Re:Show HN: a weekend project, Caltrainer
by radicalbyte on Thursday September 08, 2011 @03:25PM
(#2975286)
Just a bit of constructive criticism about your blog post: it's not exactly clear what your application does. Especially if you don't know what Caltrain is. I, for example, thought that it was something to do with personal training. Until I googled it :)
After reading your first paragraph the reader should have a general idea of what you're talking about...
Re:Show HN: a weekend project, Caltrainer
by ak217 on Thursday September 08, 2011 @03:07PM
(#2975202)
No offense, but caltrain xpress is much better. I usually want to know what are the upcoming trains from station X to station Y, and caltrain xpress has the UI that focuses on that question well.
Your app just has a flat table, and doesn't highlight express or bullet trains.
Take a look at the features in caltrain xpress and iBART.
Re:Show HN: a weekend project, Caltrainer
by sahillavingia on Thursday September 08, 2011 @03:44PM
(#2975369)
All I want is a flat table, that's quick to load, and fun to use. This app is a Caltrain schedule, and that's it. I don't want it to be anymore — it'll quickly get bloated and turn into one of those.
I agree that app is much better for certain things, but not for just reading a timetable in a slightly nicer format.
Re:Show HN: a weekend project, Caltrainer
by danilocampos on Thursday September 08, 2011 @05:02PM
(#2975659)
Cute, but no.
Homeboy introduced this as a "weekend project."
That's code for "I did whatever the hell I wanted to because it was fun, want a look?"
To me, it's in bad taste to gripe about the stack someone chooses in the pursuit of their personal, free projects, the same way only a jerk bitches about a thoughtful housewarming gift.
Re:Show HN: a weekend project, Caltrainer
by paulirish on Friday September 09, 2011 @08:43PM
(#2980378)
Show HN is a deliberate request for feedback. My comment was stating I have zero ability to provide useful feedback because of his choices. Totes bad taste.
After reading your first paragraph the reader should have a general idea of what you're talking about...
Your app just has a flat table, and doesn't highlight express or bullet trains.
Take a look at the features in caltrain xpress and iBART.
I agree that app is much better for certain things, but not for just reading a timetable in a slightly nicer format.
You should ask for a refund.
Brilliant.
Homeboy introduced this as a "weekend project."
That's code for "I did whatever the hell I wanted to because it was fun, want a look?"
To me, it's in bad taste to gripe about the stack someone chooses in the pursuit of their personal, free projects, the same way only a jerk bitches about a thoughtful housewarming gift.