That's what the EU Taxonomy does: it labels activities and specifies precise criteria.
"green" in this sense just means it's eligible to receive funding/tax status that is otherwise not available. It's not a judgement on whether the technology is carbon neutral.
That's literally the entire problem.
That's the theory anyway, and if we look at what happened in France with fuel taxes, it seems pretty plausible to me.
So sure, net you might achieve a reduction. However, that could mean that after 30 years you aren’t as decarbonized if the investments in natural gas prevented nuclear and renewable build out.
I don’t know if that’s the actual case, but my prior based on how the FF industry operates leads me to believe that to be a reason natural gas is being framed in this way. Sure, it only covers construction before 2030. However these plants easily last 50+ years and inflation means that a nuclear plant starting in 2031 will have a much harder time competing with a natural gas plant making its economics worse. I’m always open to having my mind changed with data and a compelling counterargument, but I’m more sympathetic to the position that’s extremely concerned with natural gas being included.
The emissions limit should probably be 10x lower than what was set to allow natural gas.
If this is a jobs thing to provide an off ramp for the industry, I’m more sympathetic to that as long as we’re honest and transparent that that’s why we’re doing it (the political and economic ramifications are just as important as the goal of decarbonization). Just don’t spit in my face and tell me it’s raining.
After all the idea is to incentivise truly carbon neutral energy.
Obviously there's pragmatism and gas is better than coal but I think an independent body would say "burn gas if you must, but don't expect to get off freely with closing the nuclear plants".
If it's just about such aspect you could give it some arbitrary EU regulation number and say it's compatible with that.
By basing it around the term "green" it's very much focused around marketing and what people will perceive as "carbon neutral".
Nuclear power it's climate but but environment/human friendly. So I can understand that.
But natural gas isn't green however I look at it.
It's clearly better then cush l coal, but but green.
So it shouldn't be allowed to be labeled as such.
Instead we should add a label for better but but really good tech, like yellow or so.