News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by ekianjo on Monday January 10, 2022 @08:35AM (#29874520)
> Excess deaths

Excess deaths are not just due to COVID.

Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by csours on Monday January 10, 2022 @10:24AM (#29876214)
Sure. It doesn't matter at a national population level.

---

Excess deaths is an epidemiological measure and should be used for epidemiological purposes - targeting a public health response.

It seems like quite a few people have confused epidemiology, clinical care, and virology. Each of these fields can suggest data for the others, but can't speak definitively until the studies are actually done.

For example, some have said that omicron is more mild than other variants; but it would be more correct to say that the average experience of omicron in the population is more mild AT THIS TIME.

At this time, many people have been vaccinated or recovered from a previous infection, so without some very particular data, you cannot say that omicron is more mild.

Edit:

> you cannot say that omicron is more mild than another variant to any particular person in a clinical context.

Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by renewiltord on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:32PM (#29878324)
The theory of the matter is that you take what's working and you apply it and discard what's not working. The practice of the matter is that if excess deaths goes up due to drug use increasing during lockdowns, the public health reaction is to increase lockdowns.
Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by Jedd on Monday January 10, 2022 @09:01AM (#29874895)
> Excess deaths are not just due to COVID.

Can you clarify what you mean by this?

What kinds of things might excess deaths be attributable to, and to what rate / ratio would you expect?

Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by kansface on Monday January 10, 2022 @02:02PM (#29879866)
People are now skipping routine cancer screenings, check ups, and altogether avoiding any health care out of fear of catching covid. Its not hard to find stories of people with heart attacks not going to the hospital! Kids are missing routine vaccinations, etc. Drug overdoses are up - more deaths in SF are from ODs than Covid last time I looked. Dementia patients and those in nursing homes truly took a nose dive by completely separating them from human contact (they deteriorate rapidly with no stimulation). I imagine lots of people stopped exercising and put on loads of weight.
Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by zo1 on Monday January 10, 2022 @09:21AM (#29875182)
Not OP. But it's becoming increasingly clear (to me, at least) that data about reality has been lost. And no amount of "statistics", "modelling" and accounting for confounding variables will get that data back. This applies to masks, lockdowns, vaccine effectiveness and treatment effectiveness.

Even if we do get a reasonable set of that data back via statistical means, I personally wouldn't trust it. Too many things weren't tracked, people had incentives to fudge numbers, data-integrity and duplication issues, etc. As much as I know there are lots of incredibly smart and educated people working on this, I see most of this as people running around throwing spaghetti at a wall to see what sticks, some hoping to get paid for it, others hoping to save lives.

Likewise for your question. We simply don't have data or knowledge about what people did or how they behaved differently that might have caused a non-covid death to be reasonably attributed to covid. Suicide rates, anti-social behavior of children not seeing people's faces, people hiding pro-active tests, dentists visits, hiding from leaving the house and getting depression, the list is huge and specifically unconstrained.

Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by oblio on Monday January 10, 2022 @09:43AM (#29875503)
You can complain about everything in the world, but not about masks. Masks work, we've known they work since at least 1919. When worn correctly by large groups of people in risky environments (indoors, poor airflow), they greatly reduce transmission rates.

Everything else, you can say stuff about, vaccines have side effects, we don't know if and how much they reduce transmission, treatments are in flux, but masks are a simple and obvious solution with almost 0 side effects.

Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by irthomasthomas on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:03AM (#29876847)
From the only randomised controlled study of masks... https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/5/4/e006577.long

"The rates of all infection outcomes were highest in the cloth mask arm, with the rate of ILI statistically significantly higher in the cloth mask arm (relative risk (RR)=13.00, 95% CI 1.69 to 100.07) compared with the medical mask arm. Cloth masks also had significantly higher rates of ILI compared with the control arm. An analysis by mask use showed ILI (RR=6.64, 95% CI 1.45 to 28.65) and laboratory-confirmed virus (RR=1.72, 95% CI 1.01 to 2.94) were significantly higher in the cloth masks group compared with the medical masks group. Penetration of cloth masks by particles was almost 97% and medical masks 44%."

Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by oblio on Monday January 10, 2022 @02:22PM (#29880280)
Things vary wildly across the world but in most of Europe people aren't allowed to use cloth masks anymore, and haven't been for at least half a year.

They have to wear either surgical masks or FFP2.

Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by swader999 on Monday January 10, 2022 @10:26AM (#29876261)
Masks with a decent seal work and studies with mannequins show this. But in real life, an airborne disease, massive gaps by the side of your nose, wet cloth, rules such as wear it to your restaurant table then take off to eat, it's a pathetic exercise at best.
Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by oblio on Monday January 10, 2022 @10:51AM (#29876655)
Gee, I wonder if anyone thought of testing conditions similar to real life. Nah, nobody did, because everyone is stupid.

https://www.mpg.de/17916867/coronavirus-masks-risk-protectio...

https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-02801-8

Even bad masks poorly worn are better than no masks, and the effect is statistically significant.

Also reducing the areas in which there is unmitigated exposure is a good thing, not a bad thing.

Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by brigandish on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:35AM (#29877372)
> Gee, I wonder if anyone thought of testing conditions similar to real life. Nah, nobody did, because everyone is stupid.

No need for that, at all.

From [1]:

> A recent British Medical Journal review looked at six, fairly porcine, studies concerning mask-wearing and estimated an impressive 53% reduction in risk. But the single randomised controlled trial estimated the smallest effect: a reduction of about 18% (-23% to 46%) in Sars-CoV-2 infections. The “heaviest” studies, an analysis of US states and a survey of about 8,000 Chinese adults in early 2020, observed rather than experimented and its editorial highlights the risks of confounding variables influencing both wearing masks and infections and the impossibility of disentangling the effects of measures fluctuating simultaneously. Indeed, this review found an identical 53% reduction from handwashing.

There is an introduction of Spiegelhalther and Masters given here[2]. It's well worth reading that BMJ article, btw.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/theobserver/2021/nov/28/ivermect...

[2] https://statsandstories.net/media1/covid-by-the-numbers

Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by swader999 on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:42AM (#29877476)
These are all muted by omicron that has an R7-R10.

Sure, wearing a Helmut is safer but if you hit something at 90 km/hr does it matter?

Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by brigandish on Monday January 10, 2022 @10:18PM (#29887004)
So that you may be identifiable? But you're right, so many of the arguments for masks don't hold up to the context they're used in, whether that's for high Rº or untrained non-medical professionals, type of mask, public use, (probably) aerosolised virus… the list goes on.
Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by swader999 on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:39AM (#29877431)
That study proves exactly what I said.

It describes an ideal situation where people are wearing well fitting medical grade or better masks with a virus as transmissible as Delta.

Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by ekianjo on Monday January 10, 2022 @08:44PM (#29886055)
> When worn correctly by large groups of people in risky environments (indoors, poor airflow), they greatly reduce transmission rates.

Not if the time in said environment is long. Also masks have good protection against droplets, not much against aerosols.

Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by Ensorceled on Monday January 10, 2022 @09:33AM (#29875345)
> Not OP. But it's becoming increasingly clear (to me, at least) that data about reality has been lost.

Are you claiming that death counts are incorrect and data about deaths have been lost?

Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by zo1 on Monday January 10, 2022 @09:46AM (#29875558)
Not death-counts, but definitely data about the deaths yes. So detailed reasons for the death, specifics about the death that may be pertinent, their covid history prior to the death, how covid did or didn't affect their behavior that may have caused the death, etc.

Example: Are we keeping track of all the people that skipped a routine test because of covid lockdowns? And then, is there a subsequent record of that fact linked to every covid case of death? Or are we stuck modelling the correlation/overlap of those two data points because we track those statistics across populations separately?

Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by saalweachter on Monday January 10, 2022 @10:36AM (#29876433)
Eh, I think we have enough variation in local responses that we'll be able to tease a lot of the data out with a reasonable degree of confidence.

We're living in a world full of counterfactuals, with some places mandating -- and enforcing -- mandates on various public health measures rigorously, and other places not.

The pandemic also has a time dimension. To the extent that excess deaths are from deferred treatment and missed testing, we expect them to get worse over time -- people missing a cancer screening in March 2020 shouldn't have resulted in excess deaths in April 2020, in the extreme. "Real" COVID deaths meanwhile we'd expect to follow the peaks and valleys of the infections.

It will be a lot of work, but that's what grad students are for.

Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by Ensorceled on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @07:43AM (#29890832)
> It will be a lot of work, but that's what grad students are for.

I really get the impression that a lot of these conspiracy theories are really rooted in an inability to understand how statistics work; and just how much can be legitimately derived from the data.

Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by Jedd on Monday January 10, 2022 @09:48AM (#29875600)
> We simply don't have data or knowledge about what people did or how they behaved differently that might have caused a non-covid death to be reasonably attributed to covid.

Which is somewhat tangential to my question.

Disregard any formal attribution to COVID 19 as a cause of death - direct or indirect.

Parent was suggesting all excess deaths are not just due to COVID (directly or indirectly).

Sensibly allocating excess deaths to different categories is really the question here, and I'm wondering what caveats we should be careful about.

From a terribly abstract perspective, total excess deaths within a population, year on year, prior and then during a global pandemic, should give us some useful baselines.

Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by bena on Monday January 10, 2022 @08:46AM (#29874676)
But the vast majority would be.
Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by ekianjo on Monday January 10, 2022 @08:45PM (#29886074)
That remains to be proven, since authorities have a large incentive to play the COVID-fear card.
Re:Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more tha... by bena on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @09:17AM (#29891674)
What incentive would that be?