News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by chrsig on Thursday December 30, 2021 @12:02PM (#29738433)
I encourage everyone to watch Don't Look Up. In many ways it struck me as the spiritual successor to Idiocracy.

I needed to watch it in chunks, because of how viscerally real it is. It is funny, in that it's ostensibly comedy, and the actors all have great comedic timing...but it's also a very very honest appraisal of where we're at as a society.

Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by Emma_Goldman on Thursday December 30, 2021 @12:19PM (#29738629)
I have to disagree. It attempts to satirise today's mass media by exaggerating its influence on politics to the point at which it revolves around little else, succumbing to what it is supposed to be objecting to: the idea of politics and politicians as trivial. The plotline was so wildly implausible that it ended up saying little about the real world.

Also, the asteroid threat is not a good analogy for climate change, as it is supposed to be. Climate change is so difficult to deal with because its effects are uncertain, long-term and unevenly felt. None of those issues hold for an asteroid that will, per the plot, destroy the whole of human civilization in 6 months with 99.9% certainty absent intervention.

Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by aseerdbnarng on Thursday December 30, 2021 @12:59PM (#29739231)
Its not good satire because its very heavy handed (similar to Idiocracy) but its criticisms seemed spot on to me. The characters were all there from the jingoist politicians, a media focused on trivial distractions, techno utopianists, a fragmented society that cant agree on common truths and ultimately a disastrous ending that could have been avoided. Its not a cheerful movie
Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by GeoAtreides on Thursday December 30, 2021 @02:04PM (#29740096)
>Its not good satire because its very heavy handed

ah, yes, such blunt and heavy handed satire compared with old, subtle satire, like that one, modest, pamphlet advocating for eating poor children.

not sure why satire needs to be subtle to be good. It can go from crass to oscar-wilde-subtle, as long as it's funny and based on reality I would call it good.

Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by notacoward on Thursday December 30, 2021 @02:58PM (#29740757)
> jingoist politicians, a media focused on trivial distractions, techno utopianists

Note that these groups are (for the most part) mutually antagonistic. It's not hard to find someone who agrees that politicians and media and public-health officials are all incompetent or malign or both, yet those same people absolutely idolize techno-utopian billionaires who hardly have any better claim to such adulation. That antagonism is what drives the " fragmented society that cant agree on common truths" that you mention. The problem with a movie like Don't Look Up is that everyone looks right past the offense to others, sees their own in-group being lampooned, and decides that the whole thing must suck.

Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by aseerdbnarng on Thursday December 30, 2021 @03:32PM (#29741094)
Thats a great point! “I liked everything about the movie until my ox was gored” and in this case the movie goes for it leaving no one spared. The evisceration of techno John Galt and the media might be the most flagrant sins amongst professional critics’ social class
Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by chrsig on Thursday December 30, 2021 @12:38PM (#29738900)
We do indeed disagree!

I don't think it was saying that politics and politicians as trivial -- I think it was saying that they're not necessarily smart people, and they're certainly not necessarily acting in the best interests of the people they serve.

I think they were also saying that the media serves to reinforce denial in the general population.

The asteroid is just a plot device -- the message is that in the face of mortal danger, huge chunks of the population refuse to even acknowledge the danger so that any intervention can be made. And those in power will exploit that for their own enrichment.

We don't just see this with climate change -- we've observed it with the previous administration...some hits:

- "Lock her up" -- yes, let's just start imprisoning political rivals and see what that does for us as a society)

- "Covid will go away by april" - I suppose they didn't say which april.

- Hydroxychloroquine/Ivermectin/Vitamin C

- Vaccines have microchips

- Masks don't do anything

The list goes on -- We've seen that the population is perfectly willing to disregard any science that threatens their way of life. It's easier to dismiss than to adjust.

Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by Emma_Goldman on Thursday December 30, 2021 @01:21PM (#29739571)
Let me take a couple of specific examples. Upon being told that an asteroid large enough to destroy human civilization was on course to hit the earth in 6 months, the President decided that it would make strategic sense to delay announcing or acting on the threat until after the midterms - a month or so later. This was conspicuous for the fact no reason was given, which had to be the case as it makes no sense.

Collective threats of this kind have historically created a rally-around-the-flag effect the helps incumbents. Even a venal politician would not assist in the imminent destruction of the planet from which they themselves could not escape. Obviously information of that magnitude of importance would leak, as it did in the film. Meaning its only effect would be to crater the President's support when it became clear they hid the truth. Even an amaetuer political observer would understand all this, let alone a Whitehouse team that won a Presidential election.

Or how about the manner in which the astronomers announced their discovery? They went to the NYT, who inexplicably decided that they would forego running the biggest story in human history. Instead, they helped arrange for the astronomers to announce their discovery in a 2-minute segment on an infotainment news show. Neither the NYT, nor the astronomers, nor anyone would think that was a good idea. It would never, ever happen. During the interview, one of the astronomers got upset because the talk show hosts were nonchalant about the news of the possible end of civilization (!?). Returning to the NYT offices, they're told that the journalists were able to confirm their findings with well-respected third party scientists, but that because one of the astronomers got upset in air, they weren't going to run the story - again, easily the biggest story in human history, which anyone could appreciate at such.

The upshot of this never-ending string of implausible plot points is that the film ends up obfuscating how real politics works. It dumbs politics down and makes it trivial to make an easy joke, making it part of the problem that it ostensibly satirises.

Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by bryanrasmussen on Friday December 31, 2021 @03:01AM (#29745938)
>They went to the NYT, who inexplicably decided that they would forego running the biggest story in human history

My understanding was they ran the story and the morning tv show was part of a media tour they set up, the response on the tv show such that they did not really want to continue with the big media blitz and publishing more stories that they had planned.

>Returning to the NYT offices, they're told that the journalists were able to confirm their findings with well-respected third party scientists, but that because one of the astronomers got upset in air, they weren't going to run the story

They had ran it by other scientists in the initial meeting who said that the data looked credible. However after the disastrous media appearance one of the things that made the NYT not want to continue with writing more articles was that they had learned the science was not 100% and they were mad they had been lied to.

Who said the science was not 100%? Dr. Jocelyn Calder the head of NASA, later Calder resigns in disgrace to shield the administration when scientist with Ivy League credentials confirm the comet is coming.

on edit: formatting, grammar

Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by chrsig on Thursday December 30, 2021 @01:35PM (#29739731)
> Let me take a couple of specific examples. Upon being told that an asteroid large enough to destroy human civilization was on course to hit the earth in 6 months, the President decided that it would make strategic sense to delay announcing or acting on the threat until after the midterms - a month or so later. This was conspicuous for the fact no reason was given, which had to be the case as it makes no sense.

Counter example: Trump new about the severity of covid and downplayed it for quite some time instead of trying to rally the country.

> Meaning its only effect would be to crater the President's support when it became clear they hid the truth. Even an amaetuer political observer would understand all this, let alone a Whitehouse team that won a Presidential election.

In light of the above, this has been shown to be false. There absolutely can be some fanatical base that will construct shared delusional propaganda to avoid the realization that they've been conned.

> Or how about the manner in which the astronomers announced their discovery? They went to the NYT, who inexplicably decided that they would forego running the biggest story in human history. Instead, they helped arrange for the astronomers to announce their discovery in a 2-minute segment on an infotainment news show. Neither the NYT, nor the astronomers, nor anyone would think that was a good idea. It would never, ever happen.

This I'm more inclined to believe. I'm not sure if it would impact the outcome though. I can't imagine there's a huge overlap in people that read the NYT versus watch morning infotainment. I've also lost all faith in humanity, so I can't rule out that it's quite possible that people would make such bad decisions.

> During the interview, one of the astronomers got upset because the talk show hosts were nonchalant about the news of the possible end of civilization (!?). Returning to the NYT offices, they're told that the journalists were able to confirm their findings with well-respected third party scientists, but that because one of the astronomers got upset in air, they weren't going to run the story - again, easily the biggest story in human history, which anyone could appreciate at such.

I think this pretty firmly falls into satirical license as a commentary on meme culture, and how people care more about the messenger than the message.

Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by mullingitover on Thursday December 30, 2021 @01:55PM (#29739976)
> Counter example: Trump new about the severity of covid and downplayed it for quite some time instead of trying to rally the country.

The irony is that the pandemic was such a slam-dunk easy win politically. Handled with the minimum level of political savvy, this was a dead simple way to send his approval ratings into the van allen belt, just like Bush post-9/11. I think his personal financial stake in the hospitality industry clouded his judgment and prevented him from taking advantage of the biggest election campaign tailwind in a generation.

Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by millzlane on Thursday December 30, 2021 @02:29PM (#29740419)
I remember when asked about what to say to the American people about the pandemic who are scared. His response was to lash out. It was such a easy slam dunk question, I was almost inspired to create a you tube video asking people to remix it and answer the question like a president.
Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by mullingitover on Thursday December 30, 2021 @02:38PM (#29740516)
I think this scenario was a textbook example of why the traditional norm for incoming presidents to divest from their businesses exists. His head was probably spinning like a gyroscope over his business empire cratering and his loans coming due.

We can only imagine how things would've turned out if we'd had leadership with an unbiased focus on national unity and the greater good. He could very easily have had a landslide re-election.

Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by LargoLasskhyfv on Thursday December 30, 2021 @09:07PM (#29744045)
Mulling it over, he could have made sooo much by reconfiguring them into humane quarantine centers, without the need to have FEMA-camps, or things like that.
Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by Emma_Goldman on Thursday December 30, 2021 @04:54PM (#29741921)
>Trump new about the severity of covid and downplayed it for quite some time

Trump neither tried to hide the existence of COVID from the public nor thought it would topple civilization and kill him personally. He downplayed it and the risk it posed, but that is a different order of lying. Trump said exactly as much as he thought he could get away with, and no more.

>There absolutely can be some fanatical base that will construct shared delusional propaganda to avoid the realization that they've been conned.

Sure, but COVID-deniers are a fringe and any political calculus that depends on denying COVID is therefore bound to fail. It is equally clear that denying the existence of an earth-shattering asteroid makes no political sense.

Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by chrsig on Thursday December 30, 2021 @05:33PM (#29742339)
You're right, it doesn't make sense. People do things that don't make sense.

The president in Don't Look Up didn't think it would topple civilization and kill her personally. They thought the plan to break it up and mine it would work. They took a greedy gamble on the fate of the world and lost.

In so doing, they took for granted all of the amazing technology that we have and disregarded expert opinions.

Likewise with trump, who had worked to dismantle the existing pandemic playbook[0] took for granted how well our medical response would be. He regularly disregarded expert opinions, or simply did not speak with them[1]. He even worked to make it difficult for states to get help, because he lost the vote there[2].

In my opinion, these actions do not make sense, yet they were taken by an actual POTUS.

With that in mind, it's not beyond the realm of possibility that a POTUS would try to leverage the event for political gain, and use it opportunity for personal profit, and that a sizable amount of the population would support it.

And you're right. It makes no sense. It's mind mindbogglingly dumb. Still plausible.

[0] https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/obama-team-left-pandemic...

[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2020/10/23/fauci-says-trump-hasnt-atten...

[2] https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/494807-trump-ask...

Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by Emma_Goldman on Saturday January 01, 2022 @05:09AM (#29757094)
I think this is a bit of a straw man. Yes, people sometimes do things that aren't in their rational self-interest, even capaciously understood. But we are talking about a specific scenario.

The question is: would the President, told of an imminent asteroid collision large enough to destroy human civilization, and knowing this information would leak if she did not announce it, elect to hide this information for a month until after the midterms for no particular reason?

You say "They thought the plan to break it up and mine it would work." At the time of the decision of whether to announce the existence of the asteroid, and create a plan, there obviously was no plan. So no, she didn't think that.

>"Likewise with trump, who had worked to dismantle the existing pandemic playbook[0] took for granted how well our medical response would be. He regularly disregarded expert opinions, or simply did not speak with them[1]. He even worked to make it difficult for states to get help, because he lost the vote there[2]."

Again, this isn't the point. Even Trump never tried to deny the existence of COVID. Clearly that would not have worked and would have exploded in his face.

Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by nickpp on Thursday December 30, 2021 @07:30PM (#29743393)
Looks to me like Hollywood's obsession with Trump is never ending. Makes sense - they pretty much created him.
Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by millzlane on Thursday December 30, 2021 @02:25PM (#29740393)
I always thought the asteroid threat was the pandemic.
Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by kentm on Thursday December 30, 2021 @09:56PM (#29744369)
It seems that way because it tracked how the pandemic played out really closely, but they wrote the script before the pandemic started. It was meant as commentary on climate change.
Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by BrandoElFollito on Thursday December 30, 2021 @04:30PM (#29741685)
I started to watch that movie but had to stop (for a moment) because it described precisely a fear I had for some time: that we would not able to work together even in case of a deadly event that would be within our lifetime.

If we had a meteor expected to hit Earth in 10 years I am sure we would not start to work on a plan to protect ourselves as THE only thing to care about.

There would always be discussions about budget, China/Russia/US/[pick your country] being the villains, etc.

Covid hit us very mildly and it was (and still is) a shitshow. A global disaster coming in x years (within our lifetime but not tomorrow either) wild be the end of humanity.

We know that climate changes will be terrible and we simply do not care at all, as a species.

Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by opwieurposiu on Thursday December 30, 2021 @12:45PM (#29739005)
Don't Look Up Was a the funniest thing I have seen all year. Imagine the fall of rome, but with twitter. Perfect acting all around, with a script so gin clear in it's portrayal of human nature you can see all the way to the bottom.
Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by mullingitover on Thursday December 30, 2021 @12:32PM (#29738822)
I know Don't Look Up was supposed to spur people into action, but I came away feeling hopeless, like the industrial revolution and its consequences have been a disaster for the human race.
Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by scollet on Thursday December 30, 2021 @02:22PM (#29740349)
I don't know that it's a disaster necessarily. I think people aren't prepared or don't want to pay the debt we took.
Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by 999900000999 on Thursday December 30, 2021 @12:56PM (#29739176)
Don't look up falls flat, in my opinion because you have too many superstars in a movie that should not be about star power.

Netflix has this weird habit where it's like they can't budget well. I imagine they spent so much money hiring Leonardo DiCaprio they didn't have enough to write good scriptwriters.

I really wanted to like the movie, but why would you cram so many high power celebrities in one film. Film. Idiocracy is amazing because outside of Booker T, and Scareface's cameo I had no idea who these actors were. Plus I'd argue the plot is much easier to follow. Mike Judge is a genius.

If anything Don't Look Up ends up being a demonstration of the celebrity worship it mocks.

Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by chrsig on Thursday December 30, 2021 @01:07PM (#29739339)
> Idiocracy is amazing because outside of Booker T, and Scareface's cameo I had no idea who these actors were

I can understand where you're coming from. I'm a marvel fan and I'm disappointed that they went with so many celbreties for Eternals -- I haven't seen it yet, but they were really more distracting than anything in the trailers.

I didn't mind the actors in Don't Look Up though, Leonardo DiCaprio, Jonah Hill, and Jennifer Lawrence had some good chemistry. It did feel like Jonah Hill's character was literally the same character from Wolf of Wallstreet.

My guess is that netflix was hoping that it'd garnish more attention having many big name actors. It's also possible those actors _wanted_ to do it as a form of expression.

> If anything Don't Look Up ends up being a demonstration of the celebrity worship it mocks.

I don't really think it mocked celebrity worship. Maybe to some degree with the tech ceo (I can certainly amuse myself with how HN would probably react to some of it's hivemind's idols like Jobs or PG in that situation.

Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by sangnoir on Thursday December 30, 2021 @06:17PM (#29742742)
> HN would probably react to some of it's hivemind's idols like Jobs or PG in that situation.

Or Elon Musk. I can almost imagine the following comment on HN: "The asteroid has enough lithium to make batteries for everyone alive for the next 200 years! Anyone who supports diverting it supports government dysfunction and unmitigated destruction of wealth. This is our one shot to jumpstart space manufacturing - humans have a chance of becoming a Type II civilization, the risk is negligible and well worth it"

Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by alpha_squared on Thursday December 30, 2021 @01:21PM (#29739562)
The really sad part is the script was originally written before the pandemic and wasn't at all meant to be about the current crisis, but about climate change. Then the pandemic happened and the director was surprised at how the script didn't go far enough and had to make it, "20% crazier."
Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by NovaS1X on Thursday December 30, 2021 @12:46PM (#29739021)
Don't Look Up was fantastic. I don't think there's another movie that more accurately portrays the absurdity of modern society.
Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by Ottolay on Thursday December 30, 2021 @12:41PM (#29738945)
Saw this movie last night. One of the tougher movies I have watched. Being a satire, it exaggerates a bit, but still hits pretty close to home.
Re:Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future by nickpp on Thursday December 30, 2021 @07:20PM (#29743308)
Seemed less like Idiocracy (smart comedy pointing out a real issue in a funny way) and much more like Dr Strangelove - a nihilistic crazy comedy showing how the way the system is setup is dooming us all.

The main difference from both is that Don’t Look Up is completely implausible. Also, it isn’t very funny. But I guess people are eager to overlook that if it validates their political biases.

Anyway, since Idiocracy couldn’t be made today due to the PC crowd yelling "eugenics", it is in a way a modern replacement, made straight for the woke crowd with pronouns in their Twitter bio.