News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by hdjjhhvvhga on Monday January 10, 2022 @10:57AM (#29876753)
I don't believe it's only Google, and I don't think it's particularly secret.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by gjsman-1000 on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:17AM (#29877070)
The New York Times has had an anti-tech vendetta for a while now. Most likely, in my cynical worldview, because tech has hurt their subscription numbers immensely, not because they want to do the world a service.

An example of this is when they published a whole story about a guy who became radicalized from YouTube... and then became unradicalized a few months later without doing anything radical. But someone could have stayed radicalized so Google needs to censor YouTube and hand back authority to the fact checkers and trusted news, which conveniently happens to be... The New York Times.

Another example would be when The New York Times wrote a whole shock article about the shocking nature of dark patterns in technology and the irresponsibility and corruption of Big Tech for using them. Except that their own unsubscribe system is loaded with dark patterns that are even worse.

Do I think that YouTube isn't partially responsible? Of course they have some responsibility, but The New York Times and other news sources are capitalizing on the situation for their own interests.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by cwilkes on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:42AM (#29877484)
So … they shouldn’t have run a story on dark patterns? Just sweep it under the rug?

It looks like this is the story: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/30/opinion/dark-pattern-inte...

Which I found really well done. In fact I think it shows how one part of the company can police the other by putting up articles like this.

Your comment is like saying only Olympic level athletes can write articles on exercising.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by gjsman-1000 on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:44AM (#29877505)
If I was an ethical journalist, I would not run a story lambasting others for dark patterns until my own house was in order.

And if I wanted to run the story anyway, I would at least mention that my own newspaper is guilty of the same thing for full disclosure.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by renewiltord on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:45PM (#29878516)
> If I was an ethical journalist, I would not run a story lambasting others for dark patterns until my own house was in order.

I actually think it is unethical to suppress news like this, but fine, let's grant it for argument's sake.

> And if I wanted to run the story anyway, I would at least mention that my own newspaper is guilty of the same thing for full disclosure.

Fine, let's see what the article says:

> The Times requires people to talk with a representative online or by phone to cancel subscriptions, but the researchers did not study it or other publishing sites.

Okay, the paper being discussed didn't discuss the NYT, but the NYT journo decided to bring it up. We're good then.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by TrevorAustin on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:43AM (#29877491)
This conspiratorial take is a decade out of date. New York Times coverage of tech has gotten more skeptical, but so has public opinion generally as their size and impact has increased dramatically. https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2018/06/28/public-attit...

Meanwhile, the Times did take a huge beating in the 2000s during the transition from print to digital and with the collapse of classified advertising. But today they're up 1000% from their 2009 low and flirting with historic highs. They're a category-defining digital media company with millions of digital-only subscribers that's on a tear buying up smaller players. https://www.google.com/finance/quote/NYT:NYSE?sa=X&ved=2ahUK...

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by dogleash on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:02PM (#29877810)
>The New York Times has had an anti-tech vendetta for a while now.

I believe the news should have a vendetta against anyone and anything that has outsized influence and control in society.

I don't think the NYT has the domain experience or insight to present the most damning critiques of big tech. I think that even when they get a chance, they'll prefer hot button topics over than the meatier but less sexy lines of criticism. I often think their motivations for articles are suspect.

However, even with all that said, media orgs like theirs are still the closest thing we have to a check on the control soulless monsters of industry have over our lives.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by fernandotakai on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:46PM (#29878529)
>I believe the news should have a vendetta against anyone and anything that has outsized influence and control in society.

so, should news have a vendetta against news? because one thing i've seen over the past 6 years is how much influence media has on the population.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by dogleash on Monday January 10, 2022 @03:05PM (#29881262)
Absolutely. And the good journos do have a bone to pick with the media, but a lot are hacks and don't see it or just use it to advance their own goals.
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by renewiltord on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:34AM (#29877359)
The NYT, despite their brand, is not that much different from BuzzFeed. I was a subscriber for a long time and it was quite clear that they were writing the money makers (stories like this which have people riled up and pay attention) to make money for the centerfold pieces (which were fascinating hard-nosed journalism that was very interesting).

I also subscribed (and still do) to the WSJ who are much better about keeping the looniness to the OpEds. They don't exclusively keep it to the OpEds, but they mostly do.

Unionized workers vs Ionized workers is an eternally charged discussion. It's the vim v emacs of the world. There's very little point rehashing things but for some reason, the outrage and hunger takes us and we must participate. The best thing to do is to not play.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by giraffe_lady on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:33AM (#29877345)
I am by no means a NYT-liker but I don't think they're particularly anti-tech. We had been riding on a couple decades of public good will and consistent credulity and optimism from media and the public.

Compared to that it probably does feel hostile. But it's just them being part of the general and widespread shift of more skepticism towards tech's promises and more awareness of its downsides.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by gjsman-1000 on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:37AM (#29877400)
I might agree, but consider my dark patterns example.

The author of the article was super mad, lambasting tech companies left and right for dark patterns, called it a bunch of different synonyms of immoral, etc.

His own paper, The New York Times, has a dark pattern system so pervasive that people here, on Hacker News, had to tell their bank to block payments because they couldn't get to the end of it. I've seen this story repeatedly here.

There's no way that didn't come up during the author's research. The author chose to completely ignore that and publish anyway. And The New York Times chose to make a huge deal out of it. What does that say about their ethics?

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by TrevorAustin on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:48AM (#29877577)
Do you mean this story about dark patterns? https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/24/technology/e-commerce-dar...

Because the author (who does not control how NYT subscriptions work) does mention that in the story:

> About 30 sites made it easy to sign up for services but particularly hard to cancel, requiring phone calls or other procedures. The Times requires people to talk with a representative online or by phone to cancel subscriptions, but the researchers did not study it or other publishing sites.

And highlighted it on her social media promotion of her work: https://twitter.com/jenvalentino/status/1143531833147240449?...

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by gjsman-1000 on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:52AM (#29877636)
I stand corrected, she does mention it.

However, if I were still nitpicky, I would say that her little mention leaves out a ton about what the unsubscribe experience is like.

For example, she doesn't mention that The New York Times employs very few chat agents, so that waiting to cancel takes forever even on weekdays. Or that when you get through the chat, they will offer you a discount, and if you decline they'll give you another discount, and you have to decline that one too. Same understaffing and manipulation for phone calls also applies.

Or that The New York Times has different rules for California because of the law, and allows 24/7 calling and cancelling there, whereas for the rest of the US it's only standard business hours.

And so on...

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by renewiltord on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:37AM (#29877399)
The public adores the big tech brands. It's less "riding on" and more just the fact that outside of folks in tech, people really really like these companies. They are well trusted, people have positive views of the people working there, and people believe that the companies are generally well run.

Almost all brand surveys will have most of the top 5 be the tech companies you know and which HN loves to hate. That's not trending downward. It's trending upward.

The upward trend indicates that it isn't "riding on" but simply being considered good because they are.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by iamacyborg on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:56PM (#29878697)
> tech has hurt their subscription numbers immensely, not because they want to do the world a service.

They can do both at the same time though?

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by rsj_hn on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:04AM (#29876856)
Yes, that companies don't like unions and do what they can to discourage unionization isn't newsworthy. Finding a company that encourages unionization would be newsworthy!
Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by AndrewUnmuted on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:31AM (#29877297)
> companies don't like unions and do what they can to discourage unionization

Are you sure? All of the big tech companies are entering one of the most union-entrenched industries in the US: media.

Re:Google Had Secret Project to ‘Convince’ Employees ‘That U... by xhkkffbf on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:06AM (#29876902)
Exactly. The NYT had some breathless story about this supposedly once secret fact. Yet their own management was pushing back hard on the Wirecutter union.

If the management wanted to really confuse the line workers, they would celebrate the union with some reverse reverse psychology.