News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by lmilcin on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:25AM (#29768511)
Ah, as usual. Developers thinking they know better than users.

As a developer, I hate that attitude.

The developer talked to the user, decided they understand the problem, then written their understanding in stone for the users to bang their heads on.

--

Side note: your users found the solution to this problem was offsetting your altitude by 2000ft at the start of your flight so that you can always work with positive values throughout the flight. It sort of works, most of the time, but will surprise you when you want to deploy new feature that reconciles current measured altitude with radar altitude with GPS altitude and with Google Maps. How typical technical debt.

This workaround does not cover the case if you find yourself in an emergency and so you could not have planned the offset beforehand. You will need to file a ticket requesting approval to change your altitude mid flight. You will have to explain to the approver the reason for this non-standard change and wait a week for the next CAB meeting to convene. I almost feel like working for a bank again.

Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by certifiedloud on Sunday January 02, 2022 @09:54AM (#29769156)
Actually it'll surprise you when you hit a mountain that you thought was 2000 feet lower because that's what the map and terrain database says.
Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by h2odragon on Sunday January 02, 2022 @07:52AM (#29768337)
Issue: Software fails to handle altitude of -400ft or less.

Response: "It's an airplane; it can become a submarine but usually only once and doesn't take off again."

Obviously the solution is to re calibrate our notion that "sea level" is a uniform base of the atmosphere. Its baked in to so many systems as an assumption tho; it might be easier to fill in some valleys instead.

If we plane the earth nice and smooth all over, will we have gentler weather? Or just collect it all into large, static super storms?

Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by jacquesm on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:17AM (#29768457)
If we plane the earth nice and smooth all over it will be covered with water.

Besides that, and assuming you only meant the continental landmasses the windspeeds would go up, because wind 'rolls' across the land due to it being slowed down by surface irregularities, so if you get laminar flow the speeds will be higher. Would you propose to build everything underground?

Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by B1FF_PSUVM on Sunday January 02, 2022 @10:47AM (#29769630)
(A quick search finds an average sea depth of 3,682 meters, and a "mean elevation of Earth is −2441 m relative to the WGS84 spheroid")

I think that in SF there were a few water covered worlds, mostly unmemorable except perhaps for a story about a very very long surf ride, by Zelazny I believe.

More recently Neal Asher made some good hay with a waterworld featuring interesting monsters and a very weird biology - https://www.panmacmillan.com/authors/neal-asher/the-skinner/... - which also affects humans roaming around in sailing ships.

Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by rwmj on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:18AM (#29768462)
Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by 6502nerdface on Sunday January 02, 2022 @09:42AM (#29769038)
We need to begin with a more modest interim goal: http://www.pavethehudson.org/
Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by sohkamyung on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:10AM (#29768426)
Does MS Flight Simulator handle this condition, i wonder.
Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by sio8ohPi on Sunday January 02, 2022 @10:19AM (#29769359)
On release this was bugged and would result in a crash (plane crash, not software crash). I'm not sure if that has been fixed.
Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by nickdothutton on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:28AM (#29768538)
Reminds me of the story of the Nautilus, where upon reaching magnetic north, and discovering every direction from there was therefore South, the navigation computer folded.
Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by eesmith on Sunday January 02, 2022 @01:49PM (#29772121)
I thought that was interesting, looked for more details, and found https://www.usni.org/magazines/proceedings/1958/december/nav... saying almost the opposite:

> The [magnetic] compass did operate as well as was expected. Even though at times the deviation was high, its readings were constantly monitored, especially after crossing the Pole, for a change in deviation indicating a course error. No such error was found, but it remains a fact that a good magnetic compass even though readings are approximate and/or relative is still essential to navigation in Polar regions as a basic backup should all other equipment fail simultaneously. ...

> The fact that a northseeking [gyro]compass did take the ship to a point 60–100 miles from the Pole and at that point would have by itself provided information to take the ship within normal navigational accuracy of the Pole may seem amazing to outsiders. We aboard, however, expected this type of performance from the MK 19 as a result of our previous Arctic experience with the compass and its everyday reliability since then. Even though it had already outperformed the expectations of many, it still failed to show any readable drift rate and was an outstanding DG. ...

Now, that concerned the North Pole, not Magnetic North Pole, but 1) they had a gyrocompass too, with cross-checks for possible failures, and 2) there's no mention of a navigation computer - it appears the calculations were done manually.

Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by ncmncm on Sunday January 02, 2022 @07:37PM (#29775876)
The North magnetic pole has never in living memory been especially close to the actual pole. At that time it was on land, as it is now. So, you can't drive over the North magnetic pole in a submarine, though there have been periods when you could.

At and near the pole, the direction is mostly "down".

Recently a Boeing 747 flying over the North Pole had all four engines die in the same moment. You may guess things were pretty tense in the cockpit for a while. After it glided below 10,000 ft altitude, they managed to fire them up again. There was a particular combination of pressure, temperature, humidity, and history the designers had thought would never happen.

The engine manufacturer figured out what had happened and reprogrammed the engines (on all 747s) so it would not happen again.

Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by eesmith on Monday January 03, 2022 @12:56AM (#29777798)
Before posting I had checked the location of the North Magnetic Pole, since I remembered it being in over (under?) land, in high Canadian latitudes.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_magnetic_pole and more specifically the chart at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_magnetic_pole#/media/Fil... show it is indeed 1) over water, 2) near the North Pole, near 86.400°N 156.786°E, and 3) close to where the Nautilus

It is the North Geomagnetic Pole which is over land.

Since nickdothutton said "magnetic north", I took it to be plausible.

HOWEVER! I was wrong, because I didn't check far enough.

The geographical location of the Earth's North Magnetic Pole moves, and in the 1950s it was in the Parry Channel of the Northwest Passage. Which is not where the Nautilus went.

Do you have a reference for the 747 failure? I couldn't find one.

In October 1977, Pan Am Flight 50, using a 747SP, circumnavigated the Earth via the poles: San Francisco over the North Pole to London, then Cape Town, then over the South Pole, then Auckland, then back to San Francisco. With no engine problems.

While your description reminds me of BA flight 009 going through a volcanic cloud, where all four engines flamed out and they didn't get a restart until about 12000 feet - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Airways_Flight_009 .

Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by ncmncm on Monday January 03, 2022 @03:02AM (#29778423)
I am trying to find the 747 polar engine failure. As I recall, it was a cargo flight, the which attract less attention from aviation archivers.
Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by jacquesm on Monday January 03, 2022 @07:11PM (#29789025)
AVHerald should have it though.
Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by ivan_gammel on Sunday January 02, 2022 @10:45AM (#29769607)
About 10-15 years ago I have seen a presentation from Transas, a company that develops cabine simulators for training pilots and ship crew. They mentioned such unusual flight conditions as a challenge for developers. In their case it was an airfield in the mountains that was above the approach altitude. Let’s also not forget the famous incident with F-22 Raptor software crash when crossing international date line. We should be really careful with assumptions about the domain.
Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by rwmj on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:15AM (#29768451)
In our project we call this a "doc fix", fix the documentation to reflect the buggy behaviour of the software, my favourite and least effort kind of bug fix :-)
Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by jacquesm on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:18AM (#29768459)
Also, in this case that 'doc fix' instantly declares a number of airfields to be impossible to fly to in that particular aircraft.
Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by JackFr on Sunday January 02, 2022 @10:28AM (#29769430)
“Doctor, it hurts when I do this.”

“Don’t do that.”

Re:The Challenge of Flying Below Sea Level (2016) by ncmncm on Sunday January 02, 2022 @07:33PM (#29775829)
It seems awfully optimistic to believe the NAV systems would ever be fixed.