Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop...
by charcircuit on Friday January 07, 2022 @09:13PM
(#29847868)
What's the point of CMYK? Your image is going to be displayed on a panel that has some form of red, green, and blue LEDs. For something like printing a picture you can always just have the printer do the conversion from RGB to CMYK.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop...
by egypturnash on Friday January 07, 2022 @09:42PM
(#29848074)
Working in CMYK lets you avoid the stage where everything looks muted when printed because you didn’t properly account for the different gamut, and because nobody knows how to properly set up conversions.
And beyond that, Adobe’s stuff knows about things like using spot inks outside of the RGB/CMYK spaces. Spot gloss, metallics, etc. Open source alternatives do not.
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop...
by kitsunesoba on Friday January 07, 2022 @09:26PM
(#29847967)
Conversion isn’t a perfect process and often has undesirable effects on the image. This makes it necessary for documents intended for print to be created in CMYK.
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop...
by charcircuit on Saturday January 08, 2022 @12:05AM
(#29848793)
How do you preview your image then? You have to have it in RGB for editing to show up on your monitor.
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop...
by ungamedplayer on Saturday January 08, 2022 @03:35AM
(#29849825)
This is not a discussion worth having, there isn't good logic in any of the discussions with photoshop users, its pretty much going to come down to personal preference.
Re:My 70 year old mother has been using Linux on the desktop...
by bitwize on Monday January 10, 2022 @01:40PM
(#29879405)
If by Photoshop users you mean print professionals, you're right. Arguing isn't worth your time. Adobe has built its reputation around actually listening to professional designers working in the print, film, and Web industries and adding features to their software to support workflows from those industries. GIMP... has not. (As another example also mentioned here, in addition to CMYK, Photoshop also knows about spot colors and can separate those for prepress as well.) Until GIMP gets actual, professional customers and really listens to them, it's a nonstarter in this space.