News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Web3? by indigochill on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:08PM (#29729364)
> Decentralized trust could be great, but I wonder how much time actually needs to be spent talking about it vs. actually building it...

And the order of operations. Traditionally, you build something great (or an MVP) and market it. The crypto community has been putting the marketing before the building.

It's probably uncontroversial to say although cryptocurrency -could- do great things, right now the bulk of trade in the first world is speculation. Meanwhile there are television ads in the US aimed at football fans telling them how they can trade cryptocurrency. WTF does the average football fan need with cryptocurrency?

Re:Why Web3? by cercatrova on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:23PM (#29730195)
> Traditionally, you build something great (or an MVP) and market it.

I don't like the Web3 hype either but generally people say one should market their product first then build it if there's enough demand, through a landing page capturing emails or pre-payments, or other such ways of gauging demand.

It just seems that Web3 fanatics took the marketing side too far that they've forgotten they actually have to build a product (that solves an actual problem, not yet another coin) for which the marketing will be used.

Re:Why Web3? by aquateen on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:48PM (#29730496)
> generally people say one should market their product first then build it if there's enough demand

I don't agree this is the common wisdom, and it's kind of a surprising take to see on this website specifically.

Re:Why Web3? by girvo on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @08:44PM (#29732544)
Really? Some parts of this website used to push that hard back in the "MVP" phase. And I've been here nearly as long as you (I made an account much later after lurking for years) -- what was that start-up that was a website that literally fed into an excel spreadsheet, to fake having a real product?

The growth hacking stuff took that idea even further, and for quite a while was all over this website.

That said, I disagree with said "wisdom", I just find it interesting that we've got diametrically opposed views on how this website perceived it!

Re:Why Web3? by cercatrova on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:54PM (#29730569)
It's what I commonly see on startup fora including HN, reddit, IndieHackers etc. There's books about this method like Lean Startup, Mom Test and so on.

The advice to build first and market later is actually advice that is much maligned in my experience, as there are too many stories of engineers who build and then find out they can't actually sell their product because they focused too much on the building and not enough on getting people to know about it.

Re:Why Web3? by ipaddr on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:07PM (#29730692)
The approach to validate ideas with conversation with your target market when you are unsure if anyone will buy.

But in this case you need to validate it by building it and proving it can be done. The market is already prepped.

Re:Why Web3? by cercatrova on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:59PM (#29731244)
> in this case

In which case, Web3? If so, I don't think the market is prepped at all, I don't really see people using it for what proponents say it'll be used for. If some other case, please elucidate me, I'm not sure what you're referring to otherwise.

Re:Why Web3? by ipaddr on Thursday December 30, 2021 @01:21AM (#29734192)
The market is ready for a product that hasn't come, so build it.
Re:Why Web3? by lottin on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:05PM (#29730684)
> they can't actually sell their product because they focused too much on the building and not enough on getting people to know about it

Or more likely, there was no demand for their product to begin with.

Re:Why Web3? by cercatrova on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:08PM (#29730714)
Indeed, the worst is when they don't actually solve any problems whatsoever, they treat it as a way to have fun building the product, using new technologies, new architectures etc.

There's nothing wrong with building to learn but the problem arises when engineers think building automatically leads to business success; the two are often entirely disjointed. WordPress is maligned as well but it's wildly successful for Automattic.

Re:Why Web3? by nfw2 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:07PM (#29730703)
Maybe it's not common wisdom in general, but it is a pretty common viewpoint in the startup world. Building products is expensive, and startups can't afford to build something no one wants. It's pretty much universal advise that finding an initial market fit should be the first priority of any new startup.

Literally making a sale before the product exists is the extreme end of that philosophy. Whether or not this is good advise, or even possible, probably depends a lot on the domain. For most domains though, there is some degree of market research that can and should be done before investing in product development.

Re:Why Web3? by aquateen on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:18PM (#29730828)
I've been on this website a long time and I suppose the userbase has grown quite a bit. I don't assume everyone has read all of Paul Graham's articles or even know who he is, but are you familiar with how YCombinator works?

Enough money to survive on ramen for a few months and build a demo. Get feedback from users and iterate over and over.

Re:Why Web3? by nfw2 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:51PM (#29731174)
I know multiple people personally who have been through YC, and I'm not sure what point you are trying to make.

Not every company that goes through YC are at the same stage. I've heard of companies joining YC despite already having over a million in ARR because of how valuable the YC network is.

YC invests 125k in each team, which is certainly enough to last more than a few months eating ramen if you are building the product yourself.

Also, trying to sell a product using a demo is not exactly the same as selling a finished product. At 0-1 stage, you can bet the demo hides the rough edges to some degree.

I would say selling using a demo falls somewhere on the sell-before-build spectrum, but one point I was trying to make is that it is not necessarily black-and-white.

Re:Why Web3? by aquateen on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @06:54PM (#29731679)
The point is that YC's model contradicts what you said. It's relatively inexpensive to build an initial version of a product. Build something as quickly as possible, get user feedback, and keep iterating.

I can guarantee you won't find anything Paul Graham has written about doing a bunch of marketing analysis as a first step.

Re:Why Web3? by nfw2 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @08:55PM (#29732610)
I said market research, not marketing analysis. I don't mean focus groups and A-B tests and ad words.

No YC company is literally in stage 1 of its existence. First you need to get into YC, and you probably won't if you don't know anything about the market you are trying to reach.

Re:Why Web3? by hooande on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @09:55PM (#29733009)
> Enough money to survive on ramen for a few months and build a demo. Get feedback from users and iterate over and over.

This is indeed the original idea behind YCombinator. That was a very long time ago. Things have changed, both with the YCombinator company and the ethos of this web community.

Re:Why Web3? by TimJRobinson on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @08:42PM (#29732527)
It makes more sense if you think of these token sales as Angel/Seed rounds that are fully open to the public.

Non investors never got access to these rounds before and never saw just how many companies are raising them.

This environment is foreign to most but would be familiar to well known angel investors constantly getting pitched new opportunities.

Re:Why Web3? by FridgeSeal on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @07:15PM (#29731878)
I’ve been in a company that did this (market first, build second) and it was an unmitigated disaster, and I never want to go near someone who does that ever again.
Re:Why Web3? by mvkel on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @11:45PM (#29733705)
Market-then-build is a fallacy that makes a compelling story but few, if any, real world examples.

That’s kind of the conundrum of web3. It’s all marketing, no build.

Re:Why Web3? by krrrh on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:57PM (#29729935)
This is such a good point. "Web 2.0" didn't really emerge as a term of art until there was a need to describe the widespread adoption of UGC, REST, & AJAX and blockbuster web applications like gmail replacing desktop applications.
Re:Why Web3? by pedalpete on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:43PM (#29731106)
I was actually thinking the opposite. I seem to recall talking about Web 2.0 and AJAX, SOAP, etc. before most apps were built using those technologies. We were using AJAX minimally, CSS was a thing, but UGC was still a few years away, from what I recall.
Re:Why Web3? by jrsj on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:40PM (#29730392)
The reason you see this is that the entire “web3” landscape is controlled by VCs. Also the underlying infra this stuff is running on isn’t very decentralized at all and with proof of stake it likely never will be.

If you want true decentralization you’re going to need a combination of Bitcoin/Lightning Network/side chains to recreate a lot of what has been built out on other more centralized platforms. But VCs don’t want to fund this because there’s way less potential upside for them.

Re:Why Web3? by zhoujianfu on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:01PM (#29730639)
Or just bitcoin cash!
Re:Why Web3? by dathinab on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:59PM (#29729954)
I read an article recently which claimed that the majority of transaction volume is not speculation, but scams, fraud and similar. Like e.g. pyramid schemes.

And that is where an average football fan needs crypto, to provide more monetary volume for scams and speculators manipulating the marked to siphon of.

Or at least that was the take of the article, I'm not completely sure in either direction.

Re:Why Web3? by mediocregopher on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:08PM (#29730051)
The difference between "speculation" and "scams, fraud, and similar" is in the eye of the beholder. Lots of people find all crypto to be a giant scam, others find all of it to be a potential investment (hopefully with the understanding that the long-tail of individual investments in the space will go to zero).
Re:Why Web3? by ShamelessC on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @09:17PM (#29732755)
Just FYI - that is a _deeply_ unconvincing argument where you are effectively saying "sure it's a scam (the one you know), but I have since updated _my_ definition of scam; and let me tell you - it sure did make me some money and avoid a lot of cognitive dissonance!"

Like calling a pyramid scheme a reverse funnel system.

Re:Why Web3? by acdha on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:26PM (#29730897)
> The difference between "speculation" and "scams, fraud, and similar" is in the eye of the beholder.

The definitions of those terms really comes down to intention: a scammer is selling something they _know_ does not deliver what they're promising while a speculator should be making good-faith claims. This line gets blurry with optimism but most of the cryptocurrency speculation which called out is indeed misrepresentation of what a potential buyer would get, such as claiming that an NFT conveys ownership when it does not.

Re:Why Web3? by devin on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:09PM (#29730715)
To be fair, it's not a bad target market. Look at FanDuel and PokerStars and such. For many watching, it's just a new kind of gambling. The decision many are likely making is to throw their money at bitcoin instead of placing a bet at an online sportsbook. The feeling of "investing" in crypto versus outright gambling is a nice little story to tell oneself, even if it's not particularly true.
Re:Why Web3? by irrational on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:51PM (#29730530)
Have you seen the one with Matt Damon hawking a crypto site? How much must it cost to get someone of his caliber to star in your commercial?
Re:Why Web3? by ipaddr on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:15PM (#29730789)
To get George to do those expresso ads it costs 18 million.

To get Matthew mcconaughey to drive 3 million.

As for Matt Damon. cryto.com gave 1 million to water.org and Matt said any money he makes will go to water.org and that's worth millions. My guess 4-5 million on the highside but probably 3 to 4 million

Re:Why Web3? by ThomPete on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:31PM (#29730289)
The crypto community does what every startup should do. They find the customers before they start building i.e. they build community first and in effect build products.

To say that things aren't being build in the crypto community is simply flat out false.

It's one of the fastest developing industries and more and more talent are leaving their previous jobs or industries.

Re:Why Web3? by unicornmama on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:36PM (#29730346)
Talent is pouring in because free money is gushing out from the mother of all bubbles. Enjoy it while it lasts.
Re:Why Web3? by maybecrypto on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:56PM (#29731216)
Applies to me - leaving enterprise infrastructure for crypto. I think the tech is mostly useless, but the hype is real, the VC dollars are real. I want to try to capitalize on this.
Re:Why Web3? by ThomPete on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @06:53PM (#29731675)
if you believed it was a bubble you wouldn't leave your current job.
Re:Why Web3? by maybecrypto on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @07:27PM (#29731977)
I think the current token prices are a bubble, but I think the space itself is here to stay.
Re:Why Web3? by unicornmama on Thursday December 30, 2021 @04:07AM (#29735032)
Wish you luck on making piles of cash.

It’s here to stay? Care to share your thoughts?

Re:Why Web3? by ThomPete on Thursday December 30, 2021 @06:37AM (#29735895)
if the space is here to stay so is the token price, in fact we haven't even begun seeing the gains as almost no one is in this field yet.
Re:Why Web3? by unicornmama on Thursday December 30, 2021 @06:45AM (#29735945)
Do you get paid to write these fluff pieces?
Re:Why Web3? by cam0 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @07:45PM (#29732113)
A lot of VC firms just raised huge funds that likely have a ~10yr lifespan, and they're going to need to invest that money, so I think this whole web3 thing could actually last a long time. Retail traders buying fractions of a single bitcoin and all the memecoins will likely get squashed though.
Re:Why Web3? by ThomPete on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @06:52PM (#29731669)
Talent doesn't have problem making money, talent is attracted to interesting problems and id attracting the money. Wonder at what point you will concede that you are wrong about this if 13 years isn't long enough to prove its not a bubble.
Re:Why Web3? by unicornmama on Thursday December 30, 2021 @03:52AM (#29734961)
> Talent doesn't have problem making money

No where else in my career have I seen senior level engineers earn 7 figures.

> talent is attracted to interesting problems and id attracting the money

First part is fair, top engineers are passionate about solving challenges.

Second part not so much. How can you explain that “interesting problems” is an efficient capital allocation strategy?

Money is interested in making more money. Here’s an alternate hypothesis: Every few decades a bubble appears. VCs which know their history dust off their bubble playbooks and enter close to the ground floor. But this time is different because they also got to dust of the century old playbook on unregulated financial markets.

> 13 years isn't long enough to prove its not a bubble.

Your argument is upside down. BTC has had 13 years and is complete failure. ETH came out 6 years ago but so far the DeFi space has not provided a single useful application that touches the real economy. Today we have a basket case of post-ETH decentralized compute and storage platform options that have not produced a single killer app.

Your argument is upside down. If ETH had launched in 2020 instead of 2015, we could argue for more time to try out a product market fit. But the more years of r&d without a killer app, the more confidence that it’s a bubble.

Re:Why Web3? by ThomPete on Thursday December 30, 2021 @06:41AM (#29735917)
If BTC is your idea of a failure, being the catalyst for a +2 trillion dollar industry, then i guess failure isnt bad at all. Again you are just claiming things ignoring everything else. Lifes too short for haters. good luck
Re:Why Web3? by unicornmama on Thursday December 30, 2021 @06:44AM (#29735941)
Your arguments, much like your head, are full of hot air.
Re:Why Web3? by ThomPete on Thursday December 30, 2021 @02:08PM (#29740151)
Ahh the last stage of loosing an argument. Personal insults. As I said, good luck.
Re:Why Web3? by unicornmama on Sunday January 02, 2022 @12:47PM (#29771235)
I have no problem handing out personal insults to those who deserve them. Especially fraudsters.