News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by demallien on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @02:10AM (#2990186)
You seem a bit unclear about the scientific process as it applies to climate change.

Firstly, here are the undisputable facts - facts that can be reproduced in a laboratory without relying on simulations.

a) Sunlight bouncing off the Earth's surface is red-shifted.

b) CO2 and other greenhouse gases absorb red light more than other forms of light, which they re-emit, often back towards the ground / lower atmosphere.

c) The amount of greenhouse gases in our atmosphere are increasing, as directly measured

d) this increase correlates with calculations associated with how much CO2 we are emittting through the burning of coal, oil and natural gas.

Those are the facts. Looking at those facts, it seems pretty clear that the null hypothesis for climate change is that the temperature of the lower atmosphere should be increasing. We would expect the temperature to rise, unless there is some process that we don't know about that is affecting the numbers

When we put the hypothesis to the test - is the temperature increasing? - we see that it is indeed increasing, which confirms the model.

Now, about those simulations. Yes, they are not as reliable as the science I just when through above. We know that. But they all agree with the null hypothesis that the temperature will rise if we keep increasing the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere. If you want to throw that result into dispute, you need to show that there is some process going on that we didn't know about, and hence haven't been included in the models, or you need to show that the simulations themselves are actually wrong.

What you can't do, if you want to be scientific about, is just state that you are skeptical about the simulations, and therefore we shouldn't act/create policy based on those simulations. I mean, sure, you can hold to that, but you have to admit that you are just being irrationally skeptical, and not scientific at all if that's the position you wish to hold.

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by rimantas on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @06:05AM (#2990717)
If only those four factors would affect climate, you'd have a point. Alas, weather is extremely complex system, and it is pretty difficult to say for sure what is correlation, what is causation. And I am pretty sure, that by tweaking some variables in your models you can get any outcome you want.
Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by demallien on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @06:21AM (#2990750)
I don't think you have understood my point at all. I am not claiming that this is a demonstration of human-caused global warming. I'm explaining why scientists now consider human-caused global warming to be the null hypothesis. Which is to say that unless some currently unknown factor comes into play, they expect the planet to continue to warm as we release more and more CO2 into the atmosphere.

Why is that important? Well, it basically means that if you want to claim that something other than substantial global warming is going to occur, then the onus is on you to demonstrate that there is some other process in play that the current model has failed to take into account.

So sure, there may be other other major factors that affect climate. I have no problem with that possibility. But those factors are a bit like those old maps with "Here Be Dragons" marked when the map-maker didn't know what was really there. As we explored more and made better maps, those blank areas disappeared until there were none left (and we never did find any dragons!)

Maybe this time we will find dragons, and there really is some other factor that balances out our increased CO2 emissions. But for the time being, no-one has discovered any such factor. Is it really reasonable to base public policy on the bet that this time, we really will find dragons?

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by krschultz on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @10:01AM (#2991453)
But you have completely hand waved the argument and its consequences. You have made an argument that CO2 means that it is likely to be warmer.

So? What's the problem? I like the summer.

Obviously the problem is not that it will be slightly warmer. The problem is that ice caps will melt, the weather will change, sea levels will rise, farm land may be harder to come by, species may die, etc etc etc. All of that could end up being very bad. If it is that bad then it is worth preventing.

But how do you go from 'CO2 traps heat' to 'We're screwed!'. That's the part people disagree with. All of these effects are way harder to show in an experiment than simply that CO2 absorbs heat. How do you do a full-scale experiment with cloud formation or the increased hurricanes we're supposedly going to see? You simply can't do an experiment.

This is not to say the models are wrong, just that saying CO2 can be shown to trap heat is not the answer people are looking for. That is well understood. The 2nd and 3rd order effects are what really get called into question.

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by demallien on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @10:52AM (#2991692)
Ok, firstly: "But how do you go from 'CO2 traps heat' to 'We're screwed!'"

Honestly, I don't know, that's why I didn't do that!

That said, with our current understanding, not just that CO2 traps heat, but how much heat a certain concentration of CO2 traps, we are able to anticipate a certain rise in temperature. Yes, there is maybe some unknown process that will interrupt this rise in temperature, but for the time being we know of no mechanism that will do so. Do you want to bet the planet on the idea that there is an unknown process, for which we have no evidence, that is going to stop the planet from warming up dramatically, as our models predict it will in the absence of such an unknown factor?

If I were to say to you "Hey, our current projections show that if we continue fishing Blue Fin Tuna at the current rate, they will go extinct in 15 years", do you consider it a reasonable response to say "Tuna population change is a complicated phenomenum. Maybe there's something that we've missed which means that the tuna population will bounce back, regardless of our fishing levels. Therefore, let's keep on fishing as we always have."? Because that's pretty much what you seem to be arguing for with respect to climate change.

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by krschultz on Thursday September 15, 2011 @09:36AM (#3000236)
That's not what I'm arguing at all.

These models show that temperatures are going to rise.

Your tuna model shows that tuna populations will fall after overfishing.

At the end of my climate model, I have a world with a higher average temperature. At the end of your tuna model, we have a world with no tuna. I fully agree with both of those.

But the consequences are a lot less clear. Obviously a world with no tuna is one where I don't like the menu at a sushi restaurent as much. I want to avoid that, I see a negative consequence there directly related to the model, no other models required.

What is the negative consequence of higher average temperatures? There are models showing things like more storms, higher sea levels, drought, etc etc etc. Those are definitely things we want to avoid. But those secondary models are a hell of a lot less concrete than the temperature models. We might have more drought in some places but more crop yield in others. If we have more storms obviously there is more cloud formation - won't that be a negative feedback on temperature? Those things are a lot harder to show and thats what I don't think has been sufficiently proven.

We aren't really concerned with the change in temperature. We are concerned with the consequences of the change in temperature on the world's weather. That is a significant difference.

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by Fliko on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @12:35PM (#2992186)
Thank you for being rational rather then being distorted to one view or the other.
Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by gavanwoolery on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @03:05AM (#2990313)
You seem a bit unclear about the scientific process as well. Take hugh3's example and throw out anthropogenic global warming. Do the facts still hold?

The earth had dramatic warm and cool periods long before humans, and will continue to despite us.

No one is questioning whether or not humans or CO2 have an impact - we all know that we do. The question is whether or not we have a SIGNIFICANT impact. That is, enough of an impact that we should actually give a damn, given we probably wont be using fossil fuels in 100 years anyway.

If the case for anthropogenic global warming is so strong, why are scientists falsifying data like in ClimateGate?

Much evidences suggests that we are headed into another "Little Ice Age" like in the 1700s. But few people talk about this for some reason.

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by demallien on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @03:33AM (#2990377)
"The earth had dramatic warm and cool periods long before humans, and will continue to despite us."

Ok, what you're trying to do here, in the context of my first post, is make a case for one of those 'unknown processes' that I talked about. Now, I'm all for that, I'm not closing any doors, but if you want me to accept that there is some other, natural, process going on, you're going to have to show some evidence for it. Show me that the sun's output has changed and is causing the rise in temperature, or that the real culprit is volcano emissions, or amoeba farts, or whatever.

"If the case for anthropogenic global warming is so strong, why are scientists falsifying data like in ClimateGate?"

There have been I don't know how many independant investigations (about 5 or so at last count) into "ClimateGate", and they have all cleared scientists of lying or falsifying data. So I throw your question back to you - if this is all a big put on by scientists, why can we never catch them lying/falsifying the data? I mean, we should be able to if this is a coverup, right?

"Much evidences suggests that we are headed into another "Little Ice Age" like in the 1700s. But few people talk about this for some reason." Well, the reason that we don't talk about it is because there isn't any evidence that we're heading back into a mini Ice Age. But again, apply the scientific process to this. Your hypothesis is that we are heading back into a mini Ice Age. Well, the last time that happened, we saw a drop in CO2 levels, which is what you would expect to see according to modern climate models. This time round, CO2 is rising and temperatures are rising. Bearing in mind the facts from my first post, I don't see how you can possibly expect that we are about to head into another mini Ice Age, unless you are once again proposing some mysterious cause that we haven't yet detected that is going to force the climate into a colder state. Once again, I'm willing to listen, but you're going to have to back your position up with some evidence if you want me to accept the hypothesis.

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by epistasis on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @03:41AM (#2990391)
>why are scientists falsifying data like in ClimateGate?

You've repeated this accusation several times in this thread. Can you back this up? I've asked people many times, nobody ever produces anything. They just assume that it was proved, without ever actually checking their hypotheses.

Here's an example of what scientific misconduct looks like, from my field:

http://www.economist.com/node/21528593

The researchers screwed up through basic sloppiness, then refused to correct their errors after they were pointed out. Has there been anything this bad in the the leaked climate emails? BTW, as a scientist I know that "trick" has more than one meaning, particularly when it comes to problem solving, so if you think that the use of the word "trick" is rock-solid proof, please explain how deception was perpetrated rather than clever problem solving.

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by gavanwoolery on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @03:59AM (#2990441)
Really, ClimateGate is the least of my concerns as far as "bad science" goes - most of the bad science is not being hidden behind conspiracies, it is in our face.

To be honest - I do not know if the researchers really hid or falsified data, and I do not know what attempts were made (if any) to further cover this up. But I do know that it did come into public light, and that raises my suspicions a little bit. But regardless if they did hide anything or not, I am more concerned with the fact that scientists are so eager to prove that AGW has a major impact and seemingly hesitant to try and prove the opposite.

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by sesqu on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @05:09AM (#2990598)
The hypothesis testing approach to statistical inference, which is what most of the scientific community uses, explicitly demands researchers try to prove that, say, AGW has no major impact, before reporting on their failure to do so.

The hypothesis of a major impact is suggested because negligible impact cannot be, in the face of data. The popular Neyman-Pearson test doesn't even account for failing to detect an effect - it concerns itself strictly with not seeing ghosts.

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by epistasis on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @04:39AM (#2990538)
Smoke and mirrors, smoke and mirrors...
Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by gavanwoolery on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @03:47AM (#2990408)
Demallien -

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2011/06/14/ice_age/

Here you go :)

I would emphasize that there is no more proof that we are headed into an Ice Age than there is that we are headed into a particularly warm period, I only mention the Ice Age because so few people talk about it. Weather is very difficult to model - we can barely model next month's weather accurately, let alone the next hundred years.

In particular, here is the major fallacy: Even if weather did sharply rise over a century, there is no telling what that might mean for the following century. In fact, if you look at most temperature spikes, they are usually followed by cool periods. It is like saying that because tomorrow is hot, and the next day hotter, that we must be headed into a really hot period. It simply does not work like this.

As for ClimateGate, I'm not really into conspiracies, but it would not surprise me if some scientists had their asses covered. Imagine the people who would look stupid for handing a Nobel Peace Prize to Al Gore. Not that hard to pull strings on these so called "investigations" - everyone has a price.

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by demallien on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @04:18AM (#2990484)
That article doesn't say what you seem to think it says. Or at least, the Register, in their usual slip-shod journalistic style, have been very fast and loose about the sources of different pieces of information in the article. NASA notes that their measurements indicate that the Sun is going into a low-activity period. They also note that the last time we saw this, it correlated to the Little Ice Age. They do not make any claim about a causal link between the two, simply noting that it something that is perhaps worth investigating. The Register then go on to wildly speculate that this could mean that we are heading into a Little Ice Age. I hope you don't mind if I don't take the opinion of a journalist at The Register as a serious scientific exposition.

There are major problems with this hypothesis. Firstly, it doesn't fit with our reductionist understanding of how the climate interacts with the Sun. For example, this period of 'low activity' corresponds to a drop of just 0.1% (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_variation) of the Sun's output - a drop that is too small to produce the Little Ice Age all by itself.

Secondly, even if the Sun's output of energy drops, there is the question of whether it's lower output can offset the calculated rise in temperature due to the extra CO2 in the atmosphere. The answer there is a resounding 'no', based on our current understanding of how greenhouse gases work. So once again, you're trying to argue for an unknown deus ex machina to save the hypothesis.

If you haven't noticed, each objection to climate change finishes in that same way - they all rely on some unknown effect changing the results that simulations are currently showing. Not surprisingly, most scientists prefer to wait for some substantial evidence that such an effect exists before throwing out the explanation resulting from all effects known as of today.

Also, if you really want to rely on the Sun's output to save us from global warming, I have to note in passing that a) we can't control the Sun, and b) we can't even predict the Sun very well (no one anticipated the latest minimum, so we have no idea when it's going to change).

You can poke at anomolies all you like, but unless you can upset the basic reductionist science that I outlined in my original post, you aren't doing science, you're doing politics.

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by gavanwoolery on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @04:36AM (#2990531)
Demaillien:

I completely agree with you on this:

"If you haven't noticed, each objection to climate change finishes in that same way - they all rely on some unknown effect changing the results that simulations are currently showing. Not unsurprisingly, most scientists prefer to wait for some substantial evidence that such an effect exists before throwing out the explanation resulting from all effects known as of today."

We can create all sorts of models but the harsh truth is that they are all very rough estimates. We know that solar fluxations cause temperature change, we know that CO2 does, etc. The problem lies with the measurements. We cannot accurately measure our future CO2 levels, we don't know exactly how much CO2 is getting transformed by trees and at what rate, and we do not know how much CO2 is coming from under-sea vents and how much methane from cow farts. In fact, our models have already been proven wrong many times over, inside and outside of climate research. In fact, 60 percent of all scientific studies done have been wrong. We have a tendency (as humans) to make invalid assumptions and jump to conclusions about data without accounting for all of the dependent and independent variables. There are a ton of variables, and no accurate way to measure all of them yet.

Arguing for or against climate change is like trying to tell a religious person that God does not exist. You cannot prove or disprove it, so it is kind of fruitless either way.

At the end of the day, there is one take-away: differentiating facts from hypothesis. We have a lot of hypotheses, but very few facts.

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by vacri on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @10:41AM (#2991644)
In fact, 60 percent of all scientific studies done have been wrong.

84% of all statistics are pulled from thin air.

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by Fliko on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @12:34PM (#2992180)
This is why we have statistical inference
Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by kaybe on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @04:26AM (#2990509)
As science is done in big teams I'd say it would take a lot to cover someones ass. You usually have a professor, some scientists and a heckload of students of all levels, all interested in finding out the truth (more or less I guess).

I'm in climate research (as a Bachelor candidate, granted) and I wouldn't let anything like that slip, and I know I'm not the only one.

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by gavanwoolery on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @04:55AM (#2990569)
Like I have pointed out several times - there is no (known) truth. There are only hypotheses. You can easily cover up bad data, but you can't easily prove that someone covered up that data.
Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by kaybe on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @05:10AM (#2990599)
You say it's easy. I don't think so, for several reasons:

- If you collect raw data, everyone in the group knows. You can claim instrument failure, of course, but then you'd have everyone around trying to help.

- From the raw data alone it's hard to say what to dismiss. So you'd have to do the long-term analysis first and then decide what to ditch - harder then because your data will be on backup, and you will probably have talked about things with people - because it's a group.

- You're most probably not the only person using this data. As I said, there are students doing some work for you, other scientists in your group using your data.. and everyone would be happy to find something new.

- Additionally, I cannot think of a single professor who wouldn't love to find that global warming is not true.. but I could have misjudged here, of course.

demallien has already pointed out what we know and what we think, so I won't go into this.

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by Tichy on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @04:15AM (#2990478)
We learned about the ice ages coming in cycles in school, 25 years ago. It is common knowledge - I think the climate researchers have probably heard about it, too. Honestly, I am so tired of hearing this oh so clever counterpoint.
Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by gavanwoolery on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @04:40AM (#2990545)
I guess we should just ignore all counterpoints, because you are tired of hearing them. That's real science!
Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by Tichy on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @04:42AM (#2990549)
No, because they are invalidated on the grounds of being common knowledge.

I think your conspiracy should falter if it's details are being told in high school. What kind of conspiracy would that be?

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by gavanwoolery on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @04:52AM (#2990566)
Tichy - I do not think there is any conspiracy around ice ages - all that data is readily available. There is, apparently, willful ignorance though.
Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by gavanwoolery on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @05:22AM (#2990627)
Tichy (won't let me reply directly, think its nested too deep) - "Do you have evidence that any climate researchers ignored the cycles of the ice ages?"

Yes, actually. If you look at 99 percent of studies, they are based on temperatures from maybe 1500 (at the earliest) to present. In geological time, this is the blink of an eye.

Here is a relevant quote from Tim Patterson, paleoclimatologist and Professor of Geology at Carleton University in Canada:

"There is no meaningful correlation between CO2 levels and Earth's temperature over this [geologic] time frame. In fact, when CO2 levels were over ten times higher than they are now, about 450 million years ago, the planet was in the depths of the absolute coldest period in the last half billion years. On the basis of this evidence, how could anyone still believe that the recent relatively small increase in CO2 levels would be the major cause of the past century's modest warming?"

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by Tichy on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @05:30AM (#2990644)
I don't see any mentioning of ice ages in that quote.

If you want to argue that no meaningful science can be done with data from 1500, then of course the answer of the effect of human CO2 output has to wait for a couple of million years. The whole research is then impossible in your opinion. I don't know about that...

As for Patterson's claims, I am no climatologist, so I can't comment. I don't think CO2 is generally thought to be the only thing affecting temperatures. Ok, off the top of my head: it is known that ice ages affect temperatures. That must probably be independent of CO2 (ice ages are not driven by CO2 changes), otherwise Patterson's remark would make no sense. So there is clearly at least one other known factor (the one that brings about ice ages), which Patterson conveniently forgets to mention. What do you say?

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by sesqu on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @06:19AM (#2990743)
Sorry, but did you just argue that there is a slow cooling effect that cannot be seen, but that explains or will soon negate the rapid warming effect that has been detected?
Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by Tichy on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @07:52AM (#2990992)
Ice ages appear in cycles, that much is known. Sorry it was 25 years ago that I learned about it, so I forgot about the causes. However, the cycles are rather slow, so it seems possible that warming catches up with us faster than the next ice age. IANACS, though
Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by Tichy on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @05:08AM (#2990593)
Do you have evidence that any climate researchers ignored the cycles of the ice ages?
Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by Tichy on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @04:01AM (#2990447)
"why are scientists falsifying data like in ClimateGate?"

Um, they didn't. There wasn't really a ClimateGate, either, only some people wanted to fabricate one.

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by gavanwoolery on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @05:01AM (#2990582)
http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/jamesdelingpole/100017393/...

The scientists admitted to these emails.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/earth/environment/climatechange/7...

Everybody seems to love dismissing ClimateGate, rather than at least becoming a little suspicious.

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by Tichy on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @05:07AM (#2990591)
As far as I remember, there was an official investigation into this, which found no misconduct. The quotes are out of context and rather ridiculous ("I’ve just completed Mike’s Nature trick of adding in the real temps to each series for the last 20 years (ie from 1981 onwards) amd from 1961 for Keith’s to hide the decline.") - uh oh, they used a "trick"!!! They must be cheaters. The trick could actually just be some clever idea, which is what scientists tend to come up with to make progress, but people hear what they want to hear.

Becoming a little suspicious is exactly what the skeptics want you to become, hence the attempts to blow those emails out of proportion.

It might also be worth noting that attacking the science based on those emails is not actually scientific criticism, it is merely ad hominem. If you wanted, you could perhaps draw some conclusions from the skeptics resorting to such attacks, rather than science. But lets not go there...

Edit: for completeness sake, here is a random result from Google about the investigation: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/02/24/climategate-investi...

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by gavanwoolery on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @05:37AM (#2990660)
There was an official investigation into the $2.3 trillion that Pentagon could not account for 10 years ago. They found nothing, conveniently. There are billions of dollars riding on green energy, government grants, and reputations on the line. I don't think it would be hard to do a "similar" investigation to the one done on the Pentagon.
Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by vacri on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @10:45AM (#2991655)
You suffer from selection bias. You'll believe any source, no matter how tenuous, when it detracts, but refuse to believe one that supports, citing some kind of nebulous conspiracy. You're behaving in a profoundly unscientific manner.
Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by Tichy on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @05:45AM (#2990678)
Well I think the emails are public in their entirety, which is a distinction to the oval office accounting books? So everybody can do an investigation. Where are the results from skeptics (other than out of context quotes)? I am sure they invested in analyzing those emails?

In any case, you chose who you trust. Of course the impression that you can not trust anybody in the climate discussion is also beneficial to some parties (it is called FUD).

What do you think an average climate scientists earns, btw? I mean, what would be their incentive for faking it all?

Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by gavanwoolery on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @06:13AM (#2990732)
I do not think that everybody is faking it - at most, there were a handful of scientists who covered up some bad data (if that even happened). Most scientists are benevolent - they are proposing hypotheses they honestly believe in. The problem is that they get attached to the consensus because it is the easiest thing to believe, and do not address all of the factors that could be wrong with their hypothesis. Being skeptical against AGW is much harder - I should know. For the first 25 years of my life, I was a die-hard AGW proponent.
Re:Diamond planets, climate change and the scientific method by Tichy on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @07:46AM (#2990967)
What does AGW stand for - is it not the belief that no global warming is happening?

Anyway, this is all just guesswork (what scientists are doing, I mean). More interesting are your motivations for believing certain things. Maybe you need the self-image of being a skeptic?