News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by justicezyx on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:08PM (#29676706)
Ms. Tsai is a skillful politician. Her success primarily lies on the adoption and the adept use of identity politics in Taiwan.

Despite a long history of national linkage with mainland China, Taiwan, under the colonization and brutal cultural and economic transformation by Japan invasion in the early 20 century till the end of WWII, have gone through a heart breaking separation from the homeland.

Ms. Tsai, just like her mentor, Mr. Lee Teng-hui are heavily influenced by liberal Democratic political ideology, and refined that with a modern form that is closer to western worlds. Mr. Lee Teng-hui represents a more Japanese heritage. And because of his disillusioned passion for communism, Lee had been a communist, and got bullied by KMT after the retreat.

Ms. Tsai led a whirlwind of political ascension through labeling "本省人” “外省人” political identities. Where she also mastered the online propaganda toolings eg the 1450 army (https://zh.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E7%B6%B2%E7%B5%A1%E6%89%93%...). Mrs. Tsai's domestic policy heavily rely on trade economic value for political ties like importing US pork with additive that are known to have harm to human https://zh.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E7%B6%B2%E7%B5%A1%E6%89%93%... And cultivation of national pride to distance the Taiwan island from mainland, and make the island more prestigious and similar to a national body. Like the so-called "advanced vaccine" by Taiwan's own Rd center https://www.dw.com/zh/%E5%8F%B0%E6%B9%BE%E5%BC%80%E6%89%93%E... these vaccines are rushed to public without adequate testing, and caused higher than usual death.

Ms. Tsai obviously has no adherence to the international law that recognize Taiwan as a part of China. And many Taiwan politicians are fearful of joining China for historical reasons. They even rejected Jiang Zeming's offer to retain it's own military and civil government, by just recognizing formally the CCP led central government, literally a federated nation.

Unfortunately, Taiwan's cultural linkage to China is weak. And the mainland is gearing towards a coercive reunification in some form that is appropriate to China's economic and political consideration. I.e., If China continue to grow and surpass US in all major aspects of national strength, Taiwan can keep this state indefinitely, as China does not really care that much when it becomes a more powerful US. But US won't allow that, global hegemony is a zero sum game, the loss of that status will destroy US financial industry, for an example of the consequence. And Taiwan for her self proclaimed high vision of independence, is heading into a dead end. As a weakening China will be more hostile to the island, Taiwan, in its own pursuit of some potlical value, will bring ruin to the island, probably bundled with significant damage to the mainland. Meanwhile, US would righteously declare the victory of democracy, and say nothing about the human suffering in the conflict, and exploit the economic loot afterwards.

In the end, I'll support the growth of China in all aspects of national power. Hopefully a better version of US can born from that. I'll do my best to influence the Western audience about the more complicated aspect of Taiwan issue, to broaden their view about alternatives than just the black and white democracy vs xxxx (authoritarian dictatorship swap any of your favorite words on China).

The US led world order is simply not going to sustain, everyone needs to understand not only US cannot make an example of the right and good, US no longer have the means other than destruction in shaping other nations' fate.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by yumraj on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:38PM (#29677506)
> In the end, I'll support the growth of China in all aspects of national power.

If you're a Citizen of the Mainland China, then I'll support your right to support your nation and its current CCP Government, even if I disagree with it.

However, if you're a resident/citizen of a Western nation and earning your livelihood there, I'll encourage you to take another look at the whole situation and decide for yourself if CCP model and its behavior towards other nations and even its own minorities is really the right model for any country, let alone China.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by justicezyx on Monday December 27, 2021 @11:33PM (#29710448)
> I'll encourage you to take another look at the whole situation and decide for yourself if CCP model and its behavior towards other nations and even its own minorities is really the right model for any country, let alone China.

Yes, I did that every single day. This is just what I currently feel. My perception might change. BTW, I am a Chinese living in US.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by thoughtstheseus on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:19PM (#29676818)
This comment is straight bunk. Anyone truly curious should seek out primary sources from actual people living in Taiwan.
[dead]
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by rectang on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:04PM (#29677218)
The HN policy is that we're supposed to assume people are not paid shills.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

> Please don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, brigading, foreign agents and the like. It degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about abuse, email [email protected] and we'll look at the data.

In the case of articles touching on China, though, this is hard. We will never hear the perspectives of Chinese nationals who disagree with the CCP line, even if they reside outside of China, because they will be reported and their loved ones will face fearsome punishments. So HN "debate" is polluted because only one side is let through, regardless of whether those espousing the CCP line have any formal relationship with the CCP.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by newbear1 on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:30PM (#29677423)
The logical reasoning is starting lacking, and the preassumptions are equally entrenched.

> We will never hear the perspectives of Chinese nationals who disagree with the CCP line

This is not true. Watch Radio Free Asian, the epoch times, and many indenpent Chinese dissident channels on YouTube like Mr. Jiang Feng (https://youtube.com/c/%E6%B1%9F%E5%B3%B0%E6%97%B6%E5%88%BB). These are mostly Chinese speaking content. You of course can find a lot of English content of western media interviewing Chinese dissident.

> they will be reported and their loved ones will face fearsome punishments.

Another slander by western Media about the social situation in China. Essentialy, the media wants to paint the Chinese soceity as inhuman, and incapable of rational thinking. That of course becomes a nice subconscious justification of violence towards them, like what happened in the colonial era by White colonists to justify their policy towards Indians.

Chinese do not report their friends and family. The might expose by standers occasionally, online. But again that's not too different from someone got cancelled here.

> polluted because only one side is let through

The one sided part is the negative and inhuman side of China right?

Think yourself for a moment the slanders some IDs received when they advanced a contrararian view on China with seemingly plausible backings, and the unanimous views that portrait a unjust and inhuman Chinese society.

If you think the one-sided part is the positive part, then it bears explanation that how someone stating objective truth got slandered repetitively without any factual counterparts.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by rectang on Friday December 24, 2021 @11:22PM (#29680366)
> The might expose by standers occasionally, online.

That sounds like a terrifying threat to anyone who might post on this page who has loved ones within the reach of the CCP.

The number of people who should be reported to any government for criticizing it is zero. If there are laws against criticizing the government, such laws are unjust.

> The one sided part is the negative and inhuman side of China right?

Not China. The CCP.

[dead]
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by rectang on Saturday December 25, 2021 @01:57AM (#29681120)
> I said online.

> That's not to government.

We already know that promise is empty, having witnessed numerous incidents on American college campuses where CCP loyalists were watching and reporting those deemed disloyal to the government.

> CCP represents the nation. There is no clear separation from the ruling body vs. the nation.

The CCP wants there to be no distinction because they want those who oppose the CCP to be seen as enemies of the Chinese people and Chinese culture. I do not accept that. I am not an enemy of the Chinese people. We are all humans. Furthermore, I regard those Chinese people who struggle against CCP oppression as called upon by our times to exhibit greater courage than I will ever display in my life, and I have the greatest admiration and respect for them.

Re:The leader who's standing up to China by orhmeh09 on Friday December 24, 2021 @04:23PM (#29677858)
Radio Free Asia is a propaganda outlet run by and for the US government and it used to be attached to the US state department: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Agency_for_Global_Media
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by lucian1900 on Friday December 24, 2021 @06:11PM (#29678689)
The Epoch Times is run by the Falun Gong, a far right cult funded by the US.
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by dh5 on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:15PM (#29676765)
Here comes the 50 cent army
Re:The leader who's standing up to China by akomtu on Friday December 24, 2021 @05:13PM (#29678275)
I have to disagree. The comment above uses proper English, proper formatting, cites sources where appropriate. That's a 5 dollar comment at the very least.