Generally I don't care much about the UI of any of the services offered and being browser based doesn't really make it any better for me. I can do that with spotify and most other services as well. What I would like to have is a simple paid service with high quality flacs that has an open enough API that i can use many of the great open source tools available and download music for offline use on my phone (data caps and all) without jumping through a lot of hoops. It's not music management is an unsolved problem and for local music i have tons of great options on all my devices from TUI applications to applications with great desktop integration to great open source phone apps. With Spotify there are at least some projects that work somewhat but not really well and certainly nothing that i can easily integrate into my desktop or phone without relying on proprietary clients.
But honestly before I go around trying endless services to get a decent experience I'd rather just take the red music tracker test [1] and build a local collection that "just works" and be done with it.
Well not really. There was a great (german) interview with the perfect privacy founders recently [1]. They seem to be decent guys with close ties to the Chaos Computer Club and I strongly suspect they wouldn't want to work like that.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VMr0gJvI-6I
> But if you need to hide your traffic from anybody but your peer on the internet and you need to hide the fact that you talked to that peer, then, I'm afraid, your out of luck.
Nah, that one is easy just use an anonymous sim card or an open wifi and your good to go.
Honestly these discussions often feel pretty asinine to me. I personally use paid VPNs to pirate to my hearts content, work around my ISPs terrible networking and a little bit of geo-unblocking. Of course you can't use these services to protect yourself from three letter agency type surveillance or equally powerful threat actors but if they are "private" enough to block the music industry and their lawyers from suing you that's a pretty high standard of privacy, certainly more than any ISP alone gives you!