News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by strikelaserclaw on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @09:49AM (#29892015)
Kinda crappy but i'm sure google has tons of patents on things we would find trivial as well, as far as i'm concerned, let shitty mega corps duke it out.
Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by ceras on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @11:24AM (#29893534)
Not all companies have an aggressive patent strategy. Historically, I believe Google felt negatively about software patents, and had fewer than other tech companies. Eventually they bought a large portfolio of patents (e.g. through the Motorola acquisition; when they later sold Motorola, they kept the patents) so that they could use them defensively, because not having enough patents became a liability.

Even after that, I believe Google only used their patents defensively: they'd only sue company X for patent violations if company X sued Google for patent violations. When I worked there, that was the impression the company gave off, and some initiatives like "Alliance for Open Media" the other commenter mentioned are in line with that.

I don't think Google is unique in this: older tech companies seem to have more aggressive patent strategies, whereas newer (.com era and onward) seem to dislike software patents but are forced to play the game by more aggressive companies and patent trolls. It's a drag on the industry IMO.

The biggest losers are newer and smaller companies, who haven't had enough time or resources to build up a defensive patent portfolio.

Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by darkarmani on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @12:28PM (#29894557)
> they'd only sue company X for patent violations if company X sued Google for patent violations.

That's still a problem. Suppose company X has a real innovation that is worth billions of dollars and google sues them using "bogus" patents? Most patents suck, but there are some that actually cover real innovation.

Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by sangnoir on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @02:39PM (#29896681)
> Suppose company X has a real innovation that is worth billions of dollars and google sues them using "bogus" patents?

Bogus patents will be dismissed, eventually. Going to court means commiting to a multiyear-process with no clear outcome if the other party has a hefty patent portfolio (regardless of how you characterize them). The process is quicker and more painful against those without defense,as Google learned when Apple decided to go "Thermonuclear" with patents.

Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by fomine3 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @09:49PM (#29901680)
VP9/AV1 patent would be good example.
Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by rasz on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @03:28PM (#29897367)
Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by Jensson on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @06:31PM (#29899998)
Did Google use that patent offensively? Google takes on a lot of patents, but they don't attack people with the patents, that was the statement.
Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by josho on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @11:28AM (#29893599)
Young companies typically aren’t aggressive on their patents because they are seeking growth. When their growth stalls out that’s when a shift to monetizing their patents occur.

I’m starting to understand the capitalism is cancer arguments. Infinite growth is unsustainable. So inevitably companies that were once great need to use tactics like this to continue their infinite growth trajectory.

Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by jollybean on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @01:31PM (#29895594)
Young companies with 'great patents' will leverage them both offensively and defensively if it makes sense to do that.

Sonos, in this case, is 'kind of' a younger company. They're not making huge profits and 'free cash flow from a giant' would be huge for them.

Mostly, patents are used defensively, so that companies big and small, don't get sued by trolls or steamrolled.

Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by josho on Thursday January 13, 2022 @04:21PM (#29927042)
I think Sonos proves my point. My understanding is that their growth has stalled out. So, that's why they are shifting to patent licensing. And maybe to your point that's fair assuming their patents are truly innovative inventions that Google is unfairly using.
Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by cma on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @12:32PM (#29894627)
Google patented swapping out the entropy coder in a video codec, which is already a generic swappable module in practically every codec, for another they didn't invent, arithmetic coding.
Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by chaosharmonic on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @09:57AM (#29892136)
That's also a feedback loop though, that exists in part specifically because of how easy and common patent trolling has been. They have to have patents over stupid trivial things because if they don't register these someone else will, and then suddenly it's an even bigger waste of time and money for everyone involved.

There's a reason orgs like the Alliance for Open Media -- a Google-led initiative -- use licensing that explicitly grants you use of the patents owned by member orgs, but also explicitly revoke those if you sue any of them over a patent claim.

Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by mason55 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:58AM (#29893075)
> They have to have patents over stupid trivial things because if they don't register these someone else will, and then suddenly it's an even bigger waste of time and money for everyone involved.

It also works as a way to keep incumbents in power. Say Google has 100 important mobile OS patents and Apple has 100 important mobile OS patents. It makes sense for them to cross-license. But a new mobile OS entrant has nothing of interest to Google or Apple and so no way to get access to those important patents.

Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by josephcsible on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @09:58AM (#29892142)
> let shitty mega corps duke it out

The problem with that is that we the customers end up as collateral damage.

Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by mtarnovan on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @12:06PM (#29894215)
Exactly. Case in point: Sonos not getting along with Google means the Youtube Music app doesn't allow casting to a Sonos speaker directly (like the Spotify app for example). This means I have to use the Sonos app, which "wraps" the Youtube API, but in a very shitty way (there's lots of contents that I can easily find if I search for it on Youtube directly, but the same search string gives no or bad results if searched in the Sonos app). Not sure if this is just a poor implementation of the YT API by Sonos or more bad will on Google's part (I'm inclined to think it's the first), but either way the user experience is horrible. It's so bad that the Sonos speaker basically sits there unused (even though the sound quality is very good).

I'm not taking Sonos' part here though: like other people here pointed out, I'm pretty sure they patented some very obvious things which they should imo never have gotten a patent for in the first place.

edited to add this link for reference: https://www.androidpolice.com/2020/12/10/the-forced-switch-t...

Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by strikelaserclaw on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:45AM (#29892847)
i've begun to believe that customers have no power in first place. The most recent example being how youtube just came in and removed the dislike count, and no one could do anything, not only that i bet youtube usage hasn't gone down. These big companies are so entrenched in our minds at this point that they could essentially do whatever and get away with it.
Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by makapuf on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @01:37PM (#29895671)
Again, Customers being advertisers and content producers have some power. You dont.
Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by Jensson on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @11:32AM (#29893673)
As far as I know Google are very open that they never use their patents offensively, they just have them as a defence against other companies attacking them with patents. I think that is still true today, can't find any articles about Google suing companies over patents without being sued first.

Now that Googles founders are no longer leading the company that might change, but so far their "do not be evil" still lives on in this regard, at least it did a few years ago.