The HN High Horse is pretty justified to be fair. Most recruiters haven't the first clue about the technology they recruit for and the amount of underhanded and often illegal tactics recruiters engage in warrants most of the hate they receive.
Yes there are decent recruiters but they are a very rare breed and the decent ones generally know they are decent and consider themselves to be miles apart from the general stereotype and don't get offended by the hate.
Shameless Plug: Have a look at my blog linked in my profile for more info on why recruiters are universally hated.
What the author is doing is worse. He's using this minor indiscretion (if it's even that) to jump on the recruiter-bashing band wagon and churn out a blog post and get himself a bit of traffic.
Quote from the post:
"Please note that I don’t think recruiters are evil. They provide valuable services to both companies and candidates. But good recruiting takes hard work, time and social skills building relationships over a long period of time – something that justifies a 25% ticket from your year’s salary upon hire. In contrast, what’s the definition of sending an e-mail to 800 people because you have their e-mail address and think they are in your target demographic? Spam."
Now I start laughing when recruiters match me with CS graduate jobs which match up with me on their database because they're in the same part of the country as the university I went to, four years ago, in a completely different subject area...
It's more of a waste of time and space than anything else.
EDIT: For the record, I'm not the one downvoting your posts!
> I'm not downvoting your posts
Yeah sure, any opinion that diverges from the HN hivemind is gonna get dv'd in oblivion.
We (Hackruiter, YC S10) are fully transparent about the companies we work with and it's never been a problem.
Re his 3 points:
- A recruiter is never going to reveal the employer name as this risks them getting cut out of the loop
- So what if a recruiter is trying to make money? Believe it or not line managers are trying to make money too. They wouldn't employ you if they weren't getting a postive ROI.
- This _was_ a MongoDB ad, not Erlang or whatever.
Provided a post like this is occasional and relevant, I really don't see the issue. It could really help someone land a great job too.