News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by dredmorbius on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @12:50PM (#2970243)
Money is a wealth transfer medium. If you're familiar with physics, think of exchange particles associated with forces. In biology, it's similar to blood. I'm not sure a transportation analog works but it might (I need to think about that).

Money works when it is exchanged for goods and services.

When money stops moving, the economy "stops". There isn't any exchange going on (or there's far less than before). Economic activity slows, employment slows, etc.

Credit and leverage, done right, allow more work from a given initial money supply (technically, credit increases the money supply), but this is predicated on the borrower repaying the initial investment. Done wrong, credit is extended for activities which don't allow repayment, and not only can't the the interest be paid, but the initial principle is lost -- and the money supply contracts.

Money is not wealth (value imbued in goods/services), but it can be (with a stable currency) a measure of wealth.

If the amount of money in circulation is decreasing (or the real wealth of an economy is increasing relative to a fixed money supply, say, with a gold/silver standard), then the value of a given denomination of coinage increases. Hoarding coin/currency/money becomes a wealth-accruing activity, while facilitating economic activity (by spending money) largely loses wealth. Hence the problem with a highly deflationary currency.

Economic theory says you want a currency whose value tends to be stable, or slightly inflationary, with time, in order to encourage spending rather than saving.

Note that none of this addresses the underlying physical economy, resource limitations/depletion, or other criticisms of traditional orthodox economics (most of which are highly valid -- we live on a planet of limited resources and good planets are both hard to find and the commute is a real drag).

Regarding your comments on savings: yes, there is a well-known "savings paradox" where individual incentives to save are opposed to the overall economic goals of growth. This is one of many such individual/group paradoxes, and is one of the principle reasons for laws (legal, moral, or otherwise). The 1971 book The Logic of Collective Action by Mancur Olson is one of the better illuminations of the concept: http://economics.about.com/cs/macroeconomics/a/logic_of_acti...

There are numerous other conflicts and paradoxes within economic theory and reality. Free markets, where they exist, work quite well. They're rather more rare, I'm coming to believe, than is frequently thought, and many forces work to limit them (political, plutocratic, monopolistic, and others).

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by Amincd on Thursday September 08, 2011 @07:07PM (#2976058)
The quantity of money does not affect its flow.

It's not like exchange particles, where lower densities leads to lower transfer of force. Any quantity of money, as long as it is divisible, can attain a sufficient value to be useful as a store of value. A medium of exchange merely needs to be a store of value.

Because of the lack of dependence of the value of the total money supply on its total quantity, nominal spending declining due to deflation does not reduce real spending and the market is always able to sell of the merchandise on the shelves, with the value of currency adjusting to what is needed to serve the role of store of value in exchange.

What deflation does do is discourage lending. This is a legitimate economic problem, but it's not that pronounced. The Bitcoin economy would have 3% deflation a year if the world adopted it. This is not drastic and would still allow significant lending.

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by narkee on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @10:29PM (#2972398)
Really informative, thanks!
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by dredmorbius on Thursday September 08, 2011 @04:55AM (#2973152)
You're welcome. I'm not going to claim great insight (yet), I'm still stumbling through this stuff myself (and have been for 25 years).

Other than Mancur Olsen, some of the more interesting reading I've found includes George Akerlof ("The Market for Lemons"), Garrett Hardin ("Lifeboat Ethics", "Tragedy of the Commons", and several books of essays), Neal Stephenson's Baroque Cycle (a cunningly disguised treatise on the emergence of stock corporations, banking, and modern finance and capital), Niall Fergusson's The Ascent of Money (a less cunningly disguised version of same), and The Ordinary Business of Life which is dry as dust but still a wonderful exposition of 3000 years of economic thought.

A book I've just heard of but haven't read is David Graeber's Debt: The First 5,000 Years. He's a radical anthropologist, but has some really keen insights and views on the formation of credit and money (guess which came first).