News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alternative DNS Roots by tptacek on Thursday January 13, 2022 @08:54PM (#29929687)
How would you actually accomplish a DNS blockchain? To run DNS-style Internet naming on a blockchain, you have to take control of the DNS roots. The DNS roots are community property. Unless ICANN came up with some process for starting a blockchain-based DNS, any new blockchain-based DNS would essentially be seizing community property by fiat. Nobody is going to let any private organization do that.
Re:Alternative DNS Roots by easrng on Thursday January 13, 2022 @09:58PM (#29930115)
Nope, sane projects would have 1 TLD they have names under and clients opt-in to resolution. Handshake is awful because it pretends it has the right to control the root and adds TLDs in such a way that there's no way to tell if a given domain needs to be resolved with handshake. Also it allows for numerical names which could collide with IPs. Don't use Handshake. ENS is also bad (no SPV, you usually end up relying on Infura), "Unstoppable" domains has all the problems of ENS, plus too many TLDs, and names can only be registered through the official servers. NameCoin might be ok, haven't looked into it too much. EmerCoin promises too much which makes me suspicious. (Like blockchain VoIP? What?) If I missed any, please let me know.
Re:Alternative DNS Roots by southerntofu on Friday January 14, 2022 @08:14AM (#29934036)
Sounds pretty much like the GNU Name System. With what they call a hyper hyper local root, you as a client define your own TLDs in addition to the root your system has configured (the system is intended to replace the existing ICANN root in a backwards-compatible manner).

Delegation happens via public key and records are resolved through a DHT. The idea is you could add your friend/org's key to your root, and from there you could resolve recursively using your friend/org's zone.

Pretty neat stuff, at least on paper.

Re:Alternative DNS Roots by Hyolobrika on Friday January 14, 2022 @08:44AM (#29934324)
IMO, GNS would benefit from a blockchain to store the root zone. Currently, It is managed by a non-profit. You can add your own TLD but good luck enabling everyone to resolve it without GNUnet e.V's say-so. The problem is making a blockchain that's private enough.
Re:Alternative DNS Roots by southerntofu on Friday January 14, 2022 @09:03AM (#29934493)
I would say GNS proposes an interesting tradeoff, at least one that's not been attempted/proposed by other projects. They intend their root zone to be transferred to ICANN for ownership and for the protocol to be backwards-compatible with DNS, so that moving to GNS wouldn't require major updates from all providers/vendors (unlike IPv6).

Also, the hyper hyper local root and public-key delegation balance the powers of the centralized root. Hypothetically, adding a new "TLD" (for your client) would be very easy so we would probably see more old-style "indexes" sharing zones you could subscribe to, also in a peer-to-peer manner so that if i add my friend anita's zone to my root, i could then recursively resolve through her published index (in her zone), like blog.anita or barbara.anita (a hypothetical friend of anita's).

It's also worth mentioning that this would significantly change the Certificate Authority problem by having a secure network to distribute the keys via DANE entries. It would still be a problem though that anita could suddenly point barbara in her zone to her own machine and serve her own content/certificate. But i guess that's what Web of Trust (or rather Fog of Trust with zero-knowledge proofs) is for? :)

Re:Alternative DNS Roots by WanderPanda on Friday January 14, 2022 @05:53AM (#29932927)
ENS is not necessarily relying on Infura, I could imagine resolution being run by your ISP like it is common with DNS.
Re:Alternative DNS Roots by easrng on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:24AM (#29944786)
Because ISPs do such a great job with DNS now...
Re:Alternative DNS Roots by 10000truths on Thursday January 13, 2022 @10:00PM (#29930125)
I don't see how a root would be involved. As I understand it, a "DNS blockchain" is basically "/etc/hosts, but as a distributed ledger".
Re:Alternative DNS Roots by post-it on Thursday January 13, 2022 @10:19PM (#29930226)
You create a new DNS root, like in TFA.
Re:Alternative DNS Roots by tptacek on Thursday January 13, 2022 @10:47PM (#29930385)
The "root" we're talking about here is the namespace. Creating and promulgating a new one is a seizure of that namespace. This isn't a moral argument; it's an observation about plausible adoption. To wit: nobody is going to adopt a new root namespace that's monetized for its creators.

Which leaves me the question of how blockchain DNS could ever come to pass. What's in it for the project that pulls it off? The answer to that question is likely the reason it won't come to pass.

Re:Alternative DNS Roots by WanderPanda on Friday January 14, 2022 @05:54AM (#29932934)
The project can be non-profit, like ENS was in the beginning, automatically burning the proceeds of the auctions.
Re:Alternative DNS Roots by tptacek on Friday January 14, 2022 @01:27PM (#29938132)
I mean, anything that happens here would have to be a non-profit with really strong commitments not to enrich the founders, or it's DOA. But that's a necessary and not sufficient condition; you can imagine all sorts of non-profit attempts to effectively reclaim the roots that would fail for reasons other than money; for instance, such a project would also need to have governance matching the expectations of the rest of the Internet, which is tricky to do.