How so? The law is explicit that it should be just as easy to refuse the cookies as it is to accept them. Companies are ignoring the letter of the law anyway.
They are legally enforcing the reinventing of the wheel.
It could have been done at browser level, which would have been a relatively negligible cost of compliance.
See smartphone connectors where they will demand USB-C soon. When the news hit HN quite a few people were calling EU anti innovation.
This is a massive loophole that the likes of Google can drive a coach and horses though. Doing it per website means that in practice 99% of web uses just press the "accept cookies" button without thinking.
Same with peddling with the web. They ruined the browsing experience for everyone and they're messing up with the market model of allowing people to sell their activity information in exchange for free stuff online.
The advertising model is what made the web possible. The more restrictions you apply to how websites finance themselves the more you constrain the web to be built by big actors with money and stifle innovation.
Can you expand on that? If you mean the GDPR, my reading is that it is unlawful to collect identifiable user data without informed consent. If a website does not collect data, then no problem. If a website wants to collect data, it must ask permission and give control to the user over the data. How the website implements this is not mandated.
The EU could have started fining everybody and unleash hell at unseen levels. They would have ended up bankrupting companies and people who added google analytics or AdWords to their site in good faith, without understanding the privacy implications.
So the regulators initially notified companies and gave them time to implement whatever change they were required to. To this day, if they aren’t satisfied with the changes, they contact the company again, they don’t just issue fines. This happened to a company I used to work for, that initially just added a cookie banner, then was asked to make the “deny all” and “accept all” buttons of equal size and with equal accessibility.
People who run websites really should know what they're doing, at least in broad strokes.
> without understanding the privacy implications.
Regarding Adwords, maybe the EU could've just mandated Google to serve ads based only on the web page and not on the visitor? That would've allowed websites to continue with minimal disruption.
Google's profits might be a few billion less, but frankly I'd count that as a plus.
You can't just change a law and start issuing fines as if everybody was a criminal. You need to allow time for people to adapt, especially the guy who set up his personal site, installed Google Analytics because everybody used to do that, and forgot about it.
> Regarding Adwords, maybe the EU could've just mandated Google to serve ads based only on the web page and not on the visitor? That would've allowed websites to continue with minimal disruption.
That would be a ban of targeted ads, which I'm all for, but it's not what GDPR is about.
Agreed. The way the EU has handled this is naive at best.
> These large sites know exactly what they're doing. They're hoping people will become fed up enough to just accept, or they're hoping there'll be enough accidents where people click "Accept all". It's rather shitty.
Yes, and there need to be new regulations to prevent them from doing this. Something like:
(1) all web browsers should have a setting allowing users to accept or reject advertising/tracking cookies.
(2) this must default to not accepting them.
(3) in headers of http GET/POST requests, if the user allows advertising/tracking cookies, it should indicate this; if the user doesn't allow such cookies, it should be silent.
(4) all websites would be forbidden from using advertising/tracking cookies unless explicitly permitted
(5) all websites and web browsers would be banned from nagging the user or giving them a worse user experience for not allowing advertising/tracking cookies
(6) The spirit of these regulations is that users need do nothing and they will automatically have a tracking-free experience; any work-around by companies attempting to find a loophole in this is a violation of the regulations.
(7) Violation of any of the above would result in heavy fines; and if infractions continue, further crippling fines would be levied.