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by Thorrez on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:22PM (#29974223)
It's not convention. If it's possible to create a transaction that one version thinks is valid, and the other doesn't, someone will create such a transaction, it will be included in the chain that accepts it if that side has the majority of the hash power, and the other one will reject it. Thus you will have 2 chains (not to be confused with 2 Chainz).

The definition of "major change" in this case is a change that changes the definition of a valid block or transaction.

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by neiman on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:13AM (#29944729)
Open-source has the great advantage that it's auditable by everyone, hence the trust is distributed.

That's a comment for open-source in general, not about blockchains.

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by faeyanpiraat on Saturday January 15, 2022 @05:00AM (#29945214)
Auditable in the sense that the code is there to read, but the percentage of people able and willing to do so is quite low.

Accepting pull requests is also limited to a set of individuals.

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by CRConrad on Monday January 17, 2022 @07:08PM (#29973190)
> Auditable in the sense that the code is there to read

Which code? Just your client code, or the code that miners and brokers and exchanges run on their servers, too? If the claim is the latter, how do you know that the published source code actually corresponds to the executables they're running?

Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by dmitriid on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:47AM (#29944901)
Ah yes. Unlike that recent issue with a smart contract that was "verified by community" and then drained all wallets of money.
Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by neiman on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:52AM (#29944926)
Which one?
Re:It’s not still the early days of blockchain by dmitriid on Saturday January 15, 2022 @07:02AM (#29945742)
Any of them. There are so many it's hard to keep track.

https://web3isgoinggreat.com/

Filter by hack/scam and look for all "error in contract code"