News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Losing our product to button syndrome by sundvor on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @08:17PM (#29915517)
Author uses aircraft cockpits as an example of "improvement".

I've been getting back into DCS recently, and one thing that's struck me with the A-10C (II) is just how incredibly resilient the entire design is.

Sure there's a lot of work starting the aircraft and setting up systems etc, and there's an immense learning curve, however you have a staggering amount of redundancy in case of failures, in all levels of the aircraft design.

As a consequence, pilots have been able to limp home ridiculously damaged planes, surviving to fight another day and go back to their children.

Then there's the F-16. I've only just begun to scratch the surface of this one, the simulation is equally as amazing as the A-10C. This aircraft is likewise very manual, but if something goes wrong the pilot has immediate control; in the F-35 (from what I've read) he would be completely reliant on the glass/ computers working as intended / desired, with a level of complexity that makes Tesla's entire FSD program appear as basic calculus.

That's perhaps a big tangent to computing, however I strongly feel that simplifying everything might take away more than you add. The best designs would combine quick, express usage functionality with expert panels for advanced, expert users/usage. This should be combined with a transparency of design that allows their users to understand the underpinnings.

Re:Losing our product to button syndrome by hrishi on Thursday January 13, 2022 @04:41AM (#29918759)
That's a good point at the end, and where we'd like to be. Unfortunately dev time is always a finite resource, especially for an early-stage product. You need to pick one over the other - at least a little.
Re:Losing our product to button syndrome by hansel_der on Thursday January 13, 2022 @08:00AM (#29920296)
> Unfortunately dev time is always a finite resource

true, but usually not the limiting factor.

more to the point; money is a finite resource if the product is intended to generate a profit.