News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Web3? by Apocryphon on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:30PM (#29727988)
Wouldn’t an open database lead to loads of ACID issues or is the point of blockchain to prevent that
Re:Why Web3? by jshen on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:39PM (#29728139)
It’s a very limited database that is very slow and scales poorly.
Re:Why Web3? by ehsankia on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:54PM (#29730570)
Not only that, but every operation would cost fees, right?

Good luck convincing people that every time they logging into their account or literally do any action will cost them some fees. Refreshed the page? Oops that'll cost ya!

Re:Why Web3? by threeseed on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @06:11PM (#29731349)
No you see they will have a cache in front of it.

And then eventually that cache will be a database.

And then eventually that database will have some additional data.

And then eventually we will back to where we are today.

Re:Why Web3? by capableweb on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:46PM (#29728264)
The currently most popular implementation of this "open database" (Bitcoin) is indeed slow and scales poorly. But if you start looking into the new ideas, you'll find there are plenty of still decentralized blockchains with much faster confirmation times (even as low as 5 seconds) today.
Re:Why Web3? by jshen on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:32PM (#29728984)
5 seconds is a long time, especially when a normal modern tech stack can do the same things in milliseconds. I'd also love a reference showing that any of these chains can handle 100k requests per second with a latency of a few seconds. I've never seen it.
Re:Why Web3? by kevinak on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:04PM (#29730013)
The amount of space in a Bitcoin block is around 7 TPS.

Other blockchains make decentralization tradeoffs to process more transactions on-chain per second. For example, Ethereum requires better hardware: larger storage, better CPU and more memory. Solana makes even larger tradeoffs: expensive server hardware costing up to $25000, making it pretty much a central service controlled by the few.

The key innovation of Bitcoin is the decentralization; almost anyone can participate and no one can control it. Sacrificing this for negligble is not worth it. Especially since there are smarter ways to scale the system. Even if you could improve throughput by 100x by making the system slightly less decentralized you would still not reach VISA levels of TPS.

The correct way to scale these systems is using off-chain solutions like the Lightning Network. This way you can process millions of transactions per second.

Re:Why Web3? by endisneigh on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:46PM (#29728276)
Which coins have confirmation times that low with the volume of Bitcoin?
Re:Why Web3? by capableweb on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:57PM (#29728458)
The volume has nothing to do with the confirmation time, it's a constant no matter if it's 1 or 10000 transactions. Avalanche, Algorand, Polygon and more fits the bill of very fast transactions, in case you're interested in looking into the matter further.
Re:Why Web3? by jshen on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:33PM (#29729002)
Nothing can promise constant performance at infinite volume. 10,000 transactions are a tiny number for most modern and popular products these days.
Re:Why Web3? by drawkbox on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:51PM (#29728343)
Further, open databases will potentially make it harder for iterative change on that data.

Structures and versioning become harder when that is distributed at the protocol/standard level. Right now the web is already distributed, the protocols/standards are open and versioning data/content/apps/endpoints on top of that is easy, but updating protocols/standards takes time. Apps are a second layer to that, versioning is harder as you have to roll out updates and the OSs/standards they are built on are the slower changing part, web3 is even harder as updates and versioning of the protocol/standards AND the data/content on top will need to propagate and there may be pushback and splits/forks as we are seeing ETH being difficult to change core protocols/flows. There may be innovations on this as we go but also turbulence until that is realized.

For some areas like personal data and ledger data not changing much is good. For anything beyond that it makes it harder to change. Versioning and iterative change is already difficult in some cases when a company has full control over the structures. Getting multiple companies to agree on standards is harder, especially when that impacts revenues on those systems. The same will happen with web3 maybe more intensely. Right now even open standards are actively killed off because they share data. Right now "web2" could have shared databases, and there are some, but companies push away from that and actively look to own data which is a problem. However the same will happen with web3 at additional levels including the protocols/standards now.

What may happen is APIs public facades/interfaces/signatures are more atomic/stable and less changing which is always nice to have, with the guts of the structures being more keyed/document data formats. I am always a fan of iterative change that doesn't nuke the public interfaces/facades unless absolutely necessary. It may lead to "cleaner" more generic public interfaces potentially, but it may also lead to stagnate iterations and infighting like current web standards. In a way, web3 is more about standards than what is built on it. Standards can be flexible or not, both with their pros and cons.

In a way with cryptocurrency, the real goal of the investors of web3 is recreating the web with a sort of toll system, that can be good and bad but their aim is collecting on actions on new protocols/standards.

Taking control away from companies for important data like personal data and shared public data may be good, but there is also some trouble ahead and many things to work out. The same type of sharks that capture that data are looking to go lower in the stack and control that area, and extracting fees/tolls on the movement in that structure even if it is an open database. There are pros and cons to all of this.

Re:Why Web3? by throw_nbvc1234 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:58PM (#29729940)
> In a way with cryptocurrency, the real goal of the investors of web3 is recreating the web with a sort of toll system, that can be good and bad but their aim is collecting on actions on new protocols/standards.

One could argue that today's web is a combination of ad-based revenue and tolls run by (near?) monopolies: app stores, marketplaces, ect... The crypto-like alternatives such as substack and patreon are growing though and will likely have a niche even if/when crypto fails. The centralization of those crypto-like alternatives is a risk though. I recall one substack author giving email-export as a rationale to choose substack but that's a feature that presumably could just be turned off whenever.

Re:Why Web3? by Apocryphon on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:56PM (#29730607)
What makes these alternatives "crypto-like" other than being less centralized? Are they even less centralized, other than being platforms owned by smaller corporations that choose to (for now) exercise a lighter touch?