News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is there life after death? John Cleese discusses with pan... by cblconfederate on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @02:34AM (#29711404)
Only if you preserve or scan your brain
Re:Is there life after death? John Cleese discusses with pan... by andy_ppp on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @02:38AM (#29711427)
You’re just a set of weights and biases right?
Re:Is there life after death? John Cleese discusses with pan... by tasty_freeze on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @03:18AM (#29711615)
I don't see a sarcasm tag, so I'll assume you are being straight.

No, things are far more complex than that. Perhaps, knowing the connectivity of all the connections and the "weights" of excitation and inhibition one could model the short term behavior of the brain it came from.

But brains aren't static -- they learn and grow and remodel; they have all kinds of feedback loops (eg metabolic and hormonal); their response to conditions is undoubtedly far more complex than "fire if the sum of the weighted inputs is above a certain threshold".

Re:Is there life after death? John Cleese discusses with pan... by blovescoffee on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @11:11AM (#29715007)
I’m not sure your rebuttal is sufficient. Weights and biases in the form of a neural network aren’t static either. Deep Reinforcement Learning algorithms exhibit learning and growing. Besides who says complexity is necessary or that ANNs are not complex enough?
Re:Is there life after death? John Cleese discusses with pan... by tasty_freeze on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @02:36PM (#29717085)
The idea being discussed is that a person could live on if the connectivity and weights of the neurons in their brain was captured. "You’re just a set of weights and biases right?"

I pointed out that a brain is dynamic; it depends on the biology of that person, and there are many other control loop mechanisms which are not captured by a network of weights. We aren't "just a set of weights and biases".

As practiced today, neural networks are trained, and then the trained network is statically deployed in recognition tasks or whatever. They aren't continuously evolving. Yes, one can come up with algorithms that retrain and reshape a network continuously, but (and here is the key point) it is very likely to quickly diverge from the changes that the original, organic brain would have made.

Re:Is there life after death? John Cleese discusses with pan... by cblconfederate on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @02:50AM (#29711476)
you would need gene expression and epigenomics too. And still be an approximation, but probably good enough
Re:Is there life after death? John Cleese discusses with pan... by kozikow on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @03:29AM (#29711664)
The "materialism" consciousness theory is primarily what they are arguing against and people in this video gathered lots of solid scientific evidence against it.

If not "brain is a biological computer" then what? We don't know yet, but some things in the right direction are Donald Hoffman's model, Penrose and Hammerhof quantum processing in the brain, Kastrup analytic idealism, maybe it's some form of radio? Authors of this conference through some theories in "beyond physicalism" book.

Re:Is there life after death? John Cleese discusses with pan... by cblconfederate on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @04:47AM (#29712064)
Those are tangents that someone might want to ponder about but i wouldn't want neuroscientists wasting their time looking for mythical quantum qualia.

The biggest question is why people object to a materialist theory of the mind

Re:Is there life after death? John Cleese discusses with pan... by yetihehe on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @04:51AM (#29712082)
And the biggest "hmm" is why/for what reason do we have a specific neuronal circuit/capability to tell us that some god/presence is near us[0]?

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_helmet

Re:Is there life after death? John Cleese discusses with pan... by fivea on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @06:29AM (#29712683)
> And the biggest "hmm" is why/for what reason do we have a specific neuronal circuit/capability to tell us that some god/presence is near us[0]?

I'm not sure you read the article you cited, but it clearly states that the initial claims behind the "god helmet" cannot and could not be independently replicated.

Also, the underlying theory refers to "very weak magnetic fields" that are "as strong as those generated by a land line telephone handset or an ordinary hair dryer". If this had any bearing on reality, the law of large numbers would imply we'd see a relatively large number of people experiencing this effect in the wild in ways that could be replicated and experienced by anyone in the vicinity, which we are not.

So, what leads you to believe that these claims are not made up by either a crackpot or a fraudster?

Re:Is there life after death? John Cleese discusses with pan... by rpastuszak on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @05:44AM (#29712358)
Do we? The theory you mention is widely disputed, plus even the article you shared mentions issues with reproducibility, blinding etc…
Re:Is there life after death? John Cleese discusses with pan... by yetihehe on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @02:24PM (#29716971)
That's why I said "capability". Yes, "god helmet" device may not be really working, but participants were reporting having a feeling (false reading, but a reading nonetheless). I compare it to a broken voltage detector which sometimes show a reading of voltage. That reading suggests there may exist a voltage. Yeah, counterargument could just be a signal of "beware, there is something out there going to kill you" being mistranslated as "there is god out there", but still, "god presence detector" seems to at least exist.
Re:Is there life after death? John Cleese discusses with pan... by 1_player on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @05:44AM (#29712360)
That's a fascinating link, but my materialistic understanding is that the brain is an analogue signal processor, and tries to pattern match incoming signals to known experiences. In this case the input activates the "there is someone with me" signal. Doesn't mean there is.

The brain is not a digital CPU, where every behaviour is a result of specific purpose-made circuitry. There is no "God detector" system in the brain.

Re:Is there life after death? John Cleese discusses with pan... by cblconfederate on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @04:57AM (#29712117)
our brain is the sole source of our thoughts, and most of our thoughts are baseless conjecture.
Re:Is there life after death? John Cleese discusses with pan... by simon_000666 on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @03:42AM (#29711728)
What about the neurons in your heart and gut? The brain isn’t the only place your body has processing capacity.
Re:Is there life after death? John Cleese discusses with pan... by hulitu on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @04:27AM (#29711966)
Those are the peripherals. (i.e. keyboard, usb dongle)
Re:Is there life after death? John Cleese discusses with pan... by oogetyboogety on Thursday December 30, 2021 @08:27PM (#29743797)
A motherboard or SOC's design has a lot to do with the peripherals it's intended to connect with. Interrupts directly influence control logic, for example.