Re:Approved Cameras
by chrisseaton on Saturday January 08, 2022 @06:53PM
(#29857997)
How else would you mix the dialogue except to come out of both speakers though?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
You mix the dialog louder for the entire piece, and every other sound in the middle. No extreme highs, no extreme lows. General compression with dialog forward choices.
I don't know why compression isn't built in to consumer media devices, it's so often called for (and closely followed by volume normalisation ... but I guess the advertisers veto that).
Re:Approved Cameras
by chipotle_coyote on Saturday January 08, 2022 @09:16PM
(#29859187)
> I don't know why compression isn't built in to consumer media devices
As always, it depends on the device. Dynamic range compression seems to be a relatively common feature, usually as an option described (inaccurately) with something like "Reduce Loud Sounds" like it is on the Apple TV.
Just make it a bit louder, before summing it into the left and right channel
Re:Approved Cameras
by chrisseaton on Saturday January 08, 2022 @06:58PM
(#29858044)
Right... so why isn't that done already from the 5.1 signal?
Because other times when it's not dialogue (or even when it is--the busy/crowded street effect) you may not want the center channel gain to be raised during mixdown.
Consumer hardware can only guess. A sound engineer can know.