Re:The Modern Guide to OAuth
by mooreds on Friday December 31, 2021 @09:31PM
(#29754862)
I agree that OAuth by itself doesn't solve registration, account recovery, profile management, 2fa, etc.
Most OAuth2 servers (whether the ones you mention or others like keycloak, identity server, azure ad b2c, ping identity, etc, etc) augment the standard with this functionality. Other than OIDC for authentication, I am not aware of any other high level standards for these problems (though https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc6238 is useful for 2fa).
I think that software companies push OAuth2 because it solves a real problem and is a standard. If there are other standards around identity, they'll also be used by these folks (SCIM, other OAuth grants). If there are holes in functionality, those will be filled by custom implementations (whether the software is OSS or not).
I don't see how those open source projects that you mention get us closer to data portability. Can you explain that?
FYI, both FusionAuth and Auth0 allow exports of password hashes, which is fundamental to letting the data owner migrate easily.
Most OAuth2 servers (whether the ones you mention or others like keycloak, identity server, azure ad b2c, ping identity, etc, etc) augment the standard with this functionality. Other than OIDC for authentication, I am not aware of any other high level standards for these problems (though https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc6238 is useful for 2fa).
I think that software companies push OAuth2 because it solves a real problem and is a standard. If there are other standards around identity, they'll also be used by these folks (SCIM, other OAuth grants). If there are holes in functionality, those will be filled by custom implementations (whether the software is OSS or not).
I don't see how those open source projects that you mention get us closer to data portability. Can you explain that?
FYI, both FusionAuth and Auth0 allow exports of password hashes, which is fundamental to letting the data owner migrate easily.
Disclosure: I work for FusionAuth.