News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by lalaland1125 on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:48PM (#29842175)
The judge here is being incredibly silly. They are ordering the FDA to perform medical grade redaction on 55,000 pages a month.

These clinical trial documents are chock full of patient data and clinical notes.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by prepend on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:57PM (#29842320)
They should have been designed and planned with deidentification with the expectation that data would be released.

If they are literally manually redacting patient data from pages and notes then that is a flaw in the study, I think.

I would expect patient data to be pretty limited in the trial data since they are purposefully double blind. Notes are a different story, but I’m sure there are techniques that can be purchased for entity resolution that can automate the scrubbing for PHI and PII.

Seems more like the FDA and Pfizer being silly than the judge.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by lalaland1125 on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:01PM (#29842374)
> Notes are a different story, but I’m sure there are techniques that can be purchased for entity resolution that can automate the scrubbing for PHI and PII.

You can't fully automate this because we require almost 100% accuracy. You need a manual review to ensure no data is leaked.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by prepend on Friday January 07, 2022 @06:38PM (#29846537)
I’m not sure why you think we require 100% accuracy. The actual level depends on many factors. For example, the expert determination method of deidentification in hipaa safe harbor [0] can allow up to 1% reidentification and still be considered anonymized.

This is how medical providers share notes without manually reviewing them all.

[0] https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/special-...

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by lesuorac on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:07PM (#29842476)
Would you not use trial data to determine if Pfizer's vaccine should be approved?

The FOIA request was for all of the documentation used to approve the vaccine.

> I’m sure there are techniques that can be purchased for entity resolution that can automate the scrubbing for PHI and PII.

Sounds like a good way to have "anonymized" data that isn't actually anonymized like most datasets ...

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by prepend on Friday January 07, 2022 @06:40PM (#29846566)
That’s part of the downside of “anonymized” data as there’s not any clear legal definitions so it’s quite possible to identify some persons within anonymized data.

I think this is a big problem when it comes to stuff like data brokering and selling. Less so with issues like this because vaccine data researchers are less likely to cause harm to someone than others who buy anonymized data.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by robbedpeter on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:11PM (#29843393)
>>If they are literally manually redacting...

That's a feature, not a bug. Bureacracy is a game, and they are grandmasters.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by anigbrowl on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:28PM (#29843576)
To be fair they were in a bit of a rush, and opted to dump the problem on the bureaucrats rather than spend more time designing protocols. This isn't an example of wicked plotting, it's just an argument about who picks up the tab for a large redaction job.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by prepend on Friday January 07, 2022 @06:41PM (#29846580)
I think it’s also a situation of someone not wanting to release so coming up with a bone headed way of reviewing for privacy.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by kansface on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:36PM (#29843659)
There is currently a government mandate requiring most adults be vaccinated while at the same time, the government (another agency) is unwilling to publish the evidence it considered in favor of the emergency authorization and the concomitant decision making process until after everyone mandated to take it has died... because that's the way they have always done things?
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by lalaland1125 on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:41PM (#29843721)
The FDA already released the evidence it considered for the approval. It's available right on the FDA website: https://www.fda.gov/media/151733/download

The plaintiffs in this case are asking for the clinical medical history of everyone in the clinical trials, which is a bit trickier to provide.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by encryptluks2 on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:43PM (#29843752)
If the evidence references other evidence and you don't have access to that other evidence then you do not have evidence at all.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by lalaland1125 on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:55PM (#29843891)
That's going to be the case for any paper evidence like this, included the 450,000 pages of personal medical information that the plaintiffs want. Unless you inspect the patient yourself, you are always going to be relying on someone else's word.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by rajin444 on Friday January 07, 2022 @06:32PM (#29846468)
Do you ever check the underlying data when you write a database query? Same logic applies here. There’s limits to what you can do but don’t let perfect be the enemy of good.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by mike00632 on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:34PM (#29845822)
So say you get doctor's notes saying that vaccinated patient didn't get COVID-19. What then? Do you need to interview the doctors? Where does the conspiracy theory end for you?
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by encryptluks2 on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:53PM (#29846024)
This is about data used in the vaccine approval. If you think vaccines don't need data to approve them then that throws science out the window and if that is the case then turns whatever theory into an actual conspiracy. Also, do you ever comment on anything technical or is it just pro vaccines and corporate interests?
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by tagoregrtst on Friday January 07, 2022 @06:56PM (#29846727)
The government released a summary whilst getting sued over the issue
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by bingohbangoh on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:48PM (#29842193)
The pharmaceutical companies have had a gangbusters year and we're implementing vaccine passports in places like NYC on the basis of this data.

I think they can hurry.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by Imnimo on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:54PM (#29842264)
These are FDA's documents, not Pfizer's. The pharma companies aren't the ones doing the redaction.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by bingohbangoh on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:43PM (#29842985)
Ahhhh ok, was not aware, thanks!

But my point on this being the subject of a vaccine mandate still holds.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by bluGill on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:41PM (#29843728)
This is something the FDA should have done automatically at the time the issued the EUA or full authorization. That is preparing and releasing all the data for independent review should be part of their review. there is no reason the FDA should try to keep this secret in the first place, and a number of reasons they should make it available.

That doing their job is hard isn't an excuse to not do it.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by lalaland1125 on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:58PM (#29843942)
> no reason the FDA should try to keep this secret in the first place

Personal medical information, especially as part of clinical trials, is some of the most legally protected data in the world. You can't just hand it out to people. And even with medical grade redaction (which is very expensive) there is always a risk of leaked information getting past the filters.

I just find it funny that HN, usually a place very concerned with privacy, is now suddenly demanding the release of some of the most private and personal information of tens if not hundreds of thousands of individuals.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by core-utility on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:07PM (#29844830)
I don't believe he's arguing for the release of personal medical information, he's arguing for the automatic release of the documents redacted of personal medical information. In other words, the FDA should have been prepared for this all along.

Additionally, if Pfizer were to have been told to be prepared to redact PII, I'm sure authors could have easily marked PII during authoring for quick identification and removal. Someone had to write this stuff, it didn't just appear in the ether.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by kube-system on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:47PM (#29845279)
It's not that easy. The amount of information that the someone at the FDA might need to do their job is definitely not bounded by the limitations in FOIA, they need the details. The FOIA process has to happen afterwards by the FDA anyway by law, regardless of what Pfizer provided. Additionally, the healthcare professionals who collected the data are also not qualified to do FOIA compliance, nor is it always possible to tell if a single data element will be PII after it is compiled with other information at a later date, because PII can be indirectly inferred from other elements of information.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by tzs on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:30PM (#29845086)
All the data relevant to the EUA or full authorization is available.

The data not available is personal medical information of patients that has to be collected for and during trials because some of it might become important if something bad happens during the trial. E.g, if some trial patients suffer serious adverse reactions you want to have all their medical information on hand to better understand what went wrong.

For a trial that goes well the vast majority of that information turns out to not have been looked at or used.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by tut-le-tut on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:26PM (#29842754)
"At that rate, the 10 employees would have to work non-stop 24 hours a day, seven days a week to produce the 55,000 pages a month (and would still fall a bit short)."

So 50 people on a normal (40 hour work week) could do this in a month. The FDA has 18 000 employees. I think the answer is clear.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by tehwebguy on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:43PM (#29843743)
The FDA offered a timeline of 500 pages / month (75 years) which far sillier.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by kbelder on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:55PM (#29845375)
My quick calc showed that's roughly one guy redacting 2.8 pages per hour. I know people who'd LOVE that job.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by tagoregrtst on Friday January 07, 2022 @06:54PM (#29846697)
The FDA played a stupid game by offering 500 pages a month. Thats a ream of paper. A person could redact that in a couple days.

The Judge told the FDA to take the FOIA law seriously and, so they remember to next time, ordered them to do so quickly.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by sebow on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:28PM (#29843575)
Standard procedure is being silly?