News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lawsuit aiming to break up Facebook group Meta can go ahe... by mmastrac on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @11:27AM (#29908805)
Facebook's purchases of WhatsApp, Oculus, and Instagram probably make them a softer target given how they've used those properties. On top of that, they've had some of the worst overall news.

Why not start with thesortedt target and get some ammunition when you go for the others?

Re:Lawsuit aiming to break up Facebook group Meta can go ahe... by leros on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @11:45AM (#29909187)
Facebook actually has pretty decent arguments why all their products have strong competition. They can also make some arguments about how the other tech giants have much worse monopolies.
Re:Lawsuit aiming to break up Facebook group Meta can go ahe... by DCKing on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @12:11PM (#29909637)
Antitrust is not about monopolies. It's true Facebook is not a monopoly in the classic sense of that word.

Antitrust is about anticompetitiveness. Big tech and especially Facebook is in this new situation where they're causing anticompetitiveness not due to supply side control (i.e. you can get other services that compete against Facebook's products). They're causing anticompetitiveness due to demand side control - the social media that people want to use _in practice_ is all controlled by Facebook. Not because Facebook is intrinsically a superior product (e.g. cheaper, quality of content, technical qualities), but due to network effects and acquisitions of network effect through Instagram and Whatsapp.

We're in a new situation where new precedent needs to be created in what kind of demand side control is desired, permitted and should be dealt with. Which makes this new territory, and it also means that a defense of "we have decent competitors" shouldn't be a decisive argument on Facebook's behalf.

Re:Lawsuit aiming to break up Facebook group Meta can go ahe... by camdat on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @12:18PM (#29909764)
>the social media that people want to use _in practice_ is all controlled by Facebook

Twitter? Reddit? LinkedIn?

Hell TikTok just passed Whatsapp in monthly active participants.

Anticompetitiveness is hard to argue when one of your largest competitors started after all of these acquisitions

Re:Lawsuit aiming to break up Facebook group Meta can go ahe... by ClumsyPilot on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @12:58PM (#29910452)
Kia, Ferrari and caterpillar are not competitors despite all producing vehicles.

In the same way TikTok, LinkedIn and WhatsApp are not competitors. Every sensible person understands that.

Re:Lawsuit aiming to break up Facebook group Meta can go ahe... by camdat on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @08:58PM (#29915860)
But are you arguing that Instagram and TikTok are not competitors? Or WhatsApp and Telegram? Or Facebook and Twitter?
Re:Lawsuit aiming to break up Facebook group Meta can go ahe... by DCKing on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @12:22PM (#29909845)
I'm not saying it's a clear cut case. I'm just saying that we should view this in a different light than past antitrust cases.
Re:Lawsuit aiming to break up Facebook group Meta can go ahe... by namelessoracle on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @02:09PM (#29911426)
Facebooks buying Oculus is kind of a weird example. WhatsApp could be argued buying a competitor. But buying Oculus seems like a clear example of buying a company for its technology because you want to use it. Did Facebook have some kind of competing VR program i didnt know about?