News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Once poor, always poor? by inglor_cz on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:07PM (#29704265)
"One could theorize that the descendants of chattel slavery will have (for example) less family wealth than whites who are descendants of property owners and indentured servants. "

People have even less family wealth in less stable places, plagued by war, genocide, forced expropriation, violent regime changes, state bankruptcies etc. For example, both Germany and Poland were big heaps of rubble in 1945. Nothing to inherit there but destroyed, burnt-out cities.

The 20th century in general was pretty awful outside North America. If bad history was such a universal determinant of future failure or success, the world would be one giant hopeless poverty-stricken hellhole.

Re:Once poor, always poor? by wobblybubble on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:16PM (#29704369)
> People have even less family wealth in less stable places

But we’re comparing whites and blacks in America, so the old “but people are starving in Africa” doesn’t apply here.

So why is there a disparity of family wealth between whites and blacks in America? Any alternative theories? Because “but the bombing of Dresden…!!!” does not explain it.

Re:Once poor, always poor? by inglor_cz on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:38PM (#29704624)
It sort-of does, because America is a country based on immigration and many contemporary Americans, not just white ones, have relatively recent background in poorer, less stable, more violent countries. A lot of people who are now living comfortably are kids or grandkids of parents who came with nothing in their pockets.

As for your question, I do not have any theory. A viable theory would have to explain the variation of the black-white gap across the US.

Looking for data, I found a graph mapping the differences of average black and white income (not wealth) across U.S. states:

https://www.stlouisfed.org/-/media/project/frbstl/stlouisfed...

If racism was the only root explanation, Pennsylvania would be more racist than Georgia and Wisconsin more racist than South Carolina. That does not seem plausible to me.